Sun 5 Apr 2020
A Movie Review by David Vineyard: THE SPIDER (1931).
Posted by Steve under Mystery movies , Reviews[6] Comments
THE SPIDER. Fox Film Corp., 1931. Edmond Lowe, Lola Moran, El Brendel, John Arledge, George E. Stone, Earl Foxe. Screenplay Barry Conners, Phlip Klein, & Leon Gordon, Albert Lewis, based on a play by Fulton Oursler & Lowell Bretano. Directed by Kenneth MacKenna &William Cameron Menzies.
Murder in the theater, with Edmond Lowe as Chatrand, the magician sleuth who has to use all his stage skills to clear the name of his young assistant Tommy (John Arledge) when a member of the audience is shot while Chatrand and Tommy are on stage doing their mentalist act.
Despite being based on a play by Fulton Oursler (Anthony Abbott of the Thatcher Colt mysteries) there isn’t much mystery to this film whose chief interests are Lowe as the fast thinking magician sleuth and the sets and magic acts designed by co-director William Cameron Menzies.
Menzies, who directed Lowe in the excellent Chandu the Magician (1932), along with a third magic film, Trick or Treat [reviewed by Walter Albert here ] pulls out all the stops for the magic acts and sets, which along with Lowe are the chief interests in this pedestrian mystery.
The basis for the plot is that Chatrand’s assistant Tommy has amnesia, but hopes having returned to the last place he remembers a face in the audience will awaken his memory during the mentalist act he does with the magician.
Meanwhile Beverly Lane (Moran) thinks Tommy may be her lost brother and is accompanied by her uncle, John Carrington (Earl Foxe) whose cruelty caused Tommy’s amnesia and has every reason to keep him from returning.
Sure enough, a shot rings out during the performance just as Tommy spies his uncle, and Carrington is killed in the front row. The police arrive, close the theater, and plan to arrest Tommy, but Chatrand hopes to awaken Tommy’s memory enough to identify the real killer and plays fast and loose buying time so he can stage one last act with Beverly’s help.
El Brendel is the thoroughly disposable comedy relief which I suggest you fast forward through. He was never funny (he fared somewhat better as a director), and here, teamed with a smart aleck child, it’s not hard to wish the bullet fired into the audience had claimed two other victims. Every scene with him is a complete waste of time.
But as I said, the real stars here are the sets and the magic acts designed by Menzies. Those and Lowe’s fast thinking magician are the best thing about the film, but the visuals are worth the price of admission at a fast fifty nine minutes. It’s just a shame they couldn’t wrap a better plot around them.
April 5th, 2020 at 10:06 pm
With the movie available on YouTube, at least for now, the price is is right. Will watch this one soon. I’ve grown to enjoy Lowe’s roles in his detective mysteries quite a bit.
April 5th, 2020 at 10:50 pm
Lowe is perfect in the role and the sets and tricks are well staged as you might imagine. I only wish the plot was up to the rest of the film.
April 6th, 2020 at 7:28 am
David, you should check out JUST IMAGINE, where El Beendel gets to carry the whole film!
April 6th, 2020 at 6:35 pm
Dan. didn’t he direct Just Imagine?
April 7th, 2020 at 10:25 am
For the record:
David Butler directed Just Imagine.
El Brendel, as best as I can determine, never directed anything.
I’m still trying to figure out whom David has him mixed up with.
April 7th, 2020 at 7:03 pm
It was JUST IMAGINE I was thinking of, his only critically accepted film and one I thought he was more involved in from the credit he used to get in Sci Fi film books when it was mentioned.
I’ve seen him in many films and never could stand the whole Lena and Ollie gag his whole career was based on. For my money he lessened any film he was in by his mere presence. He’s no John Qualen.
I usually admire the actors who did comedy relief in films of that era, but he is a huge exception.