Fri 22 Jul 2016
Reviewed by Barry Gardner: SARAH DUNANT – Birth Marks.
Posted by Steve under Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Characters , Reviews[2] Comments
SARAH DUNANT – Birth Marks. Hannah Wolfe #1. Doubleday, hardcover, 1992. First published in the UK: Michael Joseph, hardcover, 1991.
This is Sarah Dunant’s second mystery, but the first (I believe) featuring London-based private detective Hannah Wolfe.’ I believe we have a winner here.
Hannah accepts a job that’s basically a missing persons case — young ballet dancer hasn’t send her more-or-less adopted mother a card when she should have, and the woman is concerned. Though Hannah first believes that the young woman simply wanted not to be found, she takes the case because she needs the money. After the investigation has begun, but before anything substantive has been learned, the missing dancer is fished out of the Thames, dead, an apparent suicide, eight months pregnant.
Based on what she’s learned, Hannah doesn’t believe it,`nor does someone else: she is retained by an anonymous client to investigate further. The` trail leads to Paris, and leads Hannah into an ever-deepening questioning of her own feelings about motherhood.
Hannah Wolfe was not only believable, but appealing, and altogether the best feminine PI I’ve met in a long while. The character was beautifully developed, as were those of her sister, her ex-boss and “mentor,” and several others. Dunant’s prose style is literate and understated, and the narrative flow was very good.
This was an excellent book. There were no unbelievable characters, the plot made sense, the writing was fine, and it didn’t end in an orgy of violence. I don’t want to go overboard, but I liked this better than any first book (for me) I’ve read in a while. You need to give this lady a try.
The Hannah Wolfe series —
Birth Marks. Joseph, 1991.
Fatlands. H. Hamilton, 1993.
Under My Skin. H. Hamilton, 1995.
July 22nd, 2016 at 10:08 pm
Sarah Dunant also wrote a handful of thrillers and other crime-related novels, but she is best known for her historical fiction taking place during the Italian Renaissance.
Reviewers on Goodreads are all over the place on this one, ranging from two stars to five (out of five), averaging a solid 3.3. Two or three liked this one as much as Barry did. (I’m assuming that his comments rate as a five star review.)
July 23rd, 2016 at 2:57 am
Sounds as if it is hard to find a middle ground with this one.