Mon 13 Feb 2017
A Western Movie Review by Jonathan Lewis: GUN THE MAN DOWN (1956).
Posted by Steve under Reviews , Western movies[3] Comments
GUN THE MAN DOWN. United Artists / Batjac Productions, 1956. James Arness, Angie Dickinson, Emile Meyer, Robert Wilke, Harry Carey Jr., Michael Emmet. Director: Andrew V. McLaglen.
I had somewhat high hopes for Gun The Man Down. Not only is it a Batjac film — John Wayne’s production company — but it also features Gunsmoke star James Arness in a leading role. Sadly, I came away disappointed and, truth be told, somewhat frustrated at what clearly could have been a much better revenge story.
Arness portrays Rem Andersen, a man who stupidly decides to throw his lot in with a bank robber duo. When their first bank job together goes awry, Rem ends up wounded and at the mercy of law enforcement. The brains of the operation, Matt Rankin (Robert Wilke) not only gets away with the loot, but also rides away with Rem’s girl, Janice (Angie Dickinson). After spending a year in jail, Rem decides to get even with those who betrayed him. Standing in his path is not only a gunfighter named Billy Deal, but also a small town sheriff (Emile Meyer) and his deputy (Harry Carey, Jr.) Truth be told, none of the characters apart from these latter two are particularly compelling.
Although it starts off with promise and is well photographed and competently staged, Gun The Man Down simply never rises above its formulaic and mediocre plot. Even worse, the film eventually bogs down in a poorly lit night gunfight, a sequence which not only lasts far too long, but one that doesn’t give the viewer ample opportunity to even decipher what’s going on. Not that it really matters much, given how low the stakes seem to be in this rather uninteresting tale featuring a protagonist who is incredibly difficult to root for.
February 13th, 2017 at 10:06 pm
I wonder if this was Arness consolation prize for Duke selling his contract to television for GUNSMOKE.
February 13th, 2017 at 10:57 pm
Unfortunately this movie was no prize. Both Arness and Dickinson were miscast, and the story makes no sense. Luckily for Arness, the TV series led to something. This movie never would have.
February 7th, 2018 at 3:48 pm
Watched it last night and came away with a much higher opinion of it. McLaglen’s direction won’t take any prizes, but I found Kennedy’s screenplay quite engaging.