Sun 15 Nov 2020
Not a Review by Dan Stumpf: EDWARD S. AARONS – The Art Studio Murders.
Posted by Steve under Books Noted[6] Comments
AS A PERSONAL REFLECTION
by Dan Stumpf
EDWARD S. AARONS – The Art Studio Murders. Macfadden 50-198, paperback, 1964; Manor, paperback, 1975. Originally published by Handi-Book, #122, as Dark Memory by Edward Ronns; Avon 688, paperback, 1950, also as by Edward Ronns but under the new title.
First let me assure everyone out there that I don’t feel the least bit suicidal. But if I ever do, I know the perfect, fool-proof method: I shall simply call the Police, tell them I know who the Killer is, but I can’t name him over the phone — I must meet a Detective and tell him in person. Meeting arranged, I can simply sit back and relax, secure in the knowledge that when the cops get here, they will find me dead, bludgeoned from behind. Or fatally stabbed. Or perhaps shot. Maybe poisoned, a la The Big Sleep, but that’s rare. In any case, I shall be well & truly Dead.
Works all the time in fiction. With metronomic regularity. So much so that when I came across it here, I had a flashback to High School and Julius Caesar:
Shall this our lofty scene be acted over
In states unborn and accents yet unknown!â€
Well I couldn’t say off-hand, but I myself just couldn’t take any more. I closed Art Studio and picked up something else.
Up to that point, it had been a perfectly serviceable mystery. Aspiring artist and babe-magnet Henry Dana gets pushed off a subway platform two days before his big show at a prestigious gallery. No one sees him get pushed, the police are inclined to disbelieve him, and he himself begins to have doubts, but a second attack… well you can write the rest yourself. Or read my copy, which has a rather nice cover.
I just couldn’t get past that familiar phone call that always, invariably, repeatedly, inexorably, eternally, persistently, habitually, unceasingly, perpetually, unchangingly, endlessly, unfailingly, inalterably, everlastingly, and without exception, leads to the same end.
November 15th, 2020 at 8:29 pm
I love Aarons, but he did rely on cliche, and like Stephen King his endings were not a strong point. Usually a pleasant trip getting there, but not always as good as you were hoping it would be.
My favorite Aarons non series book is GIRL ON THE RUN about a lost treasure in Post War France where, for once, he nailed the landing.
For all the times this one was reprinted my overall reaction is only marginally better than Dan.
November 16th, 2020 at 8:02 am
Not just in books, but try watching Midsomer Murders and other similar crime shows on television – same thing. “I’ll come right over. There’s something I need to tell you.” Next scene – he or she is lying there, dead. In fact, we are watching all the old Inspector Morse shows on Britbox, and a couple of shows ago, this exact thing happened.
November 16th, 2020 at 12:23 pm
I wonder if whether in 1950 Mr. Aarons thought he had come up with something new in the world of crime fiction? It’s hard to say, but in truth I’m sure he hadn’t.
November 16th, 2020 at 12:26 pm
To David in Comment #1, here’s the link to my review of GIRL ON THE RUN:
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=59365
November 16th, 2020 at 3:53 pm
I like the covers, though.
November 16th, 2020 at 5:30 pm
Yes. Quite suitably trashy, to my way of thinking.