Thu 2 Aug 2018
GEORGE BAGBY – The Golden Creep. George Bagby/Inspector Schmidt #48. Doubleday Crime Club, hardcover, 1982. Detective Book Club, hardcover, 3-in-1 edition. No paperback edition.
At one time in my life, I think you could say that Aaron Marc Stein (aka George Bagby) was my favorite mystery writer. Emphasis on writer. He had a fluid, smooth style of putting words on paper that I’ve never been able to describe to my own satisfaction, much less anyone else’s, and his dialogue may have been even better. When two people are having conversations in his books, you always know who’s speaking, even when all you have are the words they are saying to judge by.
There were 49 books in his George Bagby series — Bagby is the fellow who tags along with New York City police inspector Schmidt on his many many cases– and this one is number 48, and I don’t even remember seeing the title before. Stein was in his late 70s when he wrote it, and while the writing is as good as ever, the plot itself is one of his weaker ones.
It starts out in semi-salacious fashion, with Bagby visiting a girlie joint on his own and ending up in an alley behind the place afterward next to a dead body. The dead man is the character the book is titled after — he made himself rather obnoxious with the Amazonian-built girls who are the main attraction — referred to, surprisingly, as “tit elation” — and Bagby, having been slipped a mickey, as he supposes, is the main suspect.
And Inspector Schmidt — I don’t know if he ever had a first name — has to play it carefully, as the press knows full well how close the two of them are. But rather than concentrate on the doings leading up to the murder, the two of them focus instead on the murder weapon — the tail of a huge stone dragon that someone carted to the roof of the place and dropped down on the dead man.
You have the feeling that when the appropriate number of pages have gone by, Stein/Bagby decided it was time to close things up and get back to the people in and around the strip joing itself, and sure enough, that’s all it takes to solve the case.
I found the book enjoyable, but if you aren’t a fan of Bagby’s from before, or worse yet, you’ve never heard of him, this one won’t be the one to convince you that you ought to read more of him.
August 2nd, 2018 at 10:49 pm
For some strange reason I preferred Stein to Bagby, but read and enjoyed both, and I agree in under either name he had a fluid style that might well be the definition of a casual but effective “armchair reading” voice.
He was one of the kings of the midlists too, a writer, who despite paperback presence, was far more popular in library sales and book club editions (a staple of the Detective Book Club throughout his career) others being Ken Crossen, Coxe, Waugh, and the non North Lockridge titles. Most libraries could be sure to have a few Stein or Bagby titles in their mystery section.
August 3rd, 2018 at 1:35 am
What all those authors have in common, David, is that none of them were flashy, in say the Robert B. Parker sense, but were uniformly reliable to provide good solid detective fiction. And yes while mostly forgotten today, libraries bought them by the truckload.
August 3rd, 2018 at 8:32 am
I read a bunch of the Bagby books about 40 years ago and recall enjoying all of them. Very dependable writer. I have one or two of them on my shelves now and ought to try him again. I also liked the Matt Erridge books he did as Aaron Marc Stein, although those were more adventure novels than mysteries. Or so I remember them, anyway.
August 3rd, 2018 at 8:48 am
I link Stein/Bagby/Stone with other Grand Masters of the era such as Judson Phillips/Hugh Pentecost, Baynard Kendrick, and George Harmon Coxe — all providing great entertainment and all deserving of a revival.
August 3rd, 2018 at 9:17 am
Like James, I binged on a dozen Bagby books back in the 1970s. I also read a fair number of Aaron Marc Stein paperbacks over the years. As David pointed out, these are wonderful “armchair” mysteries.
Once again, I wish I’d bought more of these books when they were cheap and available. I don’t see them at Library Sales anymore.
August 3rd, 2018 at 3:28 pm
It’s good to know that I’m not the only one who remembers Stein-Bagby-Hampton Stone!
August 3rd, 2018 at 5:27 pm
Thank you for an informative review!
I analyze 27 novels by Stein/Bagby (only one-fourth of his huge output!) at my web site:
http://mikegrost.com/stein.htm
There are also sizable articles on Coxe, Kendrick and non-North books by the Lockridges. Whole-heartedly agree that all of these authors did good work, that should still be read today.
August 4th, 2018 at 6:14 pm
Mike Grost’s analysis of 27 Stein/Bagby mysteries is pure critical gold! Excellent work!
August 5th, 2018 at 10:23 am
George,
Thank you very much!
A strong impression: there is lots of interesting writing in the neglected Bagby/Stein books.
August 5th, 2018 at 1:15 pm
I guess I’m the outlier here. Can’t say I’ve read as much Stein/Bagby as the rest o’ youse, although those I *have* read (his earlier Crime Club books under both names) struck me as uniformly competent, entertaining, but unmemorable. And I’ve never had the slightest interest in revisiting any of them.
August 5th, 2018 at 4:18 pm
Even though I’ve enjoyed all of the Stein/Bagby books I’ve read, each in their own way, and there have been quite a few of them, I wouldn’t disagree with your assessment of them, Ed. None of the stories stand out to me, one over the other. I wouldn’t go back and read any of them, either. It’s more a case of on to the next one!