Tue 28 Apr 2009
Movie Review: CAPTAIN APPLEJACK (1931)
Posted by Steve under Crime Films , Films: Comedy/Musicals , Reviews[2] Comments
CAPTAIN APPLEJACK. Warner Brothers, 1931. Mary Brian, John Halliday, Kay Strozzi, Alec B. Francis, Louise Closser Hale. Based on the play of the same title by Walter C. Hackett. Director: Hobart Henley.
As a play, Captain Applejack opened on Broadway at the Cort Theatre on December 30, 1921, and ran for 195 performances.
The story was soon thereafter the basis for a silent film, although why they changed the name to Strangers of the Night (Louis B. Meyer, 1923) I do not know. The main players in the cast were Matt Moore as Ambrose Applejohn, Enid Bennett as his ward Poppy, and Barbara La Marr as the vampish Anna Valeska, who in one evening gives Ambrose the thrill of several lifetimes.
None of the actors’ names in the paragraph above mean anything to me, I apologize for saying, and in fact, the first three names I’ve listed for this 1931 sound remake meant just about as little when I started watching this movie last night. I’ll get back to them shortly.
It’s one of those old British mansion movies, built upon the edge of the cliff – the mansion, that is – and the one night that the owner Ambrose Applejohn (John Halliday) will remember forever is a dark and stormy one.
It begins with Ambrose telling his Aunt Agatha (Louise Closser Hale) and his ward Poppy (Mary Brian) that he’s selling the house and striking out on a tour of the world on a quest for adventure and excitement.
Little does he know … there’s a knock on the door. Enter the beautifully exotic Madame Anna Valeska (Kay Strozzi), seeking not only shelter from the storm, but from the villain of the piece, a chap by the name of Ivan Borolsky. Adventure has fallen into Ambrose’s lap, and he doesn’t even have to leave home.
Of course he is neither as brave and stalwart as he says he is, or would like to be, and if I haven’t told you that this is a comedy, I am right now, and even alone in the room I was in, I laughed out loud several times.
Any movie with a butler named Lush (Alec B. Francis) has to be a comedy, wouldn’t you agree? Nor is Madame Valeska the only one to knock on the door. Soon there is a whole household full of guests, some welcome, some not. Did I mention that Polly is jealous of Madame Valeska? I have now.
Without telling you more than I should, there is a reason for all of the guests and intruders, and the reason has to do with the fact that Ambrose Applejohn is a direct descendant of a cruel pirate named Captain Applejack. There is also a map of sorts.
This is a very entertaining film, albeit noticeably stagey, with a bit of advice that anyone younger than 40 or 50 will probably be bored to abstract fidgetry. That this is a pre-Code film should also be mentioned, with blouses cut lower than they might have been a few years later, and a pair of male hands that do not always stay out of bounds where they belong.
The photo of John Halliday may have come from the film. If not, it’s very close. His career extended from 1911 to 1941, with perhaps his best-remembered role being that of Katharine Hepburn’s father in The Philadelphia Story (1940).
Mary Brian’s wholesome good looks once graced the cover of Picture Play, as you’ve already seen somewhere up above. She started her film-making days playing Wendy Darling in a 1924 silent version of Peter Pan; her final performances were as Corliss Archer’s mother in the 1954 TV sitcom series.
As for Kay Strozzi, in spite of her beautifully exotic appearance (early 1930s style), she made only one other movie, a Bette Davis film called Ex-Wife (1933). Otherwise she seems to have been a Broadway performer, which I can understand, and a soap opera star on the radio, which I don’t.
April 29th, 2009 at 12:22 am
Halliday was good in Frank Borzage’s Desire (1936,produced by Ernst Lubitsch) as a sophisticated jewel thief, Carlos Margoli the Pearl Necklace, whose partner Marlene Dietrich falls for American car designer Gary Cooper during a Spanish holiday. He often played roguish parts, though not always, and was usually at his best in sophisticated comedy like Desire and Philadelphia Story.
He was third billed in the Edgar Wallace thriller The Return of the Terror (1934 with Mary Astor, Lyle Talbot, J. Carrol Naish, Frank McHugh, and Robert Barrat)and was Count de Grissac in Arsene Lupin Returns (1938) with Melvyn Douglas as Lupin. From his debut in 1911 until 1921 he was billed as Jack Halliday. His last film appearance was in 1941’s Lydia directed by Jacques Duvivier (based on his own film Carnet de Bal). He died in Honolulu in 1947.
Among his better known films, Intermezzo, Hotel for Women, Peter Ibbetsen (also with Cooper), Bird of Paradise, and The Dark Angel (again with Oberon).
An interesting comment on Captain Applejack at IMDB suggests that the film, the play it is based on, and the first silent film based on it, Strangers in the Night (1923) are the basis for the Tintin adventures The Secret of the Unicorn and Red Rackham’s Treasure by Herge. I don’t know if that’s true, but it is within the realm of possibility, and if so an interesting sideline. Certainly there are some similar features between the storylines with Tintin’s friend Captain Haddock in the Halliday role.
Matt Moore, who played the role of Ambrose in Strangers in the Night (1923), was the brother of actress Mary Moore, and the brother-in-law of Mary Pickford.
April 30th, 2009 at 3:40 am
Just to follow on about the Tintin reference – I think it is pure speculation.
It certainly possible that Herge saw the film or the play but it is unlikely.
See: http://tintinmovie.org/2009/04/30/herges-secret-inspiration/