Fri 16 Jan 2015
A 1001 Midnights Review: FRANKLIN BANDY – Deceit and Deadly Lies.
Posted by Steve under 1001 Midnights , Authors , Reviews[5] Comments
by Marcia Muller
FRANKLIN BANDY – Deceit and Deadly Lies. Charter, paperback original, 1978.
Kevin Maclnnes is known as the “Lie King.” A specialist with the Psychological Stress Evaluator (lie detector), he makes a living by taking voice readings of people and assessing their truthfulness. For a handsome fee, he will aid any client — governmental or private — in a situation where getting at the truth is paramount; and the fee goes to support his elegant but enigmatic mistress, Vanessa.
One of the subjects Maclnnes is asked to evaluate is brought to him by a New York assistant district attorney; the client is a cabby who claims to have overheard two men talking about an assassination plot, something “really big.” The man apparently is telling the truth, and Maclnnes, spurred by a combination of patriotism (he is a former army officer) and curiosity, aids the authorities by embarking on a search for one of the men described — a search that nearly costs him his lover and his life.
Maclnnes is interesting, and so is his work. In the course of the novel, he aids a businessman in making a low bid on a tract of land (and suffers sleepless nights when the seller kills himself); rigs a voice test in such a way as to prove a battered wife accidentally killed her husband (he knows she is really guilty, and he loses sleep over that, too); helps a wealthy Mexican family find where the killer of their young son has hidden his body; and bugs a bedroom conversation between himself and his mistress to evaluate whether she really loves him.
The uncertain relationship with Vanessa is a thread through the story, as are Maclnnes’s fears about misusing his skills.
For all its merits, this novel could stand to be about 100 pages shorter. It is padded with Harold Robbins-like descriptions of expensive clothing, hotels, gourmet meals, and brand names of liquors and wines.
There is also a gratuitous side trip into Maclnnes’s attempt to cure a temporary bout of impotence with a call girl, which causes us to lose track of the main focus of the narrative — finding out who is to be assassinated and stopping the killers. But on the whole, it’s a good rainy day book for those who like their settings luxurious and their characters sophisticated, if a trifle stereotypical.
This novel won the MWA Edgar for Best Paperback Original of 1978. In addition, Franklin Bandy has written The Blackstock Affair (1980) and The Farewell Party (1980).
———
Reprinted with permission from 1001 Midnights, edited by Bill Pronzini & Marcia Muller and published by The Battered Silicon Dispatch Box, 2007. Copyright © 1986, 2007 by the Pronzini-Muller Family Trust.
Bibliographic Notes: The Blackstock Affair was the second and final recorded adventure of Kevin MacInnes. Bandy, who died in 1987, also wrote a book called The Shannonese Hustle (1978) and as Eugene Franklin (his first and middle names), three books in a series of cases solved by Berkeley Barnes and Larry Howe, about whom I know nothing.
January 16th, 2015 at 7:57 pm
This is a book from way back then that I do remember reading and reviewing, and I think Marcia Muller and I agree on its merits almost totally.
I also remembering wondering why this book won an Edgar. The book was interesting but had nothing else to make it stand out above the rest of the pack of ordinary-but-fun-to-read books at the time. I may do some research on this and see if I can’t find out what the other nominees were.
January 16th, 2015 at 8:07 pm
What would we do without the Google? From the Thrilling Detective website, I learned almost immediately that regarding the Eugene Franklin books: “Here’s another spin on the Nero Wolfe/Archie Goodwin formula. BERKELEY HOY BARNES is a New York hypochondriac, and former lawyer turned private eye, who really doesn’t like meeting people he doesn’t know. He relies on LARRY HOWE to do his legwork, and keep track of his medication.”
Why I didn’t know that, I don’t know. I think I should have.
January 16th, 2015 at 8:32 pm
I likely passed on this because of the ‘lie detector’ thing, a total fantasy that usually only proves you aren’t smart enough to fool the machine. Rich glamorous lie detector operators may have been too far out for me.
Doesn’t really sound like Edgar material.
The Franklin books sound a bit better, but I don’t think I’ll indulge this either.
January 16th, 2015 at 9:23 pm
I remember reading one or more of the Eugene Franklin books, but that’s all I remember. I kind of enjoyed Deceit and Deadly Lies, and in fact I was just looking at my copy the other day and wondering about rereading it. Now I guess I won’t.
January 16th, 2015 at 9:48 pm
You might want to reconsider, Bill, once I tell you that back in 1980 I read and reviewed the second book in the series, and I posted the review here.
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=22023
I don’t remember either the review or that I posted it on this blog, but there it is, and my original rating was an A minus. This is kind of surprising in another way, too, since what I had to say in the review does’t seem to be leading to such a high rating, but there it is, in black and white. I also mentioned DECEIT in passing, and I seem to have liked that one too.
I also brought up NYC PI Berkeley Barnes and his “Archie,†Larry Howe, so I knew about them then. I was much younger, too.
I discovered this earlier review while researching the other Edgar nominees the year that Bandy won. Here they are:
° Stud Game by David Anthony
° The Switch by Elmore Leonard
° Heartstone by Philip Margolin
° Charnel House by Graham Masterton
Interesting, am I right?