Tue 29 Nov 2016
Reviewed by Dan Stumpf: FREDRIC BROWN – The Wench Is Dead.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[4] Comments
FREDRIC BROWN – The Wench Is Dead. E. P. Dutton, hardcover, 1953. Bantam #1565, paperback, 1957.
This finds Brown in David Goodis territory at his smooth, shattering best.
Howard (“Howieâ€) Perry is a High School sociology teacher studying the denizens of Los Angeles’ skid row by living as one of them as he angles for a master’s degree and a better teaching position. As the story opens he’s staying in a flophouse, washing dishes for a living, and spending most nights on the street, drinking himself comatose among the other winos, all in the name of Research.
He’s also carrying on a relationship of sorts with Billie, a good-natured B-Girl who likes him for his sensitive nature, and expresses her affection in a very physical way. There’s a murder early on, and the cops don’t know whodunit, but we’re not far into the book before we realize that this is not so much a mystery as it is an observation of Howard losing control and in danger of becoming one of the derelicts he’s supposed to be studying.
Brown keeps his story light, moving the plot along with telling details about Howie and his chums as they instinctively duck the police, desperately try to make up the price of a bottle, and stake out a safe place to drink themselves unconscious. Like David Goodis, Brown never looks down on his bums and winos, nor does he seek to make them noble savages; they’re just guys getting along their own way, with their own norms and goals in life, and in Brown as well as Goodis, these are the heroes of pulp fiction.
In fact, Howie does eventually solve the murder and see the killer brought to justice, but (again like Goodis) any sense of accomplishment is illusory. Howard Perry spends a whole murder mystery treading water, and if we see the ending coming a long way off, Fredric Brown still delivers it with a punch.
November 29th, 2016 at 9:03 am
This is my favorite Brown novel, probably because it was the first one of his that I read.
November 29th, 2016 at 7:19 pm
Thank you for a good review.
I’ve never read this one.
Aspects of the plot recall a little bit Robert Reeves’ mystery “Cellini Smith: Detective” (1943).
November 29th, 2016 at 9:13 pm
The thing about Brown and Goodis is you could read books with these settings and not feel as if you had been tarnished or dragged through the dirt or the people you read about were exploited or portrayed in a way that was derogatory.
November 30th, 2016 at 7:43 am
One of Brown’s books I have not read, and I will have to check to see if I own a copy.
Given the popularity of Brown’s work, it seems strange that it’s been out of print since 1957, a fact that isn’t quite true, since Amazon offers copies for sale on Kindle.
Which does me no good, since I don’t own one, and probably never will.