Sat 18 May 2013
KELLEY ROOS – Ghost of a Chance. Dell #266, mapback edition, no date [1948]. Originally published by A. A. Wyn, hardcover, 1947. Hardcover reprint: Detective Book Club, 3-in-1 edition.
When it comes to married couples who solve detective mysteries in crime fiction, if you’re like me, the first ones to come to mind are Nick and Nora Charles (The Thin Man, 1934), but once I thought about it some more, I decided that Agatha Christie’s Tuppence and Tommy might have come earlier, and I was right: The Secret Adversary (1922).
I suspect, as it always happens whenever you try to come up with the first of anything when it comes to mystery fiction, that there were earlier ones, but if there are, I’m willing to wager that they are all obscure. Jeff and Haila Troy, the detective of record in ten entries in Al Hubin’s Crime Fiction IV (including one collection and one novella published separately), came along much later, starting with Made Up to Kill in 1940, and would probably fit very nicely in the obscure category, if the good folks at Rue Morgue Press hadn’t published a few of them in recent years.
Contemporaneous with the Troys would be Mr. and Mrs. North, whose adventures were written up by Frances and Richard Lockridge. At the time, the Norths were much better known, but I suspect they’re also falling into obscurity, if they haven’t already, sad to say.
This is the first of the Troys’ adventures that I’ve read, and while I enjoyed it and will read any others that happen to fall into my hands, as a mystery, it’s tame enough that I can see why the Troys were really never rivals to the Norths in terms of popularity, even at the time.
I may have been told in Ghost of a Chance what either or both of the Troys do for a living, but if so, I’m sorry to say that I missed it. (And I did. The Dell mapback I have in my hands has a descriptive list of the characters on the very first page. Jeff Troy is a photographer. It does not say what Haila does, but from a quick search on the Internet, it appears that she is an actress, or that she was at one time.)
Ghost of a Chance is told in a decidedly breezy style, one that does its best, but doesn’t quite succeed, in disguising the fact that there really isn’t a lot of substance to it, but breezy enough that you don’t quite realize it while you’re reading. Only when you’re done do you (or did I) realize how flimsy the plot really was.
Which involves Jeff and Haila trying their best to prevent a murder from happening, one that an old man does his best to tell them about before he dies unexpectedly in a gruesome subway accident. Only problem is, while they know when the murder is going to happen, they don’t know who the victim is going to be, nor why. (That the old man’s death is no accident, they assume right away.)
This is where the detection comes in, which is satisfactory, but the case quickly becomes a thriller more than a puzzle novel, which is where my disappointment if not discontent set in. But the locale — here and there and up and down the island of Manhattan in the middle of a vicious snow storm before adjourning briefly to a small vacation town in upstate New York — is both finely described and highly enjoyable.
As for current married couples who solve mystery cases together, is Beckett going to say yes to Castle’s proposal in last week’s end of season finale? Tune in next fall and find out.
May 18th, 2013 at 11:19 pm
It isn’t that I’m crazy about Tuppence and Tommy but I did think The Secret Adversary pretty good. Better than just that.
May 18th, 2013 at 11:34 pm
Forgot: They were well played by Francesca Annis and James Warwick.
May 18th, 2013 at 11:54 pm
I’ve been meaning to watch both that TV movie and the series that came after, but I just never have.
May 19th, 2013 at 8:35 am
The Troys were dull compared to Jane & Dagobert Brown – Delano Ames.
May 19th, 2013 at 9:45 am
Years from now I wonder how confused readers will be by your last sentence. As for CASTLE, does it matter? The CASTLE people in the past have mentioned BONES as a role model as what to do about the subplot of will they or won’t they.
There are only two forms of fiction that angers me so much I want to take the story, characters, writers, and anything or anyone connected to the idea and put them in a rocket and shoot them into the sun. Those two forms are If Only I Had Known and Will They Or Won’t They.
In both cases the characters have to often behave in an unbelievable stupid way so the question is never resolved.
May 19th, 2013 at 10:26 am
Good review!
Ghost of a Chance is a change-of-pace work in the Troy series. Most of the other books are pure mystery puzzles. Ghost of a Chance emphasizes a long chase around New York, instead. It is more of a thriller, as Steve’s review says.
IMHO The short stories in PARTNERS IN CRIME are better Tommy and Tuppence adventures than their debut novel THE SECRET ADVERSARY. The PARTNERS IN CRIME TV series is fun too.
May 19th, 2013 at 10:59 am
Jeff, Comment #4
Thanks for reminding me about Jane and Dagobert Brown. I’ve made a point over the years of collecting the mysteries they were in, but accumulating might be a better word, since I’ve not read a single one of them.
I’ll have to do something about that!
May 19th, 2013 at 11:07 am
Michael, Comment #5
I don’t mind “Will They Or Won’t They” as much as you do, and apparently the Vast Viewing Audience minds it even less.
I watch CASTLE for the detective puzzles, which are usually quite intricate, the formula often being, which twist comes next.
When it comes to Castle and Beckett and the problems they run into with their personal lives, I find that aspect of the series tolerable if not amusing. I don’t take it seriously.
As for BONES, I watched it for about half a season before I gave up on it, but I might not have if I’d enjoyed the cases they worked on more.
May 19th, 2013 at 7:49 pm
I’ve only read one book with the Troys — SAILOR, TAKE WARNING — and thought it good enough. Borrows an idea from the pages of Chesterton, though, and it’s rather easy to solve the mystery of who killed a man on a park bench without anyone noticing the murder. The murder weapon was certainly an ingenious touch.
May 20th, 2013 at 10:16 am
I’m a little surprised that no one has mentioned the Jeff & Haila Troy movie:
A Night To Remember, from Columbia in 1942.
Brian Aherne and Loretta Young starred as the Troys. I was pretty obvious that Columbia wanted their own Thin Man-type series, so call this the “unsold pilot”.
In this movie Jeff Troy is a mystery novelist, using the pseudonym “Jeffrey Yort”.
He explains to the gruff old police detective (Sidney Toler, in his gap year from Charlie Chan) that the pen name is his own, spelled backward.
Toler allows that he’s read one of “Yort”s novels, saying it’s “the kind of story that knits – you spell that backwards too.”
I’ve got the DVD (it’s in a set of “screwball comedies”, which likely explains why it’s under the mystery-movie radar), but haven’t had a chance to watch it all the way through (when I get the chance …).
The original novel by Roos is one of the recent Rue Morgue Press reprints; I can’t call the title to mind just now *darndarndarndarndarn*.
May 20th, 2013 at 11:03 am
One of the Kelley Roos’ non-series books is available on Kindle. It is “The Blonde Died Dancing.” The book would be made into a movie with Brigitte Bardot as the star, “Come Dance With Me.”
May 20th, 2013 at 11:47 pm
Mike Doran
We saw A Night To Remember two or three times. Liked the actors but not the tone, atmosphere or the script. Brian Aherne had excellent possibilities…Too bad. A straight mystery with light asides would have worked well, rather than a labored attempt at screwball comedy.