Wed 15 Dec 2021
Reviewed by Tony Baer: PATRICIA HIGHSMITH – Edith’s Diary
Posted by Steve under Reviews[3] Comments
PATRICIA HIGHSMITH -Edith’s Diary. Simon & Schuster, hardcover, 1977. Pocket Books, paperback, 1978. Reprinted several times since. Film: Germant, 1983, as Edith’s Tagebuch (Edith’s Diary).
Edith has a diary. She got it from her beloved aunt. It’s a very nice diary.
Edith has a life. A pretty ordinary life. A husband, a son. The kind of son that likes to tear the wings off flies. But hey, you can’t have everything.
They move to the country from NYC. And that’s okay. Kinda boring. But okay.
Then her hubbie’s dilapidated uncle moves in to an upper bedroom, needing care, and stingy. But hey. No biggy.
Then her hubbie leaves her for a younger woman from the office.
Meh. No big deal. I mean, it sucks, right? But hey. Shit happens.
The kid grows up to be a nothingburger. A lush. A weakling. A beerbellied wanker.
But, meh, what can you do.
On the positive side, there’s Edith’s diary.
Why put down all the boring stupid things. Who has time for that?
Rather, put down the life you wish was happening. Similar. But with some perks.
Say, like, why write about her kid that’s a do-nothing wanker?
Rather, about her kid’s unrealized potential life: He goes to Princeton, he’s an engineer, he’s successful, he’s got a nice house, a nice wife, and two adorable little children.
Her diary becomes an alternate life. A life where her hopes and dreams become real. A life much more tangible and fulfilling than her own.
Becoming a sculptress, she even makes busts of her imaginary grandchildren, so they become real, out of clay.
She’s beginning to plan for their visit. She’s beginning to speak with them.
What could possibly go wrong?
December 15th, 2021 at 7:59 pm
But is the book any good? This is a promotional blurb, not a review.
December 15th, 2021 at 8:08 pm
Highsmith was always a high concept writer. Simple ideas spiral out of control, build on each other, and avalanche.
Not my favorite of her books, but a fine example of her building almost unbearable suspense from nothing but a broken life and a mind gone slightly off kilter.
Hard to review her properly without giving anything away, isn’t it?
December 15th, 2021 at 9:12 pm
David Anderson: highsmith is gonna be well crafted. That’s never in question. Is it good? What’s good? Is a gruesome traffic accident good? No? Then why do we all rubberneck to see it? That’s what highsmith is like. A horrible traffic accident happening in slow motion. Inevitable, tragic, disconcerting. I’m not gonna tell you it’s good. I’m not even gonna say I enjoyed it. But I rubbernecked the accident. And I’d do it again.