Thu 22 Jan 2015
A ROY ROGERS Western Movie Review by Jonathan Lewis: DOWN DAKOTA WAY (1949).
Posted by Steve under Reviews , Western movies[2] Comments
DOWN DAKOTA WAY. Republic Pictures, 1949. Roy Rogers, Trigger, Dale Evans, Pat Brady, Montie Montana, Elisabeth Risdon, Byron Barr, James Cardwell, Roy Barcroft, Foy Willing & the Riders of the Purple Sage. Screenplay: John K. Butler & Sloan Nibley. Director: William Witney.
Full disclosure: I’m definitely a William Witney aficionado. Plus, out of all the singing cowboys, I like Roy Rogers the best. After recently watching Under California Stars, which I reviewed here, I had moderately high expectations for Down Dakota Way. At the very least, I thought it would be an overall fun movie watching experience. In that sense, I was somewhat mistaken.
Now, it’s not as if Down Dakota Way is a terrible movie or that the direction is necessarily of sub-par quality. No, it’s just that the movie lacks that real, but difficult to describe in words, sense of fun, lighthearted, escapism. In many ways, Down Dakota Way has all the characteristics of a dark, brooding, Hamlet-on-horseback Western but without the excellent acting and brilliant cinematography that make many “Western noirs†truly outstanding films.
In this entry in the vast Roy Rogers cinematic corpus, Rogers ends up doing battle with a corrupt cattle baron willing to employ criminal methods to cover up the widespread presence of foot and mouth disease among his stock. Complicating matters is the fact that one of the baron’s hired gunmen, a ruthless little piece of work, happens to be the adopted son of Roy’s favorite childhood schoolteacher. Since the gunman’s father was also a criminal, there’s a bit of a morality play in this somewhat forgettable Western, a didactic lesson about raising your children right and not judging sons for the sins of their fathers.
Still, when all is said and done, Down Dakota Way really just isn’t all that captivating. For a Witney-directed film, I’d expected some better rough and tumble fight choreography. That, too, was sadly lacking.
January 23rd, 2015 at 7:13 pm
This is an interesting review.
Suggestion: maybe you might want to do a series of posts, about your favorite five Roy Rogers films.
I’ve hardly seen any movies with Roy. Used to watch his TV show as a kid. So did everyone in our neighborhood.
Some of Witney’s episodes for THE VIRGINIAN tv show are good.
January 23rd, 2015 at 7:16 pm
At this point in his career Roy’s films took on an almost noir quality, and became much more violent, but the best of them are the best films he did, BELLS OF SAN ANGELO and MY PAL TRIGGER among them. Not this one so much.
But like the earliest films he did this is a bit darker than those near musical comedy pictures made during the war and just after like DON’T FENCE ME IN. Roy and the plots are much tougher, though in fairness the same thing happened with Gene Autry when he moved to Columbia after the war.
They were looking for an edge, and for a short time found it.