Fri 28 Jan 2022
A Made-for-TV Movie Review by Dan Stumpf: THE LADY’S NOT FOR BURNING (1974).
Posted by Steve under Reviews , TV Drama[6] Comments
THE LADY’S NOT FOR BURNING. Made-for-TV movie. KCET / Hollywood Television Theater / PBS, 1974. Richard Chamberlain, Eileen Atkins, Jacques Aubuchon, John Carradine, Keene Curtis, Scott Hylands, Tom Lacy, Stephen McHattie, Rosemary Murphy, Laurie Prange, and Kristoffer Tabori. From Christopher Fry’s play (1948). Directed by Joseph Hardy.
With its frequent references to tumult and celebration off-stage, this cries out to be made as a movie, but the nearest it’s come is two made-for-TV tapings of the play, and the 1987 version was ruined by Kevin Branagh’s over-acting. This 1974 production, however, is a joy to watch: perfectly cast, well-paced, and directed with an affinity for Fry’s wit and melancholy in equal measure.
Set in the Mayor’s house in a medieval village, the story builds itself on the contrasting characters who come and linger: Thomas Mendip, a wandering veteran back from some meaningless war, wants to be hanged; Alizon, a young innocent, is trothed to marry Humphrey, the Mayor’s snarkey nephew — or possibly his loutish bother Nicholas. Jenna, an alchemist’s daughter, arrives pursued by a witch-hunting mob, soon joined by a musical Priest and a hedonist Magistrate. Stir in the Mayor’s supremely serene sister, composed of equal parts Gracie Allen and Margaret Dumot, add a sensitive young Clerk smitten with Alizon, and you get a story that almost writes itself.
Well actually, Christopher Fry wrote it, with his usual wit and obvious love of the characters. Nor does he stint on the action. There’s a lot of talk, to be sure, mostly about love, death, God and the Devil, but there’s more conflict than conversation here, and much more wit than piety. I particularly enjoyed Jenna’s debate with herself over whether to sleep with Humphrey or burn at the stake, and her carnal indignation when Mendip threatens to kill her option (“Sluts are human, too.â€)
I said this was perfectly cast, and it is, from Kristoffer Tabori’s callow swain to Jacques Aubuchon’s venal magistrate, but Chamberlain and Atkins rightly dominate the piece — his ghastly grin when she asks why he wants to be hanged and he replies, “I owe it to myself.†is a marvelous bit of sheer theater. They dominate, I should say until the last few minutes, when John Carradine staggers out onstage as old Skipps, the drunken Rag & Bones man, and proceeds to blow everyone else into the wings. A small part, but unforgettable.
Try to catch this one. It’s one of those that manages to entertain and make you feel a bit smarter.
January 28th, 2022 at 8:27 pm
This is a very informative review.
I didn’t know this version existed.
A few years ago, I discovered a DVD of the Branagh version at the public library. Took it home and loved it.
As usual, watched it with subtitles on. So I read the play and watched it / listened to the actors at the same time.This really helps me understand things. Especially with dialogue as complex as this play.
Three days later, found the 1950 recording of the play on YouTube. This has Sir John Gielgud and a young Richard Burton. Too bad they couldn’t get anyone talented. (Just joking!) It was terrific too. As the text was fresh in my mind, I had no trouble understanding the actors. This version is audio only. Apparently it was released on records.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vKfw8J3eyw
Keep meaning to read more Fry plays. But so far this is the only one.
January 28th, 2022 at 11:11 pm
This is far and away the preferred filmed version though I liked the Brannagh a bit better than Dan does. Superb cast all around and probably Chamberlain’s finest moment.
I originally caught this with no idea who Fry was or what I was going to see and was delighted.
Why it hasn’t been rescued and issued in a better print I can’t imagine, but it as good a television adaptation of the play as I can imagine with everyone in it pitch perfect.
Carradine reminds audiences that once there was a stage actor of Barrymore quality in that tall angular frame.
If I recall this featured Richard Burton and Sir John Gielgud on stage originally.
January 28th, 2022 at 11:13 pm
If you wanted an actor who would blow everyone else into the wings, John Carradine was your man.
SDH subtitles are a must for me too. I wish I could blame the audio technology.
January 29th, 2022 at 6:06 am
Some other Fry plays which are recommendable are A Phoenix Too Frequent (one-acter based on a story by Petronius), Venus Observed (which has one of the longest sentences ever written in a play) and The Dark Is Light Enough. There are filmed versions of the first two of these, though I don’t know how easy of access they are.
January 29th, 2022 at 1:55 pm
I notice charismatic, little-known actor Scott Hylands in the cast. He was the biplane pilot in the wonderful period-actioner, “Death Hunt” (Lee Marvin, Charles Bronson) and he was the lead detective in the odd “Night Heat” TV series. There was always something odd about that show, everything took place at night and the production was filmed someplace like Toronto.
January 29th, 2022 at 4:11 pm
“Something ain’t right – there’s too much heat in the night!”
At least that’s what the catchy theme song for NIGHT HEAT says.
I used to watch this too. But have hardly seen more than a tiny few of the 96 episodes. Scott Hylands was indeed very good.