Fri 8 Jan 2016
A Movie Review by Dan Stumpf: ENEMY OF WOMEN (1944).
Posted by Steve under Films: Drama/Romance , Reviews , War Films[2] Comments
ENEMY OF WOMEN. Monogram, 1944. Re-released as The Mad Lover. Wolfgang Zilzner (as Paul Andor), Claudia Drake, Donald Woods, H. B. Warner, Ralph Morgan, Gloria Stuart, Robert Barra, Byron Foulger. Written and directed by Alfred Zeisler.
A real oddity.
An independent production picked up and distributed by Monogram, this was written and directed by Alfred Zeisler, who was born in Chicago but rose to prominence in the German film industry of the 1920s and 30s, with memorable hits like Gold (1934) and Viktor und Viktoria (1933) on his resume. Like many other talents, he was forced out of Germany with the rise of the Nazis and ended up back in America, where he worked mostly on “B†products like this story of the rise and (anticipated) fall of Paul Joseph Goebbels, Hitler’s Minister of Propaganda and brief successor.
Given that background, one would expect a strident film here, but Enemy is surprisingly restrained, even gentle at times. It doesn’t try to make Goebbels sympathetic or even likable, and yet ….
Goebbels is played by Wolfgang Zilzner, an actor usually cast as a sinister Nazi underling in films like Invisible Agent and All Through the Night; the guy standing behind Peter Lorre, with a sullen look and no lines. But here he’s the star, and the film opens on him, with a smooth night-time tracking shot in the rubble of a recently-bombed Berlin neighborhood (tellingly evoked by photographer John Alton, one of the architects of film noir.) Goebbels’ car arrives on the scene and he enters one of the smoldering ruins, preparing a radio broadcast to the effect that the damage was “negligible†but there’s something strange about his manner, and as he slumps into what’s left of a chair, we flash back ….
What follows is a rather staid account of the fortunes of Joseph Goebbels, starting off with him as a tutor spurned by his young student (Claudia Drake, the woman no one remembers in Detour) and hooking up with the rising Nazi Party more to recover his self-esteem than from any political conviction.
There are some understated (and economical) vignettes as Goebbels takes power and publishers and broadcasters find themselves out of work or under arrest, usually done in a single scene on one set—an approach that heightens the sense of ruthless Nazi efficiency and saves money at the same time—and a surprisingly lavish bit at a swanky party used by Goebbels to push more propaganda.
There’s also an unexpected and quite suspenseful sequence where he finds himself scheduled for a visit from the SS and has to get next to Hitler before he can be spirited away by his rivals. It’s one of those moments like the car-sinking scene in Psycho where the viewer finds himself suddenly identifying with a killer.
In fact, as Enemy of Women goes on, it becomes less about the Nazis and more about Goebbels’ ruthless pursuit of the woman he loves (the Claudia Drake character) a pursuit punctuated by murder, kidnapping and detention, but with none of the gloating villains or noble martyrs so common in movies those days.
The conclusion is skillfully and intentionally tipped off ahead of time as we suddenly recognize the room where Claudia Drake awaits her unwanted lover and this becomes, of all things, a story of losing the thing one loves by trying to possess it. The flashback ends as the master propagandist of the Third Reich delivers his prepared lies, and his close-up reveals the face of a man who realizes he is the herald of a fallen angel.
No, there are no brave patriots here, no stirring speeches or beastly villains, but despite the trashy title, Enemy of Women hits its target by humanizing it.
January 10th, 2016 at 3:07 am
I don’t know what is stranger, the subject, the handling, or the posters selling it. Only the modern DVD cover even suggests this is about Nazis outside of fine print.
Strange title, I would have said he was an enemy of mankind, not just women. I have to wonder if there was some basis for the Drake character. I can’t say I have ever read anything suggesting it. in fact he was by all accounts a happily married family man to the extent war criminals can be. His wife and family are usually portrayed with him in the Bunker with Hitler at the end.
I do like the idea of making him what he was a banal little man, not a super villain, but like the whole fantastic lot twisted ambitious little men for whom evil was a means to an end, not the Red Skull, but sick little murderous gangsters as contemptuous and pitiful as evil. He certainly did not deserve to be portrayed as anything but the pathetic little enabler of murderers he was.
June 26th, 2023 at 10:09 am
Incredibly belatedly:
Odds and Ends about Wolfgang Zilzer aka Paul Andor:
– Though he was raised in Germany, Wolfgang Zilzer was born in Cincinnati OH, which gave him automatic US citizenship.
This came in handy when Hitler came to power; Zilzer used his birthright citizenship to bring himself and his family to the US to escape the Nazi regime.
-Once in America, Zilzer began an acting career on stage and in films, using stage names – an early one was John Voight.
– After permanently adopting ‘Paul Andor’ as a stage/screen name, Zilzer settled in as a second-or-third level heavy wherever he could get the gig; that’s when he got this picture as Goebbels.
– Post-WWII, he started going back and forth between Germany – where he acted as Wolfgang Zilzer – and the US – where he appeared as Paul Andor – in movies and TV, racking up a string of credits on both sides of the pond.
– Perhaps Paul Andor’s strangest credit:
In the early days of Late Night With David Letterman, Dave did a running gag in which he would “fire” an elderly stagehand named Henry on camera; Henry would react in abject terror over losing his job, and a good time (?) was had by all …
Between 1983 and 1985, Paul Andor as Henry was fired by Letterman about twice a month; hey, it’s a living …
– The Letterman gig was Paul Andor/Wolfgang Zilzer’s last acting gig in America; he developed Parkinson’s Disease, and decided to return to Germany for his last years.
All true (I couldn’t make this up!).