Sun 2 Aug 2020
A PI Television Episode Review: BLACK TIE AFFAIR (1993).
Posted by Steve under Reviews , TV mysteries[4] Comments
BLACK TIE AFFAIR. 29 May 1993. NBC, 30m. Bradley Whitford (PI Dave Brodsky), Kate Capshaw, John Calvin, Bruce McGill, Alison Elliott. Written & directed by Jay Tarses.
Somebody thought the idea behind this show was a good one, at least at the beginning. A comedy spoof of a PI show? They must have thought laughs galore. And so not only did it make it onto the air, but it lasted all of five episodes before they decided that maybe it wasn’t such a good idea after all.
Thirteen were on the schedule, with the story to be played out over the run. I’ve just watched the first one on YouTube, and as long as it stays there, you can, too. In it PI Dave Brodsky is hired to follow a husband whom his wife – and his client – thinks he is having an affair with another woman, and she wants him followed. Disguised as a bellhop at a convention in which the husband is to be given a Man of the Year award, Brodsky finds a woman dead in the room in which the liaison is to take place – but the dead woman, surprisingly enough, apparently is not the woman he planned to liaison with.
End of installment one. Besides the fact that it is barely in focus, you don’t need to watch the embedded video if you don’t want to. There are some amusing lines, but everything is so overplayed, it’s not funny. Not even a laugh track would have helped. What’s most surprising is that it lasted five weeks.
PostScript: Every reference to the show I’ve found online (not many) is eager to point out that the working title for the series while it was in production was Smoldering Lust. Ha! False advertising there.
August 2nd, 2020 at 11:42 pm
On the other hand, Kevin Burton Smith loved it:
https://www.thrillingdetective.com/brodsky.html
Well, he and I can’t agree on everything. Maybe it gets better.
August 3rd, 2020 at 12:39 am
Wow, it took five episodes to cancel this? Guess it was something to do with Mrs. Spielberg, because it sure wasn’t acting, writing, or plot that got it on the air.
August 3rd, 2020 at 12:16 pm
Wait, I’ve updated the page & moved it onto the new site. It’s now at https://thrillingdetective.wordpress.com/2020/08/03/dave-brodsky/
And I’ve added a theory on why it was cancelled, for all you conspiracy buffs.
Now that Steve’s provided a link, I guess I should watch it again, see how I feel about it now. The 1993 me may not see it the way the 2020 me sees it. But I recall how pissed I was when NBC yanked the plug.
August 3rd, 2020 at 1:15 pm
I’ll wait to see what you think now, Kevin, and if you tell me I really ought to watch episode two before passing judgment on the entire series, well, it’s only 22 minutes long. I can do that.