Mon 23 Jan 2023
A PI Mystery Review by David Vineyard: EARL NORMAN – Kill Me on the Ginza.
Posted by Steve under Bibliographies, Lists & Checklists , Characters , Reviews[7] Comments
EARL NORMAN – Kill Me on the Ginza. Burns Bannion #6. Berkley Y626, paperback original, 1962. Barye Phillips cover art. Also available in ebook format (Kindle).
You know the old saying, “you can’t keep a good thing down?†It seems sometimes you can’t keep a bad thing down either, which explains why Earl Norman’s Burns Bannion novels are back in print.
Burns Bannion is an expatriate American private eye in Tokyo (each book gives us a long winded explanation how the Japanese would never give an American a P. I. License so Bannion is enrolled as a college student, but never goes to class), and an expert in karate. Literally the little bits of karate you get in these slender books is about the only reason to read them though they promised at times to be so bad they are good without quite making it.
This one opens with our hero in a club on the Ginza, the neon club district in wide open Post War Tokyo, Burns is leaving a club when a pneumatic Japanese performer heaving precariously in her low cut outfit smacks him over the head with a metal tray.
So far I can’t disagree with anything she says.
This is really poverty row private eye stuff with a little international intrigue and exotic locations thrown in. In every book Bannion meets one dimensional (character wise, physically they are three dimensional) Japanese women in various states of undress and gets drawn into pretty non-dimensional cases.
Bannion fails to recognize this one because she has her clothes on, and he last saw her a week earlier in the buff posing at the Art Photography Studio for Photo Fans also on the Ginza (next to the Urological and Sexual Institute we are told) where Bannion had pretended to be a photographer to check her out for a client, Hedges, a correspondent. Seems the girl, G. N. Noriko was a friend of Bill Crea a missing correspondent who disappeared on a trip to Kobe.
Before he can go to Kobe though Inspector Ezawa, another Karate man, picks up Bannion and Hedges and takes them to the train station where a dismembered body has been found, and the police have been sent his head in a bowling bag. Bill Crea’s head.
Not a terrible opening despite Norman’s somewhat tiresome version of wise guy private eye-ese. In this one he’s battling a cult, the Oshira, based on a prototype of modern Japanese gods and predating Buddhism, the hidden god, and something called the Grand Apex which turns out to be a front for sex trafficking from Korea while Bannion gets help from G. N. (and you do not want to know what those initials stand for) and a stripper called Bay-bee.
There’s also a philosophical criminal called House Charnel who talks like Nietzsche on LSD: “We are all born into the world as enemies.â€
I can see where these time killers were exotic enough at the time to draw some readers. The plots are serviceable, there is a lot of talk about sex and pneumatic Japanese beauties, and of course karate battle aplenty (I wanted to get my hands free so I could Karate-chop the Whore-master to his just rewards.).
I have a feeling that many people feel more kindly about these than I do, and I have no problem with that.
I will give Norman this, he manages to keep the action boiling down to the last page and without a single chapter break — that’s right, the edition I read had no chapter breaks, just continuous narrative, and I have a suspicion this may be his best book, though that isn’t saying a lot. He knows something about Japan and probably could have parlayed that into something interesting, but never does.
The Burns Bannion series —
Kill Me in Tokyo. Berkley 1958 [Tokyo]
Kill Me in Shimbashi. Berkley 1959 [Tokyo]
Kill Me in Yokohama. Berkley 1960 [Japan]
Kill Me in Shinjuku. Berkley 1961 [Tokyo]
Kill Me in Yoshiwara. Berkley 1961 [Tokyo]
Kill Me in Atami. Berkley 1962 [Japan]
Kill Me on the Ginza. Berkley 1962 [Tokyo]
Kill Me in Yokosuka. Erle 1966 [Japan]
Kill Me in Roppongi. Erle 1967 [Japan]
January 23rd, 2023 at 10:19 pm
Back in the 1970s, when I first started selling mystery paperbacks by mail, the Bannion books were extremely popular. Whenever I found one, I knew I could sell it almost immediately.
Unfortunately those early Berkley books were not distributed well, and I almost never found any of them.
Did I ever read one? No, I never had time to do so. I see now I had no reason to regret it.
January 24th, 2023 at 9:13 am
A friend of mine who was stationed in Japan and read these books when they were new really liked them. I think it’s probably one of those “you had to be there” things. I have most of them but have never read one. Maybe someday.
January 24th, 2023 at 10:55 am
James got my comment almost exactly – it is definitely a “time and place” kind of thing. After reading several of Richard S. Prather’s Shell Scott books, someone handed me one of these and I ended up reading three or four of them. (I remember KILL ME IN TOKYO and KILL ME IN YOKOHAMA for sure.) This was ca. 1962 and I was 13, so definitely more likely to read them than I am now.
January 24th, 2023 at 8:32 pm
I can see the appeal of these in the time period and at certain ages, probably why I didn’t come down harder on them, but they really aren’t very good, and there isn’t much to them beside the most basic of private eye tropes; a little exoticism of the Japanese setting, some karate lore (itself exotic in this era), and a lot of pneumatic bimbos (and they are all bimbos in Norman’s books no average Japanese women make it into the books).
January 24th, 2023 at 9:47 pm
This reminds me in a way of the Honey West books by G. G. Fickling. They came out about the same time, and I once again, when I found them while scouting all the local used bookshops, I knew I could sell them almost immediately. A female PI with sexy escapades? Va voom!
But when I took the time to actually read one myself, boy was I disappointed. Classic PI lit they were not.
January 24th, 2023 at 11:43 pm
I found Honey West a bit more palatable, but only because the character was less annoying than Burns Bannion. Honey West is a bit closer to Shell Scott, Prather even a friend of the Ficklings, where Bannion seems pretty serious about things lacking much semblance of sense of humor.
You could at least get a chuckle out of Honey finding yet another way to be chased by a killer wearing nothing but a smile. Burns was pretty much second-rate Spillane, nothing wrong with that, I liked the Rocky Steele books, but there was something a bit tacky and cheap about Norman and Bannion that just didn’t gel for me.
I guess you either bought the gimmick or you didn’t and I didn’t.
September 19th, 2023 at 1:22 pm
Searching for entire set of Earl Norman paperback books.