Thu 13 Sep 2018
A CRIME CLUB Mystery Review: GARLAND LORD – Murder Plain and Fancy.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[5] Comments
GARLAND LORD – Murder Plain and Fancy. Doubleday Crime Club, hardcover, 1943.
Garland Lord was the joint pen name of husband and wife Isabel Garland (1903-1988) and Mindret Lord (1903-1955). They wrote four books together under this name, none with series characters, the first three for Doubleday’s Crime Club imprint. Isabel also wrote one book under her own name, apparently before they decided to team up together.
This one starts out with the hugest of coincidences. When a young man and woman, both members of a traveling actors troupe, decide to visit the latter’s long estranged aunt, against her protests that she does not want to see her, they hardly expect to find her dead in her house at the bottom of the stairs, apparently the victim of a very untimely accident.
Well, of course, if you are reading this, you would know as soon as I did that it was no accident. What’s more, since Sheila was the woman’s only heir, it is natural for the small town local authorities to suspect that either she or her male friend Ken had something to do with it.
You might also suspect that this is a romance as well as a detective novel, but it is not Ken who Sheila finds herself more and more attracted to, but someone local, someone who’s had a taste of big city life and has decided it is not for him. Ever so slowly he has Sheila thinking that way too. Ken, of course, is green-eyed with jealousy, and begins to act more and more suspiciously.
The two authors do an excellent job is disguising a fairly obvious reason for the dead aunt’s strange behavior, which as it turns out is also strongly involved with the motive for her death. In that regard, this is a minor affair, but it is the characters who make the story. Even the minor ones are extremely well drawn, each in their own way. The end result is very readable.
NOTE: According to IMDb, Mindret Lord had some success writing for movies and TV, as well as radio.
September 13th, 2018 at 1:57 pm
And from 1934 to 1943, Mindret Lord wrote at lest twenty stories for the shudder pulps and weird tales, a number of which are available online.
September 14th, 2018 at 2:50 am
Right you are, Jerry. From the online Fiction Mags idex:
LORD, MINDRET (1903-1955); see pseudonyms Nathaniel Grew & Garland Lord (chron.)
* Agony in Clay, (ss) Uncanny Tales Apr/May 1939
* Am I a Vampire, (ss) Horror Stories Jun 1941 (unpublished)
* Anniversary, (ss) Rex Stout’s Mystery Monthly Dec 1946
* Beauty Born in Hell, (nv) Horror Stories Aug/Sep 1939
* Beauty for the Hags of Hell, (ss) Sinister Stories May 1940
* Black-Mass Bride, (ss) Mystery Tales Mar 1940
* The Butcher’s Eyes, (ss) Horror Stories Aug/Sep 1938
* College of Corpses, (ss) Terror Tales Sep 1940
Terror Tales (UK) #4 1952
* Curse of the Golden Cobra, (ss) Dime Mystery Magazine Aug 1936
Dime Mystery Magazine (Canada) Aug 1936
* The Devil Goes to Dixie, (ss) Horror Stories Oct/Nov 1938
* The Dinner Cooked in Hell, (ss) Startling Mystery Magazine Apr 1940
* Dr. Jacobus Meliflore’s Last Patient, (ss) The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction Nov 1953
* Double Trouble, (ss) Argosy Jul 1944
* The Experts, (ss) Cosmopolitan Jul 1943
Argosy (UK) Mar 1946
* First Night, (ss) Weird Tales Jul 1941
* Frame for a Nation, (ss) Short Stories Sep 25 1941
Short Stories (UK) Mar 1946
* Give Me Your Soul!, (nv) Dime Mystery Magazine Apr 1934
* Heaven Will Protect the Working Girl, (ss) The New Yorker Sep 26 1942
* Hostage to Pain, (ss) Dime Mystery Magazine Jan 1935
* The House That Horror Built, (ss) Mystery Tales May 1939
* Lil, (ss) Weird Tales Mar 1943
Weird Tales (Canada) Jul 1943
* A Little Matter of Murder, (ss) Detective Short Stories Nov 1940
* Lorenzo, (ss) The New Yorker Jul 24 1943
* Lost Vacation, (ss) Weird Tales May 1943
Weird Tales (Canada) Sep 1943
* The Mystery of Uncle Alfred, (ss) Weird Tales Nov 1941
* Naked Lady, (ss) Weird Tales Sep 1934
Playboy May 1955
* Now We Must Wish, (ss) The Strand Magazine Feb 1943
* Our Daily Bread, (ss) The New Yorker Dec 12 1942
* Prince of Pain, (ss) Terror Tales Mar 1935
* Ransom Note, (vi) The American Magazine May 1942
* Satan Takes a Bride, (ss) Horror Stories Aug/Sep 1936
* So Bright! So Beautiful!, (ss) The New Yorker Jul 25 1942
* The Streamliner Mystery, (ss) Inspector Malone’s Mystery Magazine Sep/Oct 1945
* The Tattooed Tramp, (ss) Black Mask Aug 1939
Black Mask (UK) Aug 1939
* Unconsidered Trifles, (vi) Liberty Jan 31 1942
September 13th, 2018 at 6:55 pm
I knew I knew the name Mindret Lord from elsewhere.
September 14th, 2018 at 2:06 pm
Based on the title I always thought that this had an Amish background. “Plain and fancy” is a term that crops up in Penn Dutch talk. There’s a musical set in Lancaster County about Amish youth that also uses that phrase as a title. Obviously I’ve been wrong all these years.
Coincidentally, I saw a copy of this book in Babbitt’s Books this past weekend when I was at my nephew’s wedding in Normal, IL. The copy was beat to hell and very stained inside. Even at only $8 I passed it up. Found some other great books (a couple of rare titles, too) at dirt cheap prices. Anyway, good to know what it is really about at last.
September 14th, 2018 at 5:21 pm
The book takes place in a small town in Wisconsin, John, and it does have a “non-denominational Amish” feel to it, if that makes sense, especially the local minister and his family, Scandinavian, as I recall. He, his wife and several daughters are key players in the story.
My copy, if you or anyone may be interested, is up for sale at Amazon, or it would be if I weren’t in LA at the moment, with my books back home in vacation mode.