Tue 15 Jun 2021
A Movie Review by David Friend: GIDEON’S DAY (1958).
Posted by Steve under Mystery movies , Reviews[7] Comments
GIDEON’S DAY. Columbia Pictures, UK, 1958; US, 1959, as Gideon of Scotland Yard. Jack Hawkins (Chief Inspector George Gideon), Anna Lee, Anna Massey, Andrew Ray, Howard Marion-Crawford, John Loder. Based on the novel by John Creasey. Director: John Ford.
I don’t always enjoy police procedurals. To me, they’re either grim or boring. I was interested, though, in seeing this offering from the late ‘50s, as such slice-of-life films can lend us a window into another era. Sure enough, we get to see a lot of London in the year of Britain’s first motorway, the launch of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and – most importantly, of course – Cliff Richard’s debut single.
It’s a very English film, full of military types with stiff moustaches and even stiffer upper-lips. Despite all the red buses and clear class divisions, however, it was actually directed by the American Oscar-winning director John Ford. After all those gunfights, this must have been quite the change of pace.
The excellent Jack Hawkins plays the stolid and dependable Detective Chief Inspector George Gideon, known as Gee-Gee to his colleagues. A middle-aged, middle-class family man, Gideon struggles to balance his home life with the demands of a high-ranking man of the met. We follow him through a single day, as he discovers that a colleague has been accepting bribes, an escaped mental patient is at large and that a violent gang are stealing payrolls.
Throughout the film, Gideon is reminded that he must return home in time to enjoy tea with his wife’s aunt and uncle and accompany them to a concert in which his daughter will be giving a violin recital. In a recurring gag, Gideon is frustrated with a young, officious constable who fines him for running a red light. Such humour is needed, as the mental patient kills a young woman in a sexually-motivated attack and the colleague with the bribes is murdered by the gang.
Based on a novel by John Creasey, one of Britain’s most prolific writers, but now forgotten, Gideon’s Day is a fairly grim, mundane affair with an episodic structure and a day-in-the-life gimmick which isn’t always plausible and often contrived. The situations are clearly harrowing for the Chief Inspector, but his wife doesn’t seem to understand. Frustratingly, the film doesn’t deal with this and Gideon only ever apologises.
There are some decent actors on the bill: Anna Massey, in her first film, and Cyril Cusack and Laurence Naismith, and a brief role for John Le Mesurier and erstwhile Holmes and Watson Ronald Howard and Howard Marion-Crawford, appearing separately.
It’s good to see 1950s London in colour, but there’s little else to recommend this one.
Rating: **

June 15th, 2021 at 1:20 pm
I’m impressed — seriously impressed — that you managed to review this without mentioning legendary director John Ford, who seems to have phoned this one in.
June 15th, 2021 at 2:21 pm
I liked it, Ford in a different tempo. Not one of his great pictures, but for anyone else, just dandy.
June 15th, 2021 at 2:38 pm
I’m going to offer a dissenting view.
My 100-page book on Ford is available as a free web page:
http://mikegrost.com/ford.htm
John Ford made other crime dramas: THE BLUE EAGLE, BORN RECKLESS. My web page documents 14 main points of similarity between BORN RECKLESS and GIDEON’S DAY. GIDEON’S DAY has many “personal” artistic elements for Ford, that show up in other films by him, as well. These are documented in the lists that open the web-book. Please do a search for “Gideon’s Day” and these will all be highlighted.
Like other Ford films, GIDEON’S DAY is carefully designed in color. You can see this in the stills attached to the review.
Several of Ford’s Westerns have crime themes. See the absconding baker in STAGECOACH, the courtroom drama in SERGEANT RUTLEDGE. GIDEON’S DAY is not such a drastic change of pace for Ford.
Ford had other films set in Britain. Part of UPSTREAM shows its Shakespearean actor hero achieving fame on the British stage.
I agree that GIDEON’S DAY is a lesser Ford work. It is indeed grim and harrowing, as the review points out. But it is also rich in fascination, for its Ford themes, portrait of society, and use of color.
June 15th, 2021 at 2:43 pm
I strongly agree with Barry Lane’s comments.
A typo in my post: it should read “absconding banker”.
(I’m trying to imagine a baker absconding with his cupcakes!)
June 15th, 2021 at 4:30 pm
msg #3 reminds me of another Ford crime romp: ‘The Prisoner of Shark Island’.
But otherwise I agree that I don’t often associate this director with cityscapes. Prior to this review I might only have been able to mention ‘The Quiet Man’, ‘The Informer’, or ‘How Green Was My Valley’.
Count me surprised to learn of this title. But Jack Hawkins, Cyril Cusack, and that ‘running gag’ all sound charming. Anna Massey too –she was a wan beauty like Barbara Shelley.
June 16th, 2021 at 10:15 am
Dan, I cited Ford in the second paragraph.
June 16th, 2021 at 8:16 pm
I like the film better, though I concede most of the points made. I would point out the plot is very close to the book, save in the book one of the major crimes goes unsolved if not without justice, a theme that follows off and on throughout the series.
The long running television series GIDEON’S WAY with John Gregson as Gideon was generally better and still worth catching.
This was pretty much Creasey’s breakthrough in this country recieving rave reviews and selling far better than his other books — or many other writers for that matter. John D. MacDonald among others praised the books and was a fan, and Gideon titles often were listed among the best of the year.
The series was noted for humanizing the British policemn in the way Waugh and McBain had here.
As for Creasey, hardly forgotten. Many of his series are still available in ebook form including Roger West, the Toff, the Baron, Gordon Craigie, Dr. Palfrey, and Gideon. I know there is a prejudice among collectors only physical books count, but ebooks still make money which is how I judge if a writer is
forgotten.
Obviously they don’t sell like they once did, but they are far from obscure or hard to find.