Fri 13 Oct 2017
Reviewed by Barry Gardner: CAMILLA T. CRESPI – The Trouble with Thin Ice.
Posted by Steve under Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Characters , Reviews[2] Comments
CAMILLA T. CRESPI – The Trouble with Thin Ice. Simona Griffo #4. HarperCollins, hardcover, 1993; paperback, 1994. iUniverse, trade paperback, July 2003.
This is the fourth in this series, but it’s my first, and it almost wasn’t that. When I read the description of Griffo is “an ad exec … who loves to cook and solve murders” I nearly wimped out right there. Then I thought, well, maybe it’s the copywriter here who’s an idiot and not the writer. Let’s see.
Simona and her New York Detective lover (and his 14 year old son) are spending Christmas in Connecticut, where a black friend of theirs is marrying a white man, and the couple is buying one of the town’s old mansions. The lady selling it to them is a member of the tows ruling class, and her announcement of the sale at dinner is greeted with something less than pleasure and acceptance.
The same night she is drowned in an icy pond, and the bride-to-be is arrested for the murder. Simona’s lover is called away by a family injury, and she and the son are left to soldier one.
It should be noted that there’s at least one facet of the book of which I heartily approve: a Cast of Characters at the beginning which should be de rigueur for any story with over five characters.
Praise ends here. The blurb was right — Simona really does love to (*gag*) cook and solve murders. This is a better written version of the nonsense that people like Mary Daheim and Valerie Wolzien perpetrate, and while I recognize that there are those who like such, their rationale remains incomprehensible to me.
I like my fiction to either be amusing or about people and premises that I can at least temporarily believe in, and neither of these attributes is in the slightest evidence here.
The Simona Griffo series —
As by Trella Crespi:
The Trouble with a Small Raise. Zebra 1991.
The Trouble with Moonlighting. Zebra 1991.
The Trouble with Too Much Sun. Zebra 1992.
As by Camilla T. Crespi:
The Trouble with Thin Ice. Harper 1993.
The Trouble with Going Home. Harper 1995.
The Trouble with a Bad Fit. Harper 1996.
The Trouble with a Hot Summer. Harper 1997.
October 14th, 2017 at 12:37 am
I don’t think Barry would be pleased to know that in my local Barnes and Noble there is a separate section for cozies just like this one, taking up over a third of the overall area for mysteries. I don’t know for sure but I suspect that most of them are not as good as this one.
October 15th, 2017 at 12:08 am
Whatever else, Barry nailed it.