Thu 16 Apr 2015
Reviewed by David Vineyard: HOWARD ANDREW JONES – The Desert of Souls.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[9] Comments
HOWARD ANDREW JONES – The Desert of Souls. Thomas Dunne Books, hardcover. February 2011. St. Martin’s, trade paperback, January 2012.
Arabian nights and swords and sorcery may not be the usual fodder for this site, but when they are also a detective story and thriller along Conan Doyle lines, then something new is going on.
If it were possible to modify the word unique in the English language, this one would be “uniquer.”
The time is the eighth century. The place Baghdad, the Baghdad of legend and myth under the wise rule of the most famous of the fabled cities leaders, Haroun al Rashid, the caliph of the Arabian nights, Ali Baba, Sinbad, Scherezade, the Old Man of the Mountain, the Hashishin, and wine drinking poet and mathematician Omar Khayyam. It is also the ancient Persia of cruel and unpredictable djinn, sorcery, mythical creatures, and imagination.
This really should not work on any level, but Jones proves a clever storyteller and puts us in the hands of a swashbuckling Watson, in the able Captain Asim — more Archie Goodwin than Watson in most aspects — who keeps the reader grounded like all good Watson’s should, as Hamil the poet tells him: “A good storyteller tailors his story to his audience.â€
And if there is a Watson that means there is a Holmes, in this case the scholar Dagbir, who has a bad habit of speaking truth to power. As might be expected we first meet him in relation to a murder: The case of the murdered parrot.
Pago belongs to Asim’s master Jaffar, the grand vizier (another actual historical figure), and Azim calls upon Dagbir to help distract the distraught Jaffar with a incognito journey into the city. Well disguised Jaffar, Asim, and Dagbir set out of their adventure and visit a seeress in the poorest part of town where they are told Dagbir will be famed as a slayer of monsters, Asim for his tales of Dagbir’s adventures, and Jaffar will lose his head to a woman to high for his station — literally lose his head.
Leaving the seeress, a bleeding man stumbles into their arms followed by his pursuers which they quickly dispatch, leading to a jeweled tablet that holds the secret of the Atlantis of the sands, the lost city of Ubar.
Before they can get far though, the tablet is stolen by a Greek spy and Firouz, a fire wizard, and Jaffar dismisses Dagbir assuming that the seeress confused him with the scholar who has been privately treating Jaffar’s neice, Sabirah, who is none to happy with Asim who she blames for Dagbir’s dismissal.
And we are off for high adventure, low intrigue, and some good detection though this is hardly a detective story, what with djinn and giant talkative feather serpents who guard the secrets of the sands. At stake are not only the lives of Asim, Dagbir, and Dagbir’s love Sabirah, the niece of Jaffar and forbidden to the scholar, but the soul of Baghdad itself, the target of Firouz madness.
Howard Andrew Jones is a leading expert on Harold Lamb (having edited two volumes of Lamb’s Arabian tales, Swords from the West and Swords of the Desert), whose tales, along with Robert E. Howard, and Talbot Mundy inspired this tale, but Jones wisely chooses a modern voice for his narrator eschewing any labored thee’s, thou’s, and thy’s for a crisp fast moving narrative with a capable and fast thinking narrator who just doesn’t happen to be as clever as Dagbir, but who is an amiable hero on his own, and adds a touch of Conan Doyle and Sherlock Holmes to the mix.
The result is a clever mix of sword and sorcery staples, historical fiction in the Lamb and Howard style, modern thriller, and an unusual Sherlockian adventure. This is one of those remarkably good-natured books that a few pages in you find yourself wanting to give the benefit of the doubt and simply enjoy.
I’m reminded of Elizabeth Peter’s Amelia Peabody books or Will Thomas historical thrillers in that you just want to relax and enjoy the ride without thinking about it. Books that entertain on that level are too far between these days — I suppose they always were.
“Cleave close to your friend,†a seeress tells Asim at the end, “He will need you and the world will have need of you both.â€
I certainly hope so. This doesn’t just bend the genres it apes, it ties them in knots and creates something new and original. It’s a flying carpet ride of a novel in glorious Technicolor.
April 16th, 2015 at 10:11 pm
Thanks, David. This is one that I’d never heard of before you sent me this review. I’ll have to keep an eye out for it, no doubt about it.
April 17th, 2015 at 6:57 pm
A sequel came out in hardcover in 2012, The Bones of the Old Ones. Reviewers on Amazon also point out the Holmes-Watson connection, only in in 8th Century Baghdad.
Says one: “The settings of each scene were fantastic (in all senses of the word): tombs, and mountains, and temples, and ruins, and cities, and magic carpets. The tenor of the book was as unabashedly romantic as it was heroic and sorcerous. The fight scenes were gorgeously executed and constantly interesting – and the pacing of the entire plot was smashing.
“I can’t wait for the third.”
April 17th, 2015 at 7:03 pm
It doesn’t seem that a third in the series, has appeared, yet, but The Waters of Eternity, a collection of short adventures of the pair, is available (only) on the Kindle. Too bad for me.
April 17th, 2015 at 8:25 pm
The second one is mentioned in the trade paperback edition. Hopefully sales were good enough for a few more, but if not, these are still great fun in the way the old Columbia Maria Montez/Jon Hall/Cornell Wilde films were — only with Basil Rathbone thrown in.
There are quite a few fantasy and sf series now with the setting or a faux Arabian nights world. Seems a bit odd with everyone so concerned about things in that part of the world, but readers are curious things. Mr. Moto was hugely popular while the world was bemoaning Japan’s war crimes in China.
You would have thought all the vaguely Germanic Ruritanian* and Graustark business would have suffered with WWI and the rise of Nazi Germany, but all the Prussian hair cuts, dueling scars, and heel clicking officers never seem effected.
Clever ideas are a dime a dozen, but not this well executed.
*Hope (Hawkins) actually intended Ruritania to be Scandinavian and not Middle European or Germanic, but from the John Balderston play onward no one seems to have listened.
April 17th, 2015 at 8:53 pm
I just purchased an inexpensive but new copy of the first one from an eBay seller, in paperback. Couldn’t resist.
April 18th, 2015 at 12:34 pm
Great book.And as I mentioned on my “Book Covers I Love” Pinterest board, I love how the cover illustrator managed to combine a frozen moment in time AND a kinesthetic sense as the swordsman floats in air…
April 21st, 2015 at 9:34 am
[…] once in a while nice surprises float up from the ‘net. I just read an enthusiastic new review of The Desert of Souls from a mystery review site, and there’s discussion in the comments […]
April 21st, 2015 at 1:52 pm
Howard, When you read this, I hope you don’t mind my quoting more from the blogpost above:
“…there’s discussion in the comments page wondering if there are to be more stories about Dabir and Asim.
“Well… Sooner or later there probably will be. Certainly my wife would love me to write more, because she likes Dabir and Asim more than any other characters I’ve ever used, even the ones I’m writing about now. At the least, I’ll one day write a third novel and resolve what happens between Dabir and the love of his life, from whom he was separated at the end of the first book. Maybe I’ll launch it as a Kickstarter or something.
“Alas, the first book didn’t sell that well. The second, despite even stronger reviews, including a starred review from Publisher’s Weekly (and I was SURE that would guarantee good things for the series!) sold even more poorly. You can gauge this by dashing over to Amazon and comparing the number of reviews for each book.”
For more: http://www.howardandrewjones.com/writing/return-to-the-desert-of-souls
April 22nd, 2015 at 2:38 pm
Steve,
Thanks for pointing this out to me. Hopefully we will see more of the series eventually.
I assumed the sales hadn’t been great since I purchased the paper edition remaindered at a Hasting.