Fri 14 Aug 2020
Archived Locked Room Mystery Review: LIONEL BLACK – The Penny Murders.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[5] Comments
LIONEL BLACK – The Penny Murders. Kate and Henry Theobald #5. Collins, UK, hardcover, 1979. Avon, US, 1st US printing, February 1980.
As if we didn’t already know, the age of electronics is upon us. When a wealthy numismatist is found shot to death in an inner sanctorum of his home, completely guarded by the most sophisticated of perimeter circuits and alarms, suicide is the only logical possibility. The dead man had the only keys, and they were found on his body.
Kate Theobald, unstoppable lady journalist, is persuaded by the manservant of the deceased, however, that there is more to the story. Not surprisingly, there is. Some information about the impossibly rare 1933 and 1954 English pennies, which supposedly never left the mint, comes to light, and so do some decidedly noxious wart s that had blighted the dead man’s personality.
Kate’s husband, Henry, is a barrister, the son of England’s most famous criminal lawyer, and a coin collector of sorts as well. Together, Kate and Henry make a pretty good team, although it is she who does most of the detecting, and he who (so reminiscent of the many pitfalls stumbled into by a certain Mrs. North) stupidly falls into a trap while trying to give her a hand.
The dialogue, as seems common in a goodly amount of British crime fiction, is blunt, terse, and flat. Black has an engaging writing style, and he uses it well to conceal the lack of depth exhibited by his characters. The solution is as up to date as today’s hardware store, and (surprisingly) it is as easily explained and as obvious ex post facto (an exciting phrase from the Latin which means here that, no, I didn’t figure it out but either) as most locked-room mysteries usually are.
Rating: C plus.
August 14th, 2020 at 8:47 pm
I enjoyed several of the Black Theobald titles, nothing brilliant, but the kind of reliable British mystery that used to be the norm.
August 14th, 2020 at 10:05 pm
I liked this one, nothing outstanding, but it was solid. I wish I remembered more of it. Maybe if I’d gone more into the business of the locked room and how well it was done (or not), more would come back to me now.
August 15th, 2020 at 6:25 am
Jackie read the series after British friends introduced them to us. I’d have to check Hubin, but I believe at least a couple of these were published as by “Anthony Matthews” in the U.S.
Yes, the first two were published in hardcover here by Walker as Matthews, the last three in paperback by Avon (as by Black).
Swinging Murder (1969)
Death Has Green Fingers (1971)
Death by Hoax (1974/1978)
A Healthy Way to Die (1976/1979)
The Penny Murders (1979)
August 15th, 2020 at 10:01 am
Thanks, Jeff. I’d forgotten about the Anthony Matthews pseudonym. Hubin lists two other Theobald books:
The Eve of the Wedding (Collins, 1980; Avon, 1981)
and
The Rumanian Circle (Collins, 1981) which never had a US edition.
Besides PENNY, I’m sure I read another in the series, but no more than that.
August 15th, 2020 at 2:12 pm
And for the sake of completeness, Lionel Black was itself a pen name, that of Dudley Barker, (1910-1980). He has in all 15-20 credits in Hubin.