Fri 5 Oct 2018
Mystery Review: RICHARD LUPOFF – The Comic Book Killer.
Posted by Steve under Collecting , Comic Books, Cartoons, Comic Strips , Reviews[8] Comments
RICHARD LUPOFF – The Comic Book Killer. Bantam, paperback; 1st printing, February 1989. Previously published in hardcover by Offspring Press, 1988. This earlier edition also contains bound-in black & white comic pages and a separate full color comic book “Gangsters at War” in a slip case. (This specially created comic book has a crucial role in the story.) Also published by Borgo Press, paperback, 2012.
I’m of two minds about this one. As the title indicates, this first real mystery that insurance adjuster Hobart Lindsey has ever had to deal with has to do with comic books, and comic book collecting in particular.
Right up my alley! I’ve been collecting comics in one way or another since I was five — but not necessarily as “collectibles,†if you see what I mean, not hardly. This one begins when a comic book shop insured by Lindsey’s company reports the theft of $250,000 worth of comics.
Lindsey is so unknowledgeable about comic books that he thinks the thief must have needed a truck to haul them away. The proprietor of the shop quickly disabuses of that idea. Only 35 books were stolen, and all of them could have fit in a single briefcase.
Trying to make a good impression with his superiors, Lindsey decides to take an active role in the investigation. This puts him in close contact with Marvia Plum, the black (and definitely female) detective assigned to the case. An immediate attraction develops, which leads to more.
Of two minds, I said. Making this one more difficult than I expected to enjoy is that I did not find Hobart Lindsey a very engaging protagonist. In the first few chapters especially I found him both callow and not particularly likeable.
And we learn even less about Marvia Plum. An unanswered question I kept asking myself is what does she see in him. Worse, the only character I really related to is the first murder victim. There is also one huge coincidence that needs to be swallowed as well. For me, it didn’t spoil the book, but it didn’t go down all that easily either.
A mixed bag, then, but there is no doubt that author Richard Lupoff knows his comic book history, and that was a big plus. If that’s a subject matter you’re interested in, I think you’ll find as much to like in that regard as I did.
The Hobart Lindsey / Marvia Plum series —
The Comic Book Killer (1989)
The Classic Car Killer (1991)
The Bessie Blue Killer (1994)
The Sepia Siren Killer (1994)
The Cover Girl Killer (1995)
The Silver Chariot Killer (1997)
The Radio Red Killer (1997, Marvia Plum alone)
One Murder at a Time: The Casebook of Lindsey & Plum (2001; story collection)
The Emerald Cat Killer (2010)
October 5th, 2018 at 4:09 pm
This is the first review I’ve written and posted from my iPhone. I’ll add a cover image and a list of the Lindsey and Plum books later, along with some edits I can’t do now. More later, then!
October 5th, 2018 at 5:35 pm
I had high hopes for this, but couldn’t get through it.
October 5th, 2018 at 6:19 pm
I had a copy of this once, a gift from a friend, but never got around to reading it. It seems I didn’t miss anything.
October 5th, 2018 at 7:42 pm
There was a limited hard cover that actually had a comic book attached, but I think in general, though I am a fan of Lupoff’s science fiction, biography, and literary criticism, Max Allan Collins and Ron Goulart did this better.
October 5th, 2018 at 10:12 pm
I’d forgotten about that hardcover limited edition. Thanks for reminding me. I’ve added it to the publishing information at the top of the review.
I’ve also added a couple of cover images, plus the list of Lindsey & Plum books I promised earlier.
Of special note is the next to last paragraph, to which I added the last two sentences, which somehow went missing when the review was first posted. Apologies for that!
October 6th, 2018 at 11:07 am
I’m with Dan, couldn’t get through it. I’ve had problems with other books by Lupoff too, and finally just quit trying him.
October 7th, 2018 at 10:53 pm
Haven’t read the Comic Book Killer for years, but it impressed me enough to pick up the second volume in the series when published and, years later, to buy the whole series in e-pub format from Wildside Press. The characters and the collector focus probably grabbed me more than the resolution of the mysteries.
Wildside still has the individual volumes as e-books and paperbacks, though I could not find a listing for the entire series.
According to Lupoff’s introduction to One Murder at a Time, he never wrote The Tinpan Tiger Killer.
October 8th, 2018 at 3:11 am
I said a lot of negative things about CBK in my review, but I enjoyed the general background of comic books and comic book collecting to warrant reading other books in the series myself. I don’t think I own them all, but I’m sure I have most of them. I certainly couldn’t resist them when they came out.
And thanks for the info on THE TINPAN TIGER KILLER. I may decide to delete it from the bibliography. If you don’t see it there, then you’ll know I have.