Tue 22 Sep 2020
A Mystery Review by LJ Roberts: DONNA LEON – Trace Elements.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[5] Comments
Reviews by L. J. Roberts
DONNA LEON – Trace Elements. Commissario Guido Brunetti #29. Atlantic Monthly Press, hardcover, March 2020. Setting: Contemporary Venice.
First Sentence: A man and a woman deep in conversation approached the steps of Pone dei Lustraferi, both looking hot and uncomfortable on this late July afternoon.
Benedetta Toso, a dying hospice patient who asks to speak with the police, claims her husband, Vittorio Fadalto, was murdered over “bad money.†Commissario Brunetti and his colleague, Claudia Griffoni, promise to investigate the matter, but was it murder or an accident? Suspicions mount as they learn more about Vittorio’s job, that of collecting samples of water to be tested for contamination. Piecing together the tangled threads, Brunetti comes to realize the perilous meaning in the woman’s accusation and the threat it reveals to the health of the entire region.
With an excellent beginning, one learns that being a Neapolitan in Venice is a “far greater handicap than being a woman.”— and that one may not want to visit Venice during the summer. Leon’s voice is always a pleasure. When talking about the heat, she conveys the sense of it without referencing it directly– “Brunetti realized only then how hot he was. He tried to lift his right leg, but it was glued to the chair by sweat.” It is these touches that bring Venice to life by allowing us to see the city as those who live there do.
There is a second plot thread of two Romany pickpockets. It is interesting to learn the differences between how crimes are handled in Italy versus the United States. The secondary plot does raise interesting points. Leon’s descriptions, from the route to an address Brunetti takes that only a resident would know, to his description of a room badly decorated, to food, are a delight and bring the city to life. Even a plate of sandwiches at a bar sound good– “From the sides of the sandwiches spilled ham, egg tomato, tuna salad, radicchio, rucola, shrimp, artichokes, asparagus, and olives.”
Leon is wonderful at injecting verbal exchanges to make one chuckle. When called into his boss’s office, Signorina Elettra remarks– “If you aren’t out in fifteen minutes, I’ll call the police.” However, she is also very good at making one pause and consider, as with Bruno’s conversation with a nurse– “But if you work with death, you have to become spiritual, or you can’t do it any more. … when they get close to the end, you can sense their spirit, or you sense that it’s there. They do, too. And it helps them. And us.” She knows how to touch one’s emotions– “Griffoni…raised a hand and threw open her palm, as if to release the dead woman’s spirit into the air. The three of them remained silent for enough time to allow that spirit to escape the room…”
There is something wonderful about a policeman who reads Lysistrata for pleasure and describes Agamemnon as a “windbag commander.” The relationship between Brunetti and his wife Paoli adds normality. It is one of a couple who have been married a long time and still love one another. An interesting characteristic of Leon is that when her characters are in a professional setting, she references them by their surnames, yet when in a personal setting, or amongst one another as friends, she uses their first names.
Leon is incredibly good at building a story. She takes one along with her through the steps with an amazing subtlety to the clues. Trace Elements is a police procedural without car chases or gunplay, but with a somewhat political theme. It is a very contemporary mystery with a contemporary crime. It reflects on the degradation of true justice in our time and on compromise. For some, the ending may not seem satisfactory, but upon reflection, there is some small justice amidst justice that cannot be achieved.
Rating: Very Good.
September 22nd, 2020 at 9:40 pm
Leon is a delight to read, not always what I am looking for, but in the mood a perfect place to visit.
September 22nd, 2020 at 10:18 pm
An author whose first three books I purchased when they first came out in paperback, but one whose work I’ve yet to sample. And now there are 29 of them. Perhaps there’s time for me yet.
September 25th, 2020 at 12:53 pm
I agree, David, and take us there she does. Interestingly, The Germans made an excellent television of her books. Yes, it’s a bit strange to have Brunetti et. al. speaking German. But it is filmed in Venice. It’s also disconcerting that the actors playing Brunetti and Paola changed after the second, I think, episode, but the new actors are better. I loved watching it, even with subtitles, on Mhz. I only wish they had subtitled more than nine episodes. Still, one takes what one can get.
September 25th, 2020 at 12:59 pm
LJ, I didn’t think to see if any of books had been adapted for TV, and yes, there it is, on MHz via Amazon Prime. I know what I’m watching tonight. Thanks!
September 25th, 2020 at 1:45 pm
The name of the series, in case anyone else is looking, is DONNA LEON.