Sun 24 Nov 2019
A TV Series Review by Mike Tooney: THE ORVILLE (2017- )..
Posted by Steve under Reviews , TV Science Fiction & Fantasy[5] Comments
THE ORVILLE. TV series. Season 1. (Fox; 2017; 12 episodes, 43-45 minutes); Season 2 (Fox; 2018-19; 14 episodes, 48 minutes); Season 3 (Fox and Hulu; announced for late 2020). Regular Cast: Seth MacFarlane, Adrianne Palicki, Penny Johnson Jerald, Scott Grimes, Peter Macon, Halston Sage (Seasons 1 and 2), J. Lee, Mark Jackson, and Jessica Szohr (Season 2). Creator: Seth MacFarlane. Theme music: Bruce Broughton. Executive producers: Seth MacFarlane, Brannon Braga, David A. Goodman, Jason Clark, Jon Favreau, (pilot), Liz Heldens (Season 1), and Jon Cassar (Season 2). Production companies: Fuzzy Door Productions and Fox.
Imagine that you’re a trained spaceship captain with a promising career ahead of you. Imagine that one night you date a cute space navy officer but make a mess of it; the next day you sheepishly beg her forgiveness, she gives it, and agrees to another date. (Neither of you realize it at the time, but that second date will prove to be all-important, and not just on a personal level.)
Eventually the two of you get married, but one afternoon you come home and find her in bed with another man, leading to Divorceville and your career taking a year-long nosedive. Things are looking grim when unexpectedly the higher-ups pick you to captain a new exploratory vessel. You eagerly take command, only to discover that your new executive officer is your ex-wife …
Not only is having to deal with his ex a challenge for Captain Ed Mercer of The Orville, but there’s also the oddball crew he’s given, among them a member of an all-male race (“It is much easier with an egg”), a five-foot-nothing security officer who can knock down reinforced steel doors with her bare hands (“I’m actually just sort of working on myself right now”), a couple of conceited bridge crewmen (“One time I almost died because I humped a statue”), a giant blob of gelatin (“I gotta say, watching your corpse drift away to this music would be so peaceful”), and an artificial life form who thinks an amputation would make a good practical joke (“The penchant for biological lifeforms to anthropomorphize inanimate objects is irrational”).
And that’s basically the set-up in Seth MacFarlane’s The Orville, a TV series that, as the saying goes, has garnered a cult following, starting first as a network product and then migrating to a subscription video on demand service, with its cult following . . . following. (How many people constitute a cult, anyhow? Never mind.)
If you go to the movies much, you’ve innocently become enmeshed in the latest Hollywood “trend” (more like a nostalgia goldrush) in churning out sequels, prequels, “reimaginings,” and reboots. (Not all remakes, by the way, are a bad thing; John Huston’s excellent 1941 reboot of The Maltese Falcon was the third attempt at filming it, one which succeeded very nicely.)
We view this trend as an admission that they’ve run out of steam and aren’t even trying to be creative, never mind original. Complicating an already bad situation is the unmistakable messianic zeal with which the Tinsel Town elites are willing to cram their brand of political pontificating down unsuspecting audiences’ throats, even if their projects lose them money. (Someone somewhere once observed that in Hollywood influence and ego gratification — embodied in their lay sermons, movies — are the orgasm and money the aphrodisiac, the stimulus by which they achieve satisfaction.) Indeed, until a month ago we had never heard the term “woke” applied to motion picture and television productions, but to a greater or lesser degree just about everything emerging from Tinsel Town seems to have some component of “wokeness” to it.
But we digress. In just about all aspects of art training (and, whatever you may think of them, we can include movie and TV production as art), beginners are encouraged to emulate previous masters in their field, to copy them with an eye to developing their own unique styles later on.
… which brings us back to The Orville. Seth MacFarlane, the executive producer, writer, director, star, and who knows what else on this TV series has taken the normal art training paradigm and junked it. Every single aspect of this show is derived from somewhere else, intentionally so. If you are familiar with S*** T*** (because the latest series producers are a prickly lot, we feel it safer to employ the asterisks), viewing any given episode of The Orville should provoke a feeling of deja vu. Situations, characters, whole plotlines, musical cues, even individual shots are lifted primarily from S*** T***, with S*** W*** and a random collection of components from a bunch of other sci-fi sources, as well.
Everyone has a unique gift; MacFarlane’s gift is in NOT being original (his tiresome cartoon shows demonstrate that) but in being a copycat, the best copycat on the Hollywood scene at the moment. In The Orville, he has done a remarkable thing by blurring the formerly clear-cut distinction between parody and pastiche, the result being a thing unto itself, funny, serious, derivative all at once. For that alone, MacFarlane deserves some sort of Major Award.
Is the series “woke”? Oh yeah. According to what we’ve read, MacFarlane has already received a Major Award, this one from a group of like-minded people who probably wouldn’t object if authorities prosecuted parents as child abusers for providing religious instruction to their children; since very few artists ever alter their deeply felt attitudes (indeed, they constantly draw on them for inspiration), we can expect to see the consequences of that particular frame of mind to continually play out in the series, especially with respect to The Orville‘s continuing “bad guys,” a bone-headed race of aliens whose sole motivation is to murder anyone who doesn’t conform to their religion. (Bone heads. Get it?) Like its S*** T*** predecessors, in this show any person or random cactus that entertains the faintest glimmering of spirituality is automatically a moron in desperate need of rationalist enlightenment. (A case can be made that the science fiction subgenre of literature is the primary conveyance of atheist thought today, but while that might make for a thrilling Ph.D. thesis, we just don’t have the time.)
In spite of what you’ve just read, is it possible to like The Orville? The special effects are excellent; the plots, while totally derivative, mesh nicely with the characters; and the acting is uniformly very good (Scott Grimes’s performance in his story with a simulated woman being Major Award-worthy).
Perhaps the best way for someone who still clings to Middle American values (any of you still left out there?) to fully enjoy The Orville would involve assuming a posture in which index finger and thumb are firmly placed against the proboscis. Everybody else will cheerfully overlook the subtexts and uncritically swallow MacFarlane’s spoonful of sugar. (You remember Mary Poppins, don’t you? “A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down, The medicine go down-wown …”)
November 24th, 2019 at 7:44 pm
I’ve never heard of this series, but if it’s as derivative as you say, could The Orville and its crew have been inspired by Ark Fleet Ship B of Golgafrincham? The two sound very like each other.
November 24th, 2019 at 9:39 pm
It is a send up of STAR TREK and a very good one if you like send ups or think TREK needed some of its pomposity sent up. If you don’t you won’t like it.
I believe there is a third season coming so it has some success.
Its creator and and star aside I can’t say I found it more than moderately political as satire goes, and certainly not an assault on Middle Class values any more than many series are if taken that way. The characters are all meant to be send ups of common tropes in SF series and films, and it takes on TREK much the way the Tim Allen’s film did, with a certain fondness.
It’s nowhere near as dark as say RED DWARF or as silly as QUARK, and in the best episodes it manages to both send up TREK and capture some of the fun of the original, and that is rare in any send up. That some episodes work as both a fond send up and at the same time a good adventure story is a rarity, though that quality is not consistent.
I’m more a drop in viewer than a regular, but it has its moments.
November 24th, 2019 at 11:57 pm
THE ORVILLE is an attempt to mock the tired tropes of SF so originality would be counter-productive.
MacFarland created FAMILY GUY with the same sense of humor a decade or so ago and his sense of humor has not changed.
There have been around 500 original TV series on the air during the 2018-19 season. When demand is higher than supply (not only for number of ideas but for talent and writers as well) TV has responded with remakes.
In the beginning of TV, the networks turned to the radio series as the networks owned the rights and it was easier to remake proven audience favorite DUFFY’S TAVERN as a TV series than create something out of nothing.
During the cable explosion in the 80s-00s there were enough remakes of old TV series from GET SMART to COLUMBO to ADAM 12 for a book about them, TELEVISION SERIES REVIVALS, SEQUELS, REMAKES OF CANCELLED SHOWS. It was released in 1993 and written by Lee Goldberg.
Mike, the broadcast networks are dead. If you don’t expand your choices to cable and streaming you really have no right to claim TV is creatively limited. When one of the best original TV sf ever, THE EXPANSE exists you can’t complain about a lack of originality on TV just because you won’t look beyond networks that do stuff like THE ORVILLE.
BTW my definition of a TV cult series is a TV series judged less by the number of viewers than the loyalty of a small group of intense fans that refuse to let go of the series.
November 25th, 2019 at 4:17 am
I had heard of this series before Mike sent me his review, but that’s all. I enjoyed the video clips I found to add to it, but I’m not sure how long I could withstand (if that’s the right word) a steady diet of spoofery such as this.
Dropping in once in a while might be just what the doctor ordered, but all in all, I probably won’t.
November 25th, 2019 at 7:41 am
I dislike MacFarlane – worst Oscar host ever – and I hate the trope (see every tornado/hurricane/other disaster movie made in the last 20 years) of having to work with your ex.
I have too much to watch already, thanks.