Fri 23 Jan 2015
A Review by Barry Gardner: THOMAS H. COOK – Mortal Memory.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[2] Comments
THOMAS H. COOK – Mortal Memory. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, hardcover, 1993. Bantam, paperback, 1994.
Cook’s three novels of Frank Clemons, first an Atlanta cop, then a New York investigator, are about as dark and grim a trio as you’re likely to find. I’ve only read one other book of his and it was of the same shade, so I didn’t come to this one expecting a lot of chuckles. Which was just as well, because there weren’t any.
This is the story of a man whose father murdered his brother, sister, and mother when he was nine. He has buried most of the memories of his childhood, but not so deep they can’t be disinterred, and that is what happens when a lady comes to town to interview him for a book she is writing about family Killers. As he brings the past into the light, its shadows darken the present, and we move along with him to a conclusion that seems at once both inevitable and unforeseen.
Cook’s prose reminds me at times of David Lindsey in its slow pace and somber tone. When done well — as they each do it — the combination can result in powerful and evocative storytelling. The protagonist is drawn clearly in some ways, and in others we understand him no better in the end than he does himself. The same is true of his parents and siblings. There are questions left unanswered — but then there are those at the end of everything, aren’t there?
The constant shifts between past and present were potentially distracting but well handled. I thought that the character of the writer was either too enigmatic or not faceless enough; as presented, she was vaguely unsatisfying. That is a relatively minor cavil though, and if you like this book well enough to read it through, you won’t be unaffected by it. Cook remains one of the masters of the dark side.
January 23rd, 2015 at 10:09 pm
Any comparison to Lindsey is enough to me, a writer with some of the scope and depth of a Graham Greene. I’ll clearly check this out when I can find it.
January 23rd, 2015 at 11:19 pm
I have one or two of Cook’s books, but I haven’t read any. They’ve always seemed a little too dark for me. But I’m always happy to post reviews of books that don’t immediately seem to appeal to me, especially when it comes to one by someone like Barry Gardner, whose opinion I trust.
I think, though, I’d rather start with Cook’s Frank Clemons trilogy, in essence one long book, or so I’ve been told, with the plus of being a PI novel. If only there were time!