Wed 29 Oct 2014
Jonathan Lewis Reviews Two for Halloween: DR. RENAULT’S SECRET & DR. FU MANCHU.
Posted by Steve under Horror movies , Reviews , TV mysteries[6] Comments
DR. RENAULT’S SECRET. 20th Century Fox, 1942. J. Carrol Naish, John Shepperd, Lynne Roberts, George Zucco. Director: Harry Lachman.
“THE MASTER PLAN OF DR. FU MANCHU.” An episode of The Adventures of Dr. Fu Manchu. Original air date: 2 June 1956. Glen Gordon (Dr. Fu Manchu), Lester Matthews (Sir Dennis Nayland Smith) Clark Howat (Dr. John Petrie), Carla Balenda, Laurette Luez, John George. Guest Cast: Alan Dexter, Steven Geray (Mr. X). Based on characters created by Sax Rohmer. Director: William Witney.
One of the most terrifying tasks (in a good way) that a successful horror/thriller director can do is to transport the viewer into a claustrophobic, eerie, and self-enclosed celluloid universe in which evil both lurks in the shadows and hides in plain sight. And you don’t even need an oversized budget to do it and to do it extraordinarily well.
The trick, it would seem, is to keep the running time short, the atmosphere creepy, and the plot concerned with human physicality gone awry.
Such is the case for two gems I watched this Halloween week.
The first, Dr. Renault’s Secret, stars J. Carrol Naish and George Zucco in a cinematic admonition against tampering with the evolutionary demarcation that separates man from ape. Zucco portrays the eponymous Dr. Renault, an egotistical, sadistic, and downright creepy French scientist with a beautiful niece, Madeline (Lynne Roberts).
Naish, in a chillingly sinister role, portrays Noel, Renault’s simian-like assistant, a man of unbridled rage and murderous intent. From the moment you see him lurk about on the screen, you know there’s something just so terribly not normal about this tragic character. John Sheppard rounds out the main players as Dr. Larry Forbes, Madeline Renault’s American fiance.
Directed by Harry Lachman, Dr. Renault’s Secret has that I-know-it-when-I see-it film noir aspect to it. Light and shadow are utilized to convey meaning, there are numerous camera shots from oddly distinct angles, and Noel can certainly be considered to be the film’s doomed protagonist, a man trapped in an out-of-control world.
Also look for the noir-like mise-en-scene, the numerous staircases, doorways, and pathways that play prominent roles in conveying a story about Renault’s psychological descent into madness and Noel’s descent into savagery.
In “The Master Plan of Dr. Fu Manchu,†an episode of the television show, The Adventures of Dr. Fu Manchu, a physician is pressured into performing plastic surgery on a man long thought dead but who is very much alive: Adolf Hitler.
Fu Manchu, Satan incarnate, kidnaps Dr. Harlow Henderson, a friend of Petrie, and under the threat of torture, forces him to change the face of Hitler into the visage of an ordinary looking man, a person of unspeakable evil who could then safely hide in plain sight.
Directed by William Witney, this thrilling episode has it all: murder by tarantula, Cold War paranoia, Nazis in an underground South Pacific hideaway, and the psychologically discomforting notion that physicians, with the use of surgical implements, could fundamentally re-alter a man’s physical identity.
The last five minutes or so of this episode showcase Witney’s strength as a director of action sequences. After all, we get the thrill of witnessing Smith shoot and kill Hitler!
October 29th, 2014 at 3:36 pm
The idea of plastic surgery and Nazism was also explored, to a much less satisfying effect, in BLACK DRAGONS (1942) starring Bela Lugosi as a Nazi plastic surgeon tasked with transforming Japanese spies into looking like White Americans. It was an interesting premise and could have worked, but ultimately it didn’t.
October 29th, 2014 at 4:19 pm
This was the only episode of the Fu Manchu series that I saw when it was first aired. It greatly impressed my nine-year-old self! Seeing other episodes of that quickly cancelled series when I was much older did not impress me as much. Go figure.
October 29th, 2014 at 4:54 pm
I don’t know when plastic surgery first appeared as a plot device, though it was well established by the forties. It was often accompanied with amnesia as in SOMEWHERE IN THE NIGHT and one of my favorite books Holly Roth’s THE MASK OF GLASS.
RENAULT benefits from better production and a solid cast including I see Arthur Shields, a fellow Dublin theater performer along with Naish as well as Barry Fitzgerald’s brother and the Little Old Wine Maker of commercial fame.
Glen Gordon’s stocky Fu Manchu and the bad makeup always hurt this series for me. You could always count on a good fight at the end thanks to Witney though and he did codirect the serial THE DRUMS OF FU MANCHU with John English. Even without Tom Steele and Dave Sharpe he could still stage a good brawl.
I’ll check this one out, though over all the series usually disappoints me. I would like to see that famous pilot for another Fu Manchu series though with Cedric Hardwicke as Smith and John Carradine as the Devil Doctor.
October 29th, 2014 at 6:46 pm
I can’t say Glen Gordon is my favorite Fu Manchu. He seems to have a very narrow range of speech and mannerisms, though he does have a presence. The actress who portrays Karamaneh has an exotic air to her. I believe she was in KIM with Errol Flynn
October 30th, 2014 at 5:12 pm
DR. RENAULT is visually quite nice (as one would expect from Lachman) well-paced and marvelously performed if you can accept George Zucco, Mike Mazurki and Arthur Shields(!) as Frenchmen.
Lachman also directed my favorite Charlie Can film, CASTLE IN THE DESERT
November 1st, 2014 at 3:53 pm
Jonathan,
Yes, the noir aspects of DR. RENAULT are definitely strong. “Film noirror” might be a good, though clumsy, term for it.