Mon 22 Jun 2009
NEIL McNEIL’S “COSTAINE & McCALL” SERIES, by David L. Vineyard.
Posted by Steve under Authors , Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Characters[4] Comments
by DAVID L. VINEYARD
Between 1959 and 1966 Black Mask veteran Willis Todhunter Ballard penned seven books as Neil McNeil for the Gold Medal line of paperback originals about a pair of private eyes named Tony Costaine and Bert McCall:
Third on a Seesaw. Gold Medal s844, pbo, January 1959.
2 Guns for Hire. Gold Medal s898, pbo, July 1959.
Hot Dam. Gold Medal 964, pbo, January 1960.
The Death Ride. Gold Medal 1055, pbo, November 1960.
Mexican Slayride. Gold Medal s1182, pbo, January 1962.
The Spy Catchers. Gold Medal d1658; pbo, 1966.
Though the series was never a major hit, they are highly entertaining superior light private eye fiction much in the mood and style of such popular series as 77 Sunset Strip and Peter Gunn on television. Costaine and McCall are the epitome of the cool, hip, buttoned-down PI’s of the period, distilled through the Rat Pack school of middle aged hipster, a group of slick eyes that rode the wave between Mike Hammer and James Bond.
Anthony “Tony” Costaine is the brains of the outfit, slick, smart and tough, the button-down collar Brooks Brothers suit half of the team, who first teamed up with McCall back in their FBI and OSS days, six lean feet of muscle and brains.
Bert McCall, a giant handsome Scot (born in Scotland) and topping six feet six in his stocking feet is the other half of the team, a born hedonist with an eye for the ladies, and a penchant for finding trouble and playing the bagpipes. Between the two of them they are the highest paid eyes of their day — so as you can imagine their clients tend to be rich, powerful, and in big trouble.
In Death Takes an Option Marcus Cadby has hired them to find out why the auditor of MidContinental Mine and Machine commited suicide, but not before his younger and very sexy wife has tried to pry information out of Costaine.
Then no sooner than their plane touches down in Los Angeles someone takes a pot shot at them, and before long they are involved with murder, a trip to Vegas, and a slick plot twist you will have to read for yourself.
The trip to Vegas is important, because Costaine and McCall are, as I suggested above, Frank and Dino in not very subtle guise. McCall even calls Costaine “Dad.”
Third on a Seesaw takes them to Reesedale PA, home of Reese Steel and Tube Company where they clean up the town and a murder — once McCall can be pried away from his bagpipes.
2 Guns for Hire involves the boys with the car industry and a beautiful woman who paints nudes, and in Hot Dam they encounter a whole community of distant relatives of McCall who are sabotaging a power company by trying to build a dam that will flood their homes in upper New York state.
The Death Ride takes them into the business of amusement parks, and in Mexican Slay Ride McCall ends up in jail south of the border as the boys take on a job involving fraud and the Mexican government. The Spy Catchers mixes them in with the government and treason in the aerospace industry and secret weapons.
To be fair, Ballard could do this kind of book in his sleep, but thankfully he doesn’t. The boys are cool and smart, McCall just dumb enough to get them in trouble and Costaine just smart enough to get them out.
There is a parade of attractive women varying from willing to murderous (and sometimes both), and a wide variety of action. The books aren’t major works or anything, but they are good and well worth discovering. Plotting is better than it had to be, and Costaine and McCall are always fun to be around.
● Tony Costaine was surprised. He could not remember being as surprised since the night the Chinese girl had walked into his Singapore apartment carrying a Tommy gun.
● “In that case it’s simple,” McCall licked his lips. “We make motions, we find nothing, and we trot back to Cadby and say we are sorry.”
“And lose the twenty thousand he’ll owe us when we come up with his answer? Besides it wouldn’t be ethical.”
McCall opened his eyes very wide. “I don’t dig the word, Dad. Where’d you ever hear it?”
● Wearing a black flat topped Mexican hat with tiny read balls dangling and dancing from its brim, Norbert McCall, Scotland’s contribution to the atomic age, did not look like a man who was out on fifty thousand dollars’ bail.
● “I’m never in trouble,” Anthony Costaine said with conviction. He had had five drinks. He sounded as if he meant it.
● “Whoever’s got it (the secret weapon) is playing for keeps, and the price is the peace of the world.”
McCall yawned. “Aw, it’s probably only Goldfinger.”
Ballard was one of the original Black Mask Boys with his tales of movie studio troubleshooter Bill Lennox (who also featured in three novels published as by Ballard and John Shepard), and a frequent collaborator with Robert Leslie Bellem and Cleve Adams.
He wrote for early television (Dick Tracy) and even wrote a non genre novel about his experiences. Under his own name and as P.D. Ballard and Todhunter Ballard, among others, he wrote well-received westerns, and under the W.T. Ballard name, three books about Lt. Max Hunter of the Las Vegas police.
His last novel, Murder in Las Vegas, about private eye Mark Foran, is one of the better hardboiled paperback originals of its period.
That Todhunter is a family name. He was a cousin of Rex Todhunter Stout.
Costaine and McCall may not be in the top tier of private eyes, but they are well worth discovering. The writing is lean and slick, and the action comes fast and furious. A little action, a soupcon of sex, and a twist or two in the tale are more than enough to recommend these.
They make good company, and fit right in with Shell Scott and Chet Drum. Make the effort to meet them, but first lock up the Scotch and the women. You just can’t trust that McCall with either.
June 22nd, 2009 at 10:05 pm
Thanks for the interesting and well written post. I was not aware of these books. It seems like i can read and read and feel like I’ve about come across a little bit of everything out there, but then still hear about another new (old) title or series. It’s a wonderful thing!
June 23rd, 2009 at 12:54 pm
Frank,
I’m glad to know you found the article useful. I don’t believe that many people are aware of the Neil MacNeil books, but I think they’re as good as David says they are.
I’ve been reading and collecting Gold Medal crime and mystery paperbacks for over 50 years, and I don’t think you can go wrong in hunting down any of them, through the 1970s, say, whether you recognize the author or not.
A good checklist, complete with covers can be found at
http://www.gm.bookscans.com/gm.htm
No, make that terrific, not just good. Bruce Black has done a great job with this website, and everyone reading this post should know about it.
— Steve
June 23rd, 2009 at 4:19 pm
Steve, I just wanted to say thanks for mentioning the Gold Medal bookscans site. What a great place! This is the first time I’ve seen a lot of those covers.
Now I’m going to begin searching for some of these treasures…
June 23rd, 2009 at 4:44 pm
I’ve just visited the page the link goes to, and I can’t see any way to go from it to Bruce’s main web page. Not only does he do the Gold Medal’s, but his ultimate goal, I believe, is to display cover scans for every paperback ever published through 1970.
I’ve tried to persuade him a couple of times that he ought add paperbacks all the way through the 1970s. Books from the 70s are later than what most collectors think of as “vintage paperbacks,” but there’s a demand for many of them, and for some of the publishers, I think he’s agreed.
In any case, if you’ve never been there before, go to http://www.bookscans.com and prepare to be amazed.
— Steve