Mon 19 Jun 2017
A Movie Review by Dan Stumpf: THE RETURN OF DOCTOR X (1939).
Posted by Steve under Horror movies , Reviews[4] Comments
THE RETURN OF DOCTOR X. Warner Brothers, 1939. Wayne Morris, Priscilla Lane, Humphrey Bogart, Dennis Morgan, John Litel, Lya Lys, Huntz Hall, Olin Howland. Written by Lee Katz and William J. Makin. Directed by Vincent Sherman.
1939 was the year that brought us Stagecoach, Gone with the Wind, Of Mice and Men, Wizard of Oz… and this, Bogie’s only horror film. He didn’t like it much, but it ain’t all that bad. It isn’t very good, either, but I found it fun.
Wayne Morris, playing his usual likeable half-wit, is your typical movie reporter of the day: bluff, brassy and smart as a corn cob. As the story opens, he talks his way into an interview with a stage star (Lya Lys, in a rather good sub-Dietrich performance) only to find her dead in her apartment, her body drained of blood—and cue up the ominous music.
Things take a surprising turn when Wayne’s paper splashes the story across the front page before telling the police, only to have the body disappear when the cops show up… then reappear alive (sort of; she now sports a goth look and talks like Robert Downey in his drug-using days) leading to Wayne getting fired by a typically apoplectic movie-style editor.
Nothing daunted, our hero hooks up with his doctor buddy (Dennis Morgan) and consults with blood specialist Dr. Flegg (“Interesting stuff, blood!â€) who assures him there’s nothing to see here, but….
About this time we get a look at Dr. Flegg’s assistant, Doctor Quesne, and the jig is up, for it’s no less than Humphrey Bogart, made up like a reverse-Jolson, with pasty white face, dark lips and eyeshadow, with a shock of white in his hair. Doctor Flegg (John Litel, made up with satanic goatee and monocle) explains it all by saying Bogie’s “getting over a shock.â€
It would be easy to say the shock must be appearing in this picture, but as I said, it’s not all that bad. Return is done with typical Warners polish: elaborate sets, glistening photography (by Sid Hickox, of Dark Passage and Colorado Territory) and the usual cast of Warners bit players, all doing their reliable best and keeping a straight face when we learn that Dr Quesne is actually Doctor Xavier, an executed criminal brought back to life and now in need of human blood to keep going.
I should add however that Return is also heavy-duty stupid. How so? Well for starters, we get a front-page headline of a murder out on the streets before the police can even get to the scene of the crime. Later, a detective tells Dennis Morgan that the coroner has ruled a death by natural causes — while the body is still lying on the floor!
Further on, our persistent heroes, investigating the supposed death of Dr Xavier, go to the cemetery in the middle of the night and simply have the caretaker dig up the grave, which he does as if it were the most natural thing in the world. Xavier’s coffin turns up empty of course, whereupon the cops compound the stupidity by showing up to arrest Morris and Morgan for stealing the copse! Faced with all this, the notion of raising the dead seems but another improbability, and hardly noticeable.
For those who don’t know how horror films end, I’m going to throw out a SPOILER ALERT! here and add that in deference to Bogie’s image, the writers allow him to perish shooting it out with the Law in a hail of police bullets. And it’s done well, an exciting moment in a film that can be fun if you’ll let it.
June 19th, 2017 at 8:44 pm
This one feels as if someone decided to spend money filming a DIME MYSTERY Weird Horror tale with a top cast. The result can’t help but be fun, if only to see what better actors, sets, writers, and direction would have done for Poverty Row’s horror films.
Wasn’t this also Bogie’s last film before HIGH SIERRA and THE MALTESE FALCON?
June 19th, 2017 at 10:14 pm
According to IMDb, in between DOCTOR X and HIGH SIERRA were, in reverse order:
They Drive by Night (1940)
Brother Orchid (1940)
It All Came True (1940)
Virginia City (1940)
Invisible Stripes (1939)
June 20th, 2017 at 9:05 pm
Actually, RETURN *is* based on a pulp story, but not one from DIME MYSTERY. It was adapted from William J. Makin’s “The Doctor’s Secret,” published in the July 30, 1938 issue of DETECTIVE FICTION WEEKLY. It’s a pretty fair story, although Makin’s “Red Wolf of Arabia” yarns in BLUE BOOK are far better.
Coincidentally, I just ran RETURN at this year’s Windy City Pulp and Paper Convention. I’d previously screened it there in 2003 and over the years various people had asked me to reschedule it. This year I finally had an open slot and booked it. Not one of the people who’d requested it bothered to show up.
June 21st, 2017 at 1:56 am
That’s certainly an interesting connection between the movie and the pulp magazines, Ed, something I never knew until now. I don’t believe that either IMDb or AFI point it out.
What I did find, though, once I knew to look, is that the pedigree of the story Makin wrote goes back farther than its appearance in DFW. According Phil Stephenson-Payne’s online Crime Fiction Index, it first appeared as “The Surgeon’s Secret†in the January 12 1935 issue of the British story paper THE THRILLER.