Sun 10 Jul 2016
CRIME, INC. PRC, 1945. Leo Carrillo, Tom Neal, Martha Tilton, Lionel Atwill, Grant Mitchell, Sheldon Leonard, Harry Shannon, Danny Morton, Virginia Vale. Director: Lew Landers.
Some reviewers believe this to be one of bottom-rung studio PRC’s better efforts, and while this may be true, it doesn’t mean that it’s very good. The plot is perfunctory at best, and while viewers in 1945 may have enjoyed watching Martha Tilton sing, the songs do nothing to hold the rest of the story together, nothing more than an out-and-out crime film, some scenes of which are filmed in a nightclub.
While Leo Carrillo gets top billing as a mid-level higher-up in a local crime syndicate, this is really Tom Neal’s movie, from beginning to end. He plays a brash young reporter (the only other kind in movies like this are the old embittered ones) who gets an edge on the police by befriending an upwardly mobile gangster (Danny Morton) who is making enemies of the gang currently in power.
It may or may not be relevant that Martha Tilton plays the latter’s sister, so she gets to have more lines to say than in some of the other movies she was in. She acquits herself well, but then again so do most of the other players, most of them long-time veterans of movies like this. It’s only too bad they didn’t have better lines to say.

July 10th, 2016 at 5:59 pm
Does the poster mean that the screenwriter was thrown in jail?
July 10th, 2016 at 10:00 pm
Gary R.
That particular aspect wasn’t played up in the movie, but Wikipedia says:
“The film, based on a story by former crime reporter Martin Mooney, is about a newspaper journalist who faces prison time because he refuses to name his sources.”
Other sources suggest that the story is fact-based. Here’s what the TCM has to say:
“The film’s opening credits are preceded by a shot of the following letter from FBI director J. Edgar Hoover, dated August 27, 1935 and addressed to writer/producer Martin Mooney, who was then a New York crime reporter: “Dear Mr. Mooney: I am pleased to learn of the progress you have made on your book ‘Crime, Incorporated.’ I feel that books of its type, written by experts in their respective fields, such as yourself, possess a vital influence in arousing the American public to the continuing, widespread menace of crime throughout our country today, particularly in our urban centers.” According to an April 1944 news item, Mooney’s book Crime, Incorporated exposed Louis Lepke Buchalter, James J. Hines, federal judge Martin T. Manton and Willie Bioff as criminals, and caused then New York governor Herbert H. Lehman to appoint Thomas E. Dewey as a special prosecutor.”
This is all I know so far.
July 10th, 2016 at 8:04 pm
PRC tries to do Warners with minimal success. Neal was supposed to be a low rent John Garfield but his performances are uneven. Carrillo mugs as usual to less effect than usual in a non comic non supporting role.
July 10th, 2016 at 10:52 pm
Tom Neal didn’t impress me very much in this one. A very limited range as an actor.
July 11th, 2016 at 12:13 am
David,
Your description of Tom Neal as a low-rent John Garfield is on the money. Reportedly, Warner Bros. even tried to buy the rights to DETOUR, Neal’s most famous film, as a project for Garfield (at Garfield’s urging), but PRC declined to sell. You have to wonder if the film would’ve ended up the cult item it is today if Warners had made it with someone other than Edgar G. Ulmer as director.
July 11th, 2016 at 12:39 am
Steve,
Thanks for the research. Sounds like that poster copy was just publicity hype.
July 11th, 2016 at 3:48 am
So whathehell is Lionel Atwill doing in this picture?
July 11th, 2016 at 8:32 am
Lionel Atwill was unemployable for
personal reasons and behavior the last several years of his life. he needed to make a living, ergo — his appearance here.
July 14th, 2016 at 6:02 am
Thank you for a good review.
This is a film I’ve never seen.
Another film directed by Lew Landers was shown yesterday on TCM. Cowboy Canteen is a little Western musical. It’s full of charm and lots of good singing.
There are some brief notes on Landers at my web site:
http://mikegrost.com/landers.htm
Tom Neal was not always an intense noir type. In his early days MGM cast him as a patrician young man full of refinement. See Within the Law (Gustav Machaty, 1939).