Tue 10 Nov 2009
JOSEPH CONRAD – Victory: An Island Tale. Doubleday Page & Co., 1915. First Edition (shown immediately below). Reprinted many times, in both hardcover and soft.
We all have our instants of clairvoyance. They are not very helpful. The character of the scheme does not permit that or anything else to be helpful. Properly speaking the character judged by the standards established by its victims, is infamous. It excuses every violence of protest and at the same time never fails to crush it, just as it crushes the blindest assent. The so-called wickedness must be, like the so called virtue, it’s own reward …
Victory was the first of Conrad’s great works and his first popular success. It is also in many ways a crime novel that might well have come from Dashiell Hammett or out of Black Mask magazine.
We tend to think of Conrad in terms of serious literature and forget that he wrote adventure stories (Lord Jim, The Arrow of Gold, and Nostromo), spy novels (The Secret Agent) political novels (Under Western Eyes), science fiction (The Inheritors with Ford Madox Ford), historical fiction (Romance again with Ford), and even domestic drama (Chance).
Victory , set in the islands of the Malay Archipelago is the story of Axel Heyst, a mysterious and solitary Swede (“…Heyst, the wanderer of the Archipelago, had a taste for silence …”) who sets the actions of a tragedy in motion when he saves a young English woman from her predatory employer, the German hotelier Schomberg.
Heyst retreats to his home on remote Samburan with the girl, and Schomberg’s wrath, is brought to a head by the arrival of the mysterious Mr. Jones, his “secretary,” the violent Martin Ricardo, and Pedro the brutish animal like Portuguese half cast alligator hunter from Columbia.
It is to these three that Schomberg entrusts his mission of revenge against Heyst and the woman with rumors of the riches the mysterious Heyst is alleged to have hidden on his remote island.
It’s hard to read the novel today without visions of The Maltese Falcon and Gasper Gutman. Joel, Cairo, and Wilbur. There are hints of something unwholesome and perverse between Jones and Ricardo, and a suggestion of crimes unspoken. “Wickedness for it’s own reward.”
Jones is virtually the model for the suave educated villains we have seen in a thousand books and films, but with something both decadent and perverse in his genteel shabbiness. Ricardo, his violent nature barely repressed, is another familiar figure.
When Jones and his team arrive on Samburan the events of the tragedy, the plots of the criminals and the personal drama between Heyst and the woman plunge toward a violent bloodbath (“… there are more dead in this affair — more white people, I mean — than have been killed in many of the battles of the last Achin war.”).
Victory isn’t a thriller by any means, or a crime novel. It is dense and character driven, and by no means a quick or simple read, but it does present a fascinating portrait of evil and in Heyst and the woman he loves almost noirish prototypes.
And yet though the fate of Heyst and the woman are tragic, the fact that they find love and finally come together makes the novels title true rather than ironic.
Ultimately they triumph over both the villains and themselves. Their human triumph over the forces of crime and brutality is a victory.
The 1940 John Cromwell film of Victory is not available on VHS or DVD, but should be. Frederic March and Betty Field play Heyst and the woman, and Sir Cedric Hardwicke, Jerome Cowan, and Sig Ruman Jones, Ricardo, and Schomberg. Hardwicke and Cowan are especially chilling. It was also filmed in 1919 and 1930 (as Dangerous Passage).
November 10th, 2009 at 4:53 pm
David, Have you or anyone else seen the 1995 movie, the one with Willem Dafoe, Sam Neill, Irène Jacob, and Rufus Sewell? The reviews I’ve seen have been fairly positive, and yet the movie gets only 6 stars out of 10 on IMDB.
I’ve yet to see it myself, but with a little push in the right direction, I think I’d move it up in my To Be Watched pile.
— Steve
November 10th, 2009 at 4:58 pm
My favorite Conrad.
The ’95 film is quite nice, with Sam Neill and Rufus Sewell an engaging pair of baddies, though Dafoe looks too Christ-like.
The silent version is also worth seeing for Chaney’s scene-stealing villain.
November 10th, 2009 at 5:00 pm
One of the best books on the films of the 40s described Cromwell’s VICTORY as a quintessential film of that decade.
November 10th, 2009 at 6:19 pm
I’ve always admired Conrad’s work and have read most of it. I even have the signed Collected edition of his work. VICTORY is one of my favorites and I’ve read it three times over the years.
I also bought many of the Conrad biographies and have his Collected Letters even though the cover price was over $100 for each book. I think he’s in the running for best novelist in the English language, which was his third language behind Polish and French. Didn’t really start writing until late in life and spent 20 years as a sailor rising to Captain. Amazing life.
By the way, he is even a pulp writer, being serialized in ROMANCE, 1920. It was briefly a companion pulp to ADVENTURE.
November 10th, 2009 at 6:25 pm
Steve, concerning the movie VICTORY with Dafoe, I liked it. Amazon.com has five favorable comments and a copy is available used for $1.80 plus 3.00 shipping.
November 10th, 2009 at 6:28 pm
Steve
I haven’t seen the ’95 film, and to be honest, despite that cast I’d like to see a really good print of the Cromwell version first. It has become one of those legendary films on a lot of lists.
Dan
I think I read the same book as you that went on in some detail about the Cromwell film and its import.
All things considered it’s a bit hard for Dafoe to escape ‘Christ like’ considering Last Temptation, though I can’t say there is anything in Conrad’s character that is messianic in any way.
Victory isn’t my favorite Conrad, but it is a good one, and in some ways one of the most accessible. As I said it is structured much like a crime novel, and develops a good deal like one. Still, the first time I read it I was reminded of Hammett, and more so after I read that first Conradian South Sea’s story of Hammett’s.
November 11th, 2009 at 12:33 am
Walker
When a DVD is going for $1.80 on Amazon, should we take that as a good omen, or not?
David
I’ve looked around a little, and while you’re right about there being no signs of the 1940 movie version, I did come across an earlier one, a silent film, on DVD. It was probably the one from 1919, though I forgot to make a note of that while I was “surfing.”
November 11th, 2009 at 1:44 pm
I think prints of Victory exist, but for some reason it has never been on VHS or DVD. Can’t imagine why. Cromwell was a major director and certainly that’s an important cast. Likely the silent was the one with Lon Chaney.
Look at it this way, a video for $1.80 on AMAZON can be a good omen for us, even if it isn’t for the movie.
November 12th, 2009 at 3:21 pm
David–
What makes you think prints of the 1940 VICTORY exist and how soon can you get me one?
Dan
November 12th, 2009 at 5:56 pm
Dan, the 1940 VICTORY does indeed exist and I’m looking at my copy now. It’s a bootleg dvd, never officially released. Unfortunately the dealer I bought it from for only $5.00 has been forced to close his website, probably for copyright violations. It’s a shame because he had practically every old movie not on a commercial vhs or dvd. But keep your eye out on the bootleg market. It does exist.
December 16th, 2009 at 5:09 pm
I too would love to see the 1940 Cromwell version of Victory. I love the book and saw the 1940 version on British TV one night maybe 20 years ago. I`d love to see it again. I remember it being true to the book and looked great, capturing the atmosphere of the book and the characters.
November 19th, 2010 at 4:53 pm
Finally found the ’40 version on ioffer.com!
November 19th, 2010 at 4:59 pm
Sometimes you just have to be lucky when you’re looking for stuff on ioffer. Many of the sellers I bought from last year aren’t around any longer (*), but there always seem to be new sellers who come along, and lots of times they bring rare movies with them.
(*) And yes, I know. Good luck on replacing bad disks.