Fri 13 Jul 2007
Inquiry: MAURICE COONS aka ARMITAGE TRAIL.
Posted by Steve under Authors , Crime Fiction IV , Inquiries[9] Comments
Hi Steve,
Please find below a brief biography (well, the only one I have found) on the writer who, as Armitage Trail, wrote the novel Scarface.
I wonder if anyone has ever done any research to track down the pseudonymous work mentioned in it. I asked Victor Berch who knows little more — apparently he could not even find him in the census for the years he was alive. (Apparently his brother, also difficult to trace in official records, wrote over 20 episodes for the Addams Family [television show] amongst other work).
Just wonder if he is worth putting in your blog to see if anyone can add to the bio?
John Herrington
Armitage Trail was a pseudonym for the American author Maurice Coons. The son of a theatrical impresario who managed the road tours of the New Orleans Opera Company, and also manufactured furniture and farm silos, Maurice Coons left school at 16 to devote all his time to writing stories. By 17 or 18, he was already selling stories to magazines. By his early twenties he was writing whole issues of various detective-story magazines under a great assortment of various names. And at 28 — after going to New York to write more stories, and from there to Hollywood to write movies — he dropped dead of a heart attack at the downtown Paramount Theatre in Los Angeles.
At the time of his death, he weighed 315 pounds, had a flowing brown moustache, and wore Barrymore-brim Borsalina hats. He was survived by his brother, humorous writer Hannibal Coons.
Maurice Coons gathered the elements for Scarface when living in Chicago, where he became acquainted with many local Sicilian gangs. For a couple of years, Coons spent most of his nights prowling Chicago’s gangland with his friend, a lawyer, and spent his days sitting in the sun room of his Oak Park apartment writing Scarface. He never did meet Al Capone, who was the inspiration for his immortal character, though Capone was very much alive when his book was published.
When Howard Hughes was making plans to produce the movie, Coons wanted Edward G. Robinson to play the leading role because of his resemblance to Capone but being Hollywood, it ended up with Paul [Muni] playing Scarface, a different-looking sort of man altogether. The author did not live to see the picture, but Al Capone did, and screenwriter Ben Hecht had to talk fast to convince his henchmen that Scarface was not based on him. Scarface was also made into a film in 1983, directed by Brian de Palma and starring AI Pacino. Armitage Trail’s only other surviving novel is The Thirteenth Guest ( 1929). Both his novels prefigure the birth of hard-boiled fiction and Black Mask magazine.
From Crime Fiction IV, by Allen J. Hubin:
COONS, MAURICE (1902-1930); see pseudonym Armitage Trail.
TRAIL, ARMITAGE; pseudonym of Maurice Coons.
* * Scarface (Clode, 1930, hc) [Chicago, IL] Long, 1931. Film: United Artists, 1932 (scw: Fred Palsey, W. R. Burnett, John Lee Mahin, Seton I. Miller, Ben Hecht; dir: Howard Hawks). Also: Universal, 1983 (scw: Oliver Stone; dir: Brian De Palma).
* * The Thirteenth Guest (Whitman, 1929, hc) Film: Monogram, 1932 (scw: Francis Hyland, Arthur Hoerl, Armitage Trail; dir: Albert Ray). Also: Monogram, 1943, as Mystery of the Thirteenth Guest (scw: Charles Marlon, Tim Ryan, Arthur Hoerl; dir: William Beaudine).
July 14th, 2007 at 3:33 am
I can add a little on Maurice R. Coons. He was born in Nebraska, the son of Oscar Athol Coons (1874-1946) and Alice Lucille Coons.
His brother, although known as Hannibal Coons, was born Stanley J. Coons in Missouri on 26 March 1909. Died 29 April 1977.
July 14th, 2007 at 11:16 am
Paul Muni, not Paul Moon, played the main character in the film Scarface (1932).
>> Thanks, John. The error slipped right on by, but the correction’s been made already. — Steve
July 24th, 2012 at 12:32 am
Great stuff on Maurice Coons aka Armitage Trail.
Hell of a guy, hell of a writer.
Should not be forgotten, particularly by those of us who write.
And yes, Edward G. Robinson should have been cast as Al Capone; except for the height, they did look alike.
But Paul Muni did the job, all through his career.
April 14th, 2014 at 11:11 pm
Maurice and Hannibal coons were my mother’s first cousins. I have a detailed genealogy of the family.
August 2nd, 2014 at 12:10 pm
Are there any extant pictures of Maurice aka Armitage? We are putting on A Visist From Scarface and one of the props is a newspaper obit about Maurice’s death. I would like to put a picture on the obit we are printing for the play. The play starts on Tuesday, August 5th, 2014 and I know this is late notice, but I and Pioneer Playhouse from Danville, Kentucky would be very thankful.
September 23rd, 2014 at 4:52 pm
I, in no way whatsoever, intend to cast any dispersions here; but, there are a couple of statements made in the last sentence of this article that are simply not true.
Steve wrote: “Both his novels prefigure the birth of hard-boiled fiction and Black Mask magazine.”
BLACK MASK magazine began in 1920, that is nine years before Trail/Coons’ books appeared.
Also, Carroll John Daly’s THE FALSE BURTON COMBS–the story that is most widely attributed to giving birth to the hard-boiled school of writing–was published (in BLACK MASK) in 1922. Hammett’s first BLACK MASK story (THE ROAD HOME) also appeared in 1922. That’s seven years before SCARFACE or THE THIRTEENTH GUEST.
I love Trail’s (or Coons’, if you prefer) books a great deal, by the way, but they did not prefigure BLACK MASK, etc., as stated.
All the best,
Chris
September 23rd, 2014 at 5:54 pm
All corrections welcome, Chris. Thanks!
September 23rd, 2014 at 8:07 pm
You’re welcome, Steve!
I am glad to know that corrections are welcome. I was worried you might take exception to mine and I certainly didn’t want to offend you or anyone else here, for that matter. Love your blog!
Sincerely,
Chris
June 25th, 2023 at 10:43 pm
[…] Armitage Trail, the pen name of Maurice Coons, died aged 28 in 1930, the same year he published Scarface and sold the film rights to Howard Hughes for 25 grand. Immediately moving to Hollywood, screenwriter W.R. Burnett relates that Trail drank heavily and lived flamboyantly, getting fat, wearing wide-brimmed Borsalino hats, and hiring a servant, only to die of congestive heart failure in the Paramount Theatre. The only info I found on him was on Wikipedia (if you can call that a source) and this great website I happened upon: https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=303 […]