Mon 24 May 2021
A Mystery Review by LJ Roberts: J. D. ROBB – Shadows in Death.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[7] Comments
Reviews by L. J. Roberts
J. D. ROBB – Shadows in Death. Lt. Eve Dallas #51. St. Martin’s Press, hardcover, September 2020; paperback, December 2020.
First Sentence: As it often did since he’d married a cop, murder interrupted more pleasant activities.
Lt. Eve Dallas, with her husband, Roarke, goes to the scene of a murdered woman. While on-site, Roarke sees a man he knew from his past in Ireland. Lorcan Cobbe, a contract killer, claims he is Roarke’s father’s actual and first son. Lorcan hates Roarke enough to kill him, and everyone he loves. Eve is certain the dead woman’s husband hired Cobbe to perform the hit. Eve’s first task to proving the husband a killer, then stop Cobbe before he kills Roarke.
There are times when one wants an entertaining, captivating read. With her 51st book in the Eve Dallas series, Robb succeeds in creating exactly that. Yes, the plots are somewhat predictable, but the world Robb has created is visual, and the characters are ones about whom readers’ care.
What is remarkable is that the “…in Death” series began in 1995 with the first book set in 2058 and Eve being 30 years old, releasing two Dallas books/year, plus the occasional novella. Shadows in Death is set in 2061; three years and 51+/- cases later, bringing Eve’s clearance rate to ~17 cases per year, or once every three weeks. What police department wouldn’t love that?
Robb has a deft hand when it comes to dialogue, even creating slang that fits for the near-future time period. How clever to use an expression known to readers in the present but would be anachronistic to the period. There are some great lines, and her wry humor is always a pleasure. A discussion on the subtle differences between colors leads to an internal observation— “Peabody turned a little green —perhaps celadon — and turned her head to stare hard at the wall.” Robb carries thoughts through from one scene to another with great deliberateness and ease.
One learns more about Roarke’s childhood and one must respect that Robb, even this far into the series, still has new information to impart. One small irritant is Roark’s references to Eve being “his,” making her seem a possession. However, this is mitigated by the realization that Eve claims Roarke in the same manner and showing it is a manifestation of their commitment of care and protection, and not possessiveness, even including those around them. Yes, the scenes of lovemaking are hot, but they are more about emotion than sex.
Eve is not perfect which makes her more real. She has areas of discomfort and gaps in her knowledge for anything beyond her job or her city— “They look like cops…I need them to look like farmers. Irish farmers,” Eve added. “Who are out there doing farm stuff.”
There is an urgency and intensity to the investigation which gives the sense of needing to run to keep up. The action scenes are visceral, tense, exciting, and filled with twists. They provide excellent examples of Eve’s leadership and authority, and the respect she has earned. Even so, it is not a perfect book. There were opportunities for danger and suspense not taken, and the ending seemed too quick with a final scene a bit silly, albeit satisfying.
Shadows in Death is an excellent remedy to offset the stress and uncertainty of these times in which we live.
Rating: B Plus.
May 24th, 2021 at 3:51 pm
Do I get to be the first to mention that J. D. Robb is another way of saying Nora Roberts?
(And would that start up a whole bunch of other things?)
(It occurs to me that Ms. Roberts/Robb might have come up here before; I’m now going to your archives (belatedly) to check up on that …)
May 24th, 2021 at 4:01 pm
OK, back from my quick archive check, wherein I learn that several of you beat me to the Robb/Roberts saga by more than a decade.
Never let it be said that I’m reluctant to learn something new, after all these years.
(And I’ll admit that I’m always willing to find something – or someone – new to read …)
May 24th, 2021 at 4:27 pm
Looks like three previous Robb books, Mike, all reviewed by LJ:
#45. Secrets in Death
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=52234
#31. Indulgence in Death
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=18112
#37. Fantasy in Death
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=2066
May 24th, 2021 at 7:06 pm
I seem to recall reading somewhere Roberts is a Mickey Spillane fan, which really isn’t as odd as it seems in that I’ve known a few women Romance writers who liked Spillane and found a streak of romanticism in his work.
I only mention that to point out she came to the mystery field as an insider and not slumming as too often happens with writers from other genres. Even as Roberts some of her novels fall in the mystery/suspemse category.
While I don’t read them all the time I pick up a Robb book once in a while and usually enjoy them. The future setting is a bit wasted as it doesn’t really have much to do with most of the plots. That said the mystery element is adequate, the suspense well handled, and Dallas an attractive heroine more or less believable within the parameters of the Robb books.
The ones I’ve read I usually enjoy, and I really wouldn’t mind seeing the series picked up for film or television.
For that matter Romance novelist or not I’ve read a few Roberts books I enjoyed. She writes well, which is a plus for any writer in any genre.
May 24th, 2021 at 8:38 pm
I am also surprised that no one has picked this series up for TV. The already existing fan base must be huge.
May 24th, 2021 at 11:45 pm
Sorry, Mike, it has been known for many years that J.D. Robb is Nora Roberts. Because she is such a prolific author, her publisher requested she use a pseudonym for the detective/futuristic series.
As for a television show, it’s not that there hasn’t been interested, it’s that Roberts doesn’t want to sell the rights. Yes, her fan base is massive and there has always been hot debate as to who would play Roarke, especially. I think she’s smart, and she clearly doesn’t need the cash.
May 25th, 2021 at 6:16 am
Jackie was clued in to the Robb series years ago by the late Bob Briney, of all people. She has read ALL the books in the series, plus the occasional shorter story. Obviously, she’s a big fan.