Mon 1 Feb 2010
Movie Review: NINE GIRLS (1944).
Posted by Steve under Films: Comedy/Musicals , Mystery movies , Reviews[7] Comments
NINE GIRLS. Columbia, 1944. Ann Harding, Evelyn Keyes, Jinx Falkenburg, Anita Louise, Leslie Brooks, Lynn Merrick, Jeff Donnell, Nina Foch, Shirley Mills, Marcia Mae Jones, Willard Robertson, William Demarest. Based on the play by Wilfred H. Pettitt. Director: Leigh Jason.
Supposing that you knew that tomboyish Jeff Donnell was sometimes billed as “Miss Jeff Donnell,” or that she played George Gobel’s wife ‘spooky old’ Alice on The George Gobel Show in the mid-1950s, I wouldn’t blame you if you counted up the number of female stars in this movie and found that there were ten. (Alice, by the way, was neither spooky nor old.)
There is an easy explanation, of course. The nine girls of the title are sorority sisters (including two soon to be pledged), while Ann Harding plays Miss Thornton, their favorite teacher and sorority mother. Anita Louise (playing Paula) has the shortest role in the movie. She’s one of those ultra-cultured creatures who manages to make herself intensely disliked if not hated by each of the other eight girls, and hardly above a little non-sisterly blackmail to get her way.
Willard Robertson is the State Police officer who investigates Paula’s murder (if you ever see the movie, you will know how infinitely inevitable that event is), while William Demarest plays his dim-witted (and leering) assistant. There is quite a bit to leer at in the movie, too, as all of the girls have quite a variety of clothes to wear, including swim suits. I can’t tell you that this movie, made on a small B-movie budget, was a smash hit at the box office, but with nine girls in it, if it was, I can tell you who the attractions were.
What I can’t tell you is which girl played what part. Some, those who had larger roles, I can, if you’re interested, but Evelyn Keyes (of Johnny O’Clock fame, among others) had a large portion of the dialogue, and so did tall statuesque Jinx Falkenburg, who probably had the shortest movie career of any of them.
Lynn Merrick, whom I didn’t know before now, does a smash-up imitation of Katharine Hepburn, but only when there’s a man in the vicinity.
Nina Foch (also later in Johnny O’Clock) did not have a high billing this early in her career, but she was perhaps the most noticeable of the eight girls, all suspects, cooped up together in a vacation lodge while the police do their thing. (She’s the mousy girl with glasses who was forced by the dead girl to write papers for her.)
Personally, from the mystery end of things, I think the killer’s identity was revealed 10 or 15 minutes too early, but on the other hand, detection in an isolated manor house is or was not the primary reason this movie was made. View it as a light-hearted high spirited comedy instead, with lots of spooky moments during the night and silly antics and corny jokes all of the rest of time.
If you enjoy silly antics and corny jokes, you’ll like this movie as much as I did.
February 1st, 2010 at 3:55 pm
Very nice review of this entertaining film, Steve. Leigh Jason was one of my directorial discoveries at a film convention a few years ago , and his films (the ones that I’ve seen) are uniformly fun to watch. His light touch is perfectly suited to his material, and he’s very good with actors. I’ve reviewed the films of his I’ve seen, but until the day I compile an index of my reviews they’re buried somewhere in my apa files.
February 1st, 2010 at 6:18 pm
Looking through Jason’s credits, I see that one I didn’t care for, THREE GIRLS ABOUT TOWN (1941), another comedy-cum-murder case, and reviewed here: https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=1477 . Maybe I wasn’t feeling all that sprightly at the time?
But among the rest of the films he directed, there’s one that really stands out. It’s THE MAD MISS MANTON (1938), which I haven’t seen in quite a while, but I remember it as being very stylish and very enjoyable. Perhaps the screwball mystery was one of his specialties…?
— Steve
February 2nd, 2010 at 7:24 am
You’re right; MANTON is lots of fun, particularly seeing Stanwyck and Fonda getting into the spirit of the thing.
March 12th, 2013 at 11:09 am
I can not find the film to buy, but would love to know the name of the actress, who played the killer. I saw it back in early TV and would love to purchase it….Russ
March 12th, 2013 at 1:16 pm
Russ
Searching the Internet should turn up a collector-to-collector copy. Try ioffer.com and sell.com, as well as eBay.
Unfortunately, at this late date, over three years later, I do not remember who the killer was. I know some people do, but I simply don’t have that kind of mind. Once the review is written, all too soon that will be all I remember of the movie, and that’s the case here.
March 23rd, 2013 at 10:47 am
I have never seen this movie or play but am wondering if at any time they mention the sorority they are a part of or if in the play there is a sorority mentioned? I just wanted to know as well if this was based on an actual sorority. THanks
March 23rd, 2013 at 2:50 pm
I saw the movie too long ago to remember. Perhaps someone else who’s seen it more recently will reply…?
— Steve