Sat 23 Aug 2014
Review: RHYS BOWEN – The Twelve Clues of Christmas.
Posted by Steve under Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Characters , Reviews[5] Comments
RHYS BOWEN – The Twelve Clues of Christmas. Berkley, hardcover, November 2012; paperback, November 2013.
Lady Georgianna Rannoch, who tells the story, is 34th (or 35th; sources differ) in line to the throne of England, but due to various misfortunes, none of her own doing, she is dependent on the good will of others, especially at the beginning of Clues that of her sister-in-law, the Duchess of Rannoch, commonly known as Fig, as to her overall welfare and a roof over her head.
Determined not to spend Christmas at the ancestral (and austere) Rannoch castle where she is not particularly welcome, Georgie answers an ad in a magazine to act as a social director for a lengthy Christmas house party in Devonshire. Her application is accepted almost at once, and it is goodbye to winter in gloomy Scotland even more quickly.
Turns out, as it so often does in fiction if not real life, that her mother, a flighty lady and a sometimes actress who abandoned Georgie at very young age, is staying in a nearby cottage with none other than Noel Coward. (There is no ill feeling between Georgie and her mother. The former has learned to accept her for who she is.) And as it also turns out, Georgie’s good friend, the adventurous Mr. Darcy O’Mara, is on hand as well.
As in cozy mystery fiction of which this is a fine example, Georgie’s personal life, family relationships and the like take up a sizable percentage of the story. There is a murder involved, or in fact a whole series of them. Or perhaps I should take that back. There is a whole series of strange deaths that occur, all of which appear accidental, nor is there any apparent connection between them.
We, the reader, know better. It is a murderous scheme on the part of someone, a plan worthy of a villain in an Agatha Christie or Ellery Queen detective story, but without a detective on hand to solve it. With the local police inspector barely up to the job, it is up to the purely amateur efforts of Lady Georgianna, and the sometimes assistance of Darcy, to come up with killer or killers.
The Twelve Clues of Christmas is fun to read, and is chock full of various Christmas customs of England in the 1930s, but the detective plot certainly could have been filled out more. It’s clever to begin with, but the details become more and more sketchy as time goes on. In fact, the connection between the deaths is discovered with more than 70 pages to go, leaving only Georgie’s kidnapping (and a couple of gruesome deaths) to fill in most of the rest of the novel.
The Royal Spyness series —
1. Her Royal Spyness (2007)
2. A Royal Pain (2008)
3. Royal Flush (2009)
4. Royal Blood (2010)
5. Naughty In Nice (2011)
5.5. Masked Ball at Broxley Manor (novella, 2012)
6. The Twelve Clues of Christmas (2012)
7. Heirs and Graces (2013)
8. Queen of Hearts (2014)
August 23rd, 2014 at 5:19 pm
The recent birth of an heir to her brother bumped her from 34 to 35th in line to the throne. It’s a recent development.
August 23rd, 2014 at 6:21 pm
Thanks, beb. This is the first in the series I’ve read, so I didn’t know that!
August 23rd, 2014 at 9:49 pm
Several of these series in this vein and aimed at women audiences are more romantic thrillers in the Elizbeth Peters vein than mysteries per se. Whodunnit takes a back seat to the customs, relationships, and romance though the violence can be more intense than you might expect.
They can be witty and well written, but however close they hove to Agatha Christie country they are really closer to the early books like THE MAN IN THE BROWN SUIT and THE SECRET OF HIGH CHIMINEY’S than the complex mystery novels of the later era.
Actually 34th or 35th is pretty high up on the list for succession and it is not always as straight forward as it seems. After all, they skipped the Stuart’s entirely when William and Mary were gone and went all the way to what is now Germany for the current lot.
Politics can play as much a role as bloodline.
Sounds like a good set up for a female version of KIND HEARTS AND CORONETS though.
I may check these out just because they sound like entertaining light reading with a pleasant period flare, and the covers look attractive).
I wonder if Lady Georgianna ever runs into Albert Campion (a much closer heir) at family reunions?
August 23rd, 2014 at 10:47 pm
David
Your first paragraph is right on. A cheery Christmas setting and any number of deaths, some very graphic, that’s what you get with this one.
And you’re absolutely right about the covers, They make the books very hard to resist. So much so that I ought to mention the artist. It’s John Mattos, and here’s his website:
http://www.johnmattos.com/
He does great work.
August 24th, 2014 at 12:17 am
Hard to resist.