Wed 15 Apr 2009
Review: KATHLEEN WADE – Crime at Gargoyles.
Posted by Steve under Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Crime Fiction IV , Reviews[7] Comments
KATHLEEN WADE – Crime at Gargoyles. Hutchinson, UK, hardcover. No date stated [1947].
The current, updated entry for Kathleen Wade in the Revised Crime Fiction IV, by Allen J. Hubin, looks like this:
WADE, KATHLEEN (Nesta Knight). 1903 -1986. SC: Detective Inspector (Hamilton) Drake, in at least those marked HD.
Death at Aranshore (Gifford, 1942, hc)
Death on ?Calamity” (Gifford, 1945, hc) [England; Ship]
Crime at Gargoyles (Hutchinson, 1947, hc) [England] HD
A Cloak for Malice (Hutchinson, 1949, hc) [England]
The Dark Moment (Hutchinson, 1951, hc) [England] HD
Act of Violence (Hutchinson, 1954, hc)
Note that some of this information appears only in the online Addenda, which adds some facts uncovered by British mystery bookseller and researcher Jamie Sturgeon. He also notes that “she lived with the [noted] sculptor and writer Eric Benfield (if you do a Google search you will find a little bit about both of them).”
The link will lead you to one such page; more than likely there are several others. It was also Jamie who discovered that Inspector Drake appeared in at least two of the books, Crime at Gargoyles being one of them.
Drake doesn’t enter in until well after halfway through, however. Until then the story focuses solely on John Shirley, home from the Far East as a war correspondent on sick leave — a “recent breakdown.”
Which helps explain, perhaps, why he does what he does when he moves a body he finds in his guest lodgings at Max Tarn’s manor house, a former monastery called Gargoyles. He was shattered at first by meeting his ex-fiancee at the dinner party the night before, but matters are made worse when the dead man turns out to be the fellow she chose as a husband instead, Tarn?s stepson.
Strangely enough, when he dumps the body in a small nearby stream — although he realizes how neat a frame it is — he’s thinking as much of the old man who’s been taking care of the guest lodge, a fellow named Beal, who also had good reason to hate the dead man. But good intentions often lead to bad consequences, and of course that is what they do here.
It isn’t until another victim is found, one presumed to be suicide, but Shirley thinks not, that he decides to call on his good friend Inspector Drake, eventually confessing all. By that time, the case has evolved into as much a thriller novel as a detective story.
One possible definition of a thriller novel: one that you pick up at midnight to read and at 2:30 you discover you haven?t put it down yet.
Of course when you do finish it, perhaps not the same evening, you may often look back and see how inconsequential it all was, as is the case here, but not while you are reading it, not at all.
April 13th, 2021 at 8:31 am
Only twelve years late but I’ve just discovered that Drake also is in her first book Death at Aranshore.
April 13th, 2021 at 9:54 am
Thanks, Jamie. Better 12 years later than never!
And there’s a certain synchronicity going on here. While cleaning my upstairs study last week, I came across my copy of this book, which got me to wondering. Had I read this book before?
Answer now, obviously yes.
March 28th, 2026 at 6:38 pm
Another note, also belated, from Jamie:
“Just an update on Kathleen Wade for your blog review, as I’m reading Death on “Calamity” now, which does also feature Detective Inspector Hamilton Drake.”

Late or not, information such as this is always most welcome. Thanks, Jamie!
March 29th, 2026 at 8:47 am
The note above was followed by this from Jamie:
“Also the link to the Eric Benfield article needs updating (see below) as the old link doesn’t work. Eric Benfield also wrote one crime novel for definite, it is ‘Poison in the Shade’, the other one in Hubin ‘The Dead Bury Their Dead’ I think is probably not crime fiction.”
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/article_1131jsp/
Thanks for the better link, Jamie. I’m not able to edit posts at the present time. All I can do is insert it into this, another comment!
March 29th, 2026 at 3:39 pm
Thanks Steve, I’ve just unearthed my Mystery Book Guild reprint edition of Kathleen Wade’s last book Act of Violence, only acquired in the last year. Looking through it I see Inspector Drake of Scotland Yard appears, though rather oddly he’s not mentioned in the blurb.
June 23rd, 2026 at 12:11 pm
I am now not sure that the Kathleen Wade who lived with Eric Benfield was ‘our’ Kathleen Wade. I found on Google Books a book about the Isle of Purbeck that has a chapter on Eric Benfield that in a footnote states: In Neil Pearson’s biography of the Obelisk Press, Pearson relates Brian Bugler’s story that Kathleen Wade ‘promised to return all of Eric Benfield’s papers and unpublished manuscripts to the family. But Wade died of a stroke six weeks after Benfield’s funeral and the papers were lost’. Pearson, Obelisk, p.327. Benfield died in December 1955 in Hampshire and the mystery writer Kathleen Wade died in Croydon 1986, I know that is correct because she has an entry in Author & Writer’s Who’s Who 1971 giving her full name. Can’t find a Kathleen Wade’s death in first quarter 1956 or any Wade death that might fit. All my research on Ancestry shows the Kathleen Wade mystery writer lived in London (Croydon then Hampstead then Croydon) most of her life after 1911, though admittedly I have found nothing about where she might have lived after 1939 until 1963. She was a secretary to a literary agency in the 1939 Register, living in Hampstead. Never married. So either it wasn’t Kathleen Wade the mystery writer or Brian Bugler (Benfield’s grandson born 1948) was incorrect about her date of death. Something wrong somewhere. More research needed I think.
If you are able to edit comments please delete my idea that Benfield’s The dead bury the dead isn’t crime, the plot is in the article I sent you the link for! It looks rather gruesome.
June 23rd, 2026 at 12:29 pm
I’ve now finished reading Act of Violence. Definitely Detective Inspector Hamilton Drake as he is called Hamilton by a small boy at one point. The book has the third party narrator behave in the same way as in Death on Calamity. In both books the narrators don’t tell Drake crucial information about another person because it might be damaging to that person and each narrator (female in the first and male in the second) has fallen in love with that person. Of course it all ends happily for each narrator, wedding bells etc. I enjoyed reading it, I thought it very good, apart from a bugbear of mine, if you use some proper place names in a book, don’t invent topographical details that are complete nonsense for that place (in this case the county of Sussex)