Wed 30 Jan 2019
Pulp PI Stories I’m Reading, by David Vineyard: RAYMOND CHANDLER “Guns at Cyrano’s.”
Posted by Steve under Pulp Fiction , Reviews[13] Comments
RAYMOND CHANDLER “Guns at Cyrano’s.” Ted Carmady #1. Novelette. First published in Black Mask January 1936 (with the leading character named Ted Malvern). Collected in: Five Murderers, Avon, paperback, 1944; Red Wind, World, hardcover, 1946; The Simple Art of Murder, Houghton Mifflin, hardcover, 1950; Pick-Up on Noon Street, Pocket, paperback, 1952; Stories and Early Novels, Library of America, hardcover, 1995. TV episode: Season 2 Episode 4 of Philip Marlowe, Private Eye, 18 May 1986 (with Powers Boothe as Philip Marlowe).
“Guns at Cyrano’s†is one of the many short works written by Raymond Chandler for the pulps between 1929 and the publication of his first story “Blackmailer’s Don’t Shoot†and 1938 and the publication of The Big Sleep, the first Philip Marlowe novel. It is neither the best nor the worst of the lot (certainly not as good as the John Dalmas stories, particularly “Red Windâ€), not even the best of the stories written in the third person (“Spanish Blood†and “Nevada Gas†are both better).
I’ll go further, it isn’t even the best of the stories featuring Carmady (here known as Ted Carmady).
I am not damning with faint praise though, because it is my personal favorite of the early stories, a pulpy B-movie of a boozy rainy noir tale replete with women no better than they have to be, a hero who isn’t so noble he’s boring or hard to believe in, a few innocents, and of course that famous man who walks into the room with a gun just as the lull starts to set in.
Carmady, at least as presented here — and you will be forgiven if you question if this is the same Carmady of “Killer in the Rain†— has money and lives well, unlike anyone else in Chandler’s oveure he is not a private detective (he used to be, and even identifies himself as one at one point, but a rich private eye goes against almost everything Chandler ever wrote elsewhere) nor a good cop or house dick, but instead the son of a father who got his money in a clearly stated illegal way, meaning his son knows a lot of shady people and has a romantic notion that maybe he ought to make up for his father’s sins by helping people in trouble:
Here he is headed for the hotel room he lives in when he spots a victim lying in an open doorway.
Carmady slid down beside her, touched her cheek. It was warm. He lifted the hair softly away from her head and saw the bruise.
“Sapped.†His lips pressed back against his teeth.
Frankly at this point you wouldn’t be too shocked if Carmady turned out to have a sobriquet like the Saint or the Toff. Only the language is different, and maybe the attitude, the milieu is pretty much the same.
The Dame, all women in these stories are some shade of Dames, good, bad, classy, murderous, or saintly, is a chanteuse named Jean Adrian (“I do a number at Cyrano’s.â€), no better and no worse than life and men have made her, who likes his whiskey and is loathe to admit she was sapped or explain the.22 he finds beside her.
Seems Miss Adrian has a boy friend who is a fighter, Duke Targo, and the Boys would like him to drop a fight, and they are trying to get to her through him. Naturally no Chandler hero can let that knightly quest go unmet.
Of course that knightly quest is far from simple this being Chandler, involving a State Senator being blackmailed, a fixer named Doll Conant (His clothes looked as if they had cost a great deal of money and had been slept in.), an innocent victim to be avenged, and that gunfight at Benny Cyrano’s club from the title.
Before it is over there is more gunplay (more in this single story than all the Marlowe novels put together), a few beatings, plenty of the kind of tough poetic dialogue Chandler was famous for, and a moral of sorts. It all makes for a satisfying pulp tale with the air of a good B movie and with those little touches that make even early Chandler such a pleasure to read.
As I said, I like this story much more than it deserves for what it is. I’ve even seen it suggested it is the weakest of the Chandler stories, but it just happens to fit me for some reason, which is all any of us can ask of any story.
If, like me you are a sucker for that particular brand of music, “Guns at Cyrano’s†hits all the notes on key, sonata for Thompson Machine Gun in B-Flat.
January 31st, 2019 at 7:30 am
You can’t go wrong with Chandler. I’ve read and reread his work several times and he is one of the reasons that I started to collect the detective pulps, especially BLACK MASK and DIME DETECTIVE.
His influence on hard boiled literature was enormous and along with Hammett, he was one of the greats.
January 31st, 2019 at 9:21 am
Chandler’s novels are things to treasure. His early short stories are just plain FUN!
January 31st, 2019 at 11:22 am
I like it a lot too, David. Very nice summary/review, now I want to pluck my copy of Pickup on Noon Street off the shelf.
January 31st, 2019 at 5:56 pm
I’m with you, Rick. It’s been too long since I read anything by Chandler. I’m going to have to remedy that fact soon!
January 31st, 2019 at 5:59 pm
By the way, I’ve just added the Powers Booth as Philip Marlowe episode of the TV show to the credits at the top of David’s review.
I’m sure I watched it at the time, but I don’t remember it at all. Can anyone with a better memory than mine tell us how well the program follows the actual story?
Other than changing the name of the leading character, of course.
January 31st, 2019 at 6:24 pm
I haven’t read any Chandler short stories for ages, either. Recall that Guns at Cyrano’s was good.
January 31st, 2019 at 7:08 pm
Steve,
As I recall the Boothe episode kept the basics of the plot pretty well though obviously Marlowe wouldn’t have the kind of pull with the cops, club owners, or the crooks that Carmady does in the story. I don’t recall if the business with the bell captain and the second fighter is handled the same as the story, but that would be the only major element that might be different.
It’s one of Chandler’s more straight forward plots, even with the twists, which may be why he didn’t seem to cannibalize this as much as some of the others for the novels.
January 31st, 2019 at 7:46 pm
I found a twelve minute clip from that episode. I’ll add it below. Watching it for a while reminded how much I enjoyed that series. Something else to locate and watch again!
January 31st, 2019 at 8:35 pm
I just watched one of the HBO Philip Marlow stories that starred Powers Boothe on youtube. It was from the second season entitled Red Wind.
January 31st, 2019 at 9:42 pm
I have the series on DVD — complete, I think — I hope — so all I have to do is find it. Conceding that that may be difficult to do right now, I may have to resort to YouTube myself.
February 1st, 2019 at 8:29 am
I highly recommend RAYMOND CHANDLER: BOX SET from the LIBRARY OF AMERICA. Here’s the description:
Here, for the first time in a deluxe collector’s box, are all seven Philip Marlowe novels—The Big Sleep; Farewell, My Lovely; The High Window; The Lady in the Lake; The Little Sister; The Long Goodbye; and Playback—along with thirteen classic pulp stories, Chandler’s brilliant screenplay for Double Indemnity, and a selection of his revealing essays and letters: the most comprehensive edition of the hard-boiled crime fiction of Raymond Chandler ever published.
February 1st, 2019 at 10:40 am
That’s a great book. I bought it when it first came out, and it allowed me to toss out some of my older worn out Chandler paperbacks. I kind of regret it now, but they really were worn out.
February 7th, 2022 at 1:46 am
Powers Boothe had screen presence as Marlowe. I liked what I glimpsed of that series.
‘Red Wind’ gets my vote as maybe the most quintessential Marlowe short story. I listened to the Gerard Mohr radio version tonight.