Fri 20 Nov 2020
A Mystery Review by LJ Roberts: SHELDON SIEGEL – The Dreamer.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[3] Comments
Reviews by L. J. Roberts
SHELDON SIEGEL – The Dreamer. Mike Daley/Rosie Fernandez #11. Sheldon M. Siegel, Inc., hardcover/softcover, March 2020. Setting: Contemporary San Francisco.
First Sentence: The Honorable Elizabeth McDaniel glanced at her watch, rested her chin in her palm, and spoke to me in a world-weary tone still bearing a trace of her native Alabama.
Mercedes “Mercy” Tejada is a Dreamer who was brought to the United States as a baby. Now she’s accused of murdering her boss, celebrity chef and James Beard Award recipient, Carlos Cruz. Carlos was known for sexually harassing his female staff, particularly Mercy. Now, he is dead in an alley, Mercy kneeling over him, and her prints on the knife next to him. San Francisco Public Defenders Rosie and Mike are against the clock to prove Mercy innocent, and to keep her, and her family, from being deported.
Siegel begins with an amusing vignette that pleases and establishes Mike Daley as a sharp, clever, and well-established lawyer. The way in which we meet the others in Mike’s life, especially his ex-wife and boss, Rosie Fernandez, is handled succinctly, but with clarity.
A murder case is always the perfect base for a legal mystery. Add the element of a Dreamer with an undocumented mother, and the level of suspense immediately escalates. The decision of Rose to be the lead attorney, with Mike as second chair, makes one smile.
Siegel excels at throwing back the cover on the legal system. He shows just how unjust justice can be, especially if one is a woman, a person of color, and undocumented. Siegel takes on the issue of undocumented workers. What is nice is that the story addresses the issue from a moral perspective, rather than a political one.
Reading about a city one knows well always adds a personal touch. However, even when it is a city unknown to the reader, some things have become sadly universal in urban areas— “A homeless man asked me for change. A man in a Warriors jersey offered me a fentanyl. A woman in a halter top asked me if I was looking for a date.”
There is an excellent twist and good questions raised during the investigation. One doesn’t normally think of the initial, information-gathering phase of a case as being suspenseful. Under Siegel’s deft hand, it is.
It may be a classic trope, but it is always interesting to have a victim everyone wants to kill. But watching Rosie and Mike prepare a case with no other suspects, and no witnesses, based on a defense of SODDI (“some other dude did itâ€), and with the prosecution not meeting the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt makes things all the more engrossing.
The Dreamer has a major plot twist and a very satisfying affirmation at the end. Siegel is an under-appreciated author who writes excellent legal procedurals.
Rating: Very Good.
November 20th, 2020 at 9:16 pm
Sounds a bit more interesting than many of the legal procedurals I have come to pass on automatically these days. Sounds as if there is more than a bit of detective work as well as legal manuevering.
November 20th, 2020 at 9:40 pm
I read an early one in the series, and while (as I remember) the legal maneuvering took precedence over the detective work, I don’t mind legal maneuvering at all. I wish I’d been able to keep up with the series, but alas, it was a series that I just couldn’t fit into my reading time at the time.
December 23rd, 2020 at 12:27 am
One of the things I like best about Siegel’s book is the combination of information about the law, and the investigation. I always learn something from his books, which is also good. I believe he is still a practicing attorney, at least part time.