Mon 30 Jan 2012
Movie Review: YOU CAME ALONG (1945).
Posted by Steve under Films: Drama/Romance , Reviews[7] Comments
YOU CAME ALONG. Paramount Pictures, 1945. Robert Cummings, Lizabeth Scott, Don DeFore, Charles Drake, Julie Bishop, Kim Hunter, Helen Forrest. Co-screenwriter: Ayn Rand. Director: John Farrow.
For some viewers, the primary reason for watching this movie may be the fact that Ayn Rand was in part responsible for the script. Perhaps others couldn’t care less, noting instead that this was the film debut of Lizabeth Scott, known more for her roles in film noir, of which category this movie is most definitely not.
Count me in as one of the latter. The story is kind of silly, and not particularly being a fan of Ayn Rand’s, I don’t know why she was writing movie screenplays in the mid 1940s. You can tell me more in the comments, if you’d care to, but for now, the rest of this review will focus on the movie itself, with no offense intended.
All things considered, though, I’d rather not tell you all that much about the story line, even though every other review of this movie that you’ll find online will probably spell out the whole thing to you, from beginning to end, and in detail.
What I will tell you is it begins as a sort of standard 1940s comedy, with a strait-laced young blonde being assigned to accompany three boisterous, fun-loving and girl-chasing war pilots on a Savings Bond tour across the US.
The blonde being Lizabeth Scott, who soon with a gleam in her eyes turns the table on the hijinks the three decorated aces come up with, and soon thereafter that she is to be seen sitting around their cross-country transport plane with her feet up on the table with the others. Later on she finds the time to sit at a piano and sing a song – and rather well too.
Nature has a way of taking its course in this kind of film, and I might as well tell you that romance does also. This is as much as I will say, except perhaps to add that the three heroes she is hanging out with are hiding a secret, the secret involving… No, I shan’t say, as secrets are meant to be kept.
Or are they? Secrets are what make stories in movies like this churning along, and between you and me, they are also what makes them as sappy and sentimental as the ending of this one turns out to be. I’d also suggest that you keep the tissues handy, but I won’t. If I did, I have a pretty good idea that it would give the whole show away.
If you were to ask me, I’d say you should watch this one for Lizabeth Scott in a role far from the ones her career led her, and for the three buddies she finds herself on the road with. Together they make a very engaging, fun-loving foursome, and like me, you may find yourself enjoying the first half of the film much more than the second.
January 31st, 2012 at 12:58 pm
I’ve always been a big Robert Cummings fan. Not a great actor, but a personable one.
January 31st, 2012 at 1:21 pm
I don’t like Robert Cummings’ work at all, but he is perfectly all right in You Came Along, which I do like. I think the ending works well, and playing throughout, especially Lizabeth Scott, a revelation in excellence.
January 31st, 2012 at 2:25 pm
I see one reviewer on IMDB calls the first part of the movie “silly” and the ending “very adult and realistic.” I saw just the opposite. Of the three online reviews, in terms of the ending, one’s with me, and two are with you, Barry.
As for Lizabeth Scott being a revelation in excellence? We’re on the same page there.
January 31st, 2012 at 2:30 pm
George
I remember Bob Cummings mostly for his TV work, which (as I recall) involved what I thought of as mugging for the camera on his part. That’s probably unfair, being as it was an impression formed by a teen-aged kid, but it has persisted ever since.
But as Barry says, he’s pitch perfect in YOU CAME ALONG. The more I think about this movie, the more I realize how well cast it was.
February 16th, 2012 at 7:22 am
hello – well done for writing a review of You Came Along – not an easy film to categorise at all, because as you say it starts off a a sort of “road” film a bit like some kind of fundraiser vehicle for the troops / war bonds or whatever and then becomes something very different. There’s something a little bit to strained however in the boys forced fun-loving attitude – as if they haven’t got a long time…I think – maybe I’m too sentimental / romantic or whatever – but Bob’s and Liz’s love for each other is one of the most poignant things in movies I think…the US was far away the best in doing this sort of thing, although I think there is a British film called “The Way to the Stars” (also 45) which hits similar notes but in a typically “British reserve” way. This film – and that one – find the perfect way to show how upheavals like war etc touch peoples lives in ways they could never expect, and show that we haven’t necessarily got tomorrow. Best Years of Their Lives does the same in a deeper darker way. Keep reviewing, God Bless, John Tate
April 2nd, 2013 at 2:56 pm
I WOULD LIKE TO OBTAIN THE MOVIE….YOU CAME ALONG..
April 2nd, 2013 at 3:01 pm
Dorothy
It’s not been commercially released but copies are easy to come by. Simply Google YOU CAME ALONG DVD, and you’ll find several sellers who have it.