Mon 3 Apr 2023
Reviewed by David Vineyard: PHILIP WYLIE – The Savage Gentleman.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[5] Comments
PHILIP WYLIE – The Savage Gentleman. Farrar & Rinehart, hardcover, 1932. Dell #85, paperback, 1945. Avon #390, paperback, 1952. University of Nebraska Press, softcover, 2011.
Betrayed by his wife, newspaper magnate Stephen Stone takes his small son Henry and with his trusted companion Jack, a giant black man, and with the Scotsman McCobb travels to a savage paradise where he runs his yacht the Falcon aground. “Suddenly I remembered this island … I knew then that my son was going to be brought up without the influence of women. Without the knowledge of women they imbue in men.â€
So the small group of men carve a world on the island and young Henry grows into manhood, a copper haired bronzed giant, perfect in mind and body, but a savage as far as the outer world goes. Eventually Stephen repents of his anger and madness and tries to make it up to Jack (respectfully written for the era, but unfortunately a sacrificial figure, a trope still too common), McCobb, and especially Henry, but dies before he can guide Henry’s entry into civilization. While he will be fabulously rich in the real world, is Henry ready for the modern world and is the modern world ready for Henry Stone, the savage gentleman?
Henry is none the less a superman in body and mind save for his one weakness, he is completely guileless when it comes to women, which is why when Henry meets Marian Whitney the daughter of his father’s attorney and oldest friend Elihu Whitney Henry is knocked for a loop.
The great muscles in his jaws were knotted.
His hands hung limp.
Henry isn’t just love struck, he practically has a stroke. It doesn’t help that the first thing Marian does is to enter the room laughing at the newspaper story about the recently rescued Henry Stone, a savage who probably will have to be locked up in the zoo.
If that all sounds vaguely familiar it must be pointed out that even Lester Dent admitted he had read Wylie’s Savage Gentleman. Henry may not trill when he’s thinking or be a polymath in all subjects, and he doesn’t have an Arctic fortress or five of the most brilliant men in the country as an entourage, but he is that favorite figure of the Twenties, the superman, and somewhere between Tarzan and John Galt, he hits New York by storm.
Of course Philip Wylie was an old hand at this. Science fiction pioneer, pulpster, sophisticated writer of stories for the slicks, literary maven, humorist, early environmentalist, philosopher, and gadfly, his career encompassed classics in all those genres.
Even the most shallow of overviews of his career include Gladiator which inspired Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster to create Superman, When Worlds Collide, which inspired Alex Raymond to create Flash Gordon (and its own strip Speed Spaudling), The Murderer Invisible (as much the inspiration of the Invisible Man films as H. G. Wells novel). the Crunch and Des stories that helped influence John D. MacDonald to create Travis McGee, and works such as Finlay Wren, As They Reveled, Generation of Vipers, They Both Were Naked, Triumph,Tomorrow, and The Disappearance. He was a respected science fiction author, mystery writer, and literary figure all the while letting his mind and imagination range free where ever it lead him (often as not into controversy).
Meanwhile Henry has returned to find his father’s newspaper has, under the guidance of corrupt newsman Voorhies, been commandeered by the forces of crime and corruption and of course Henry isn’t going to bother with the courts to take that on ending with a wild melee as Henry reclaims his legacy with fists flying amid a hail of gunfire.
As a wounded Henry lies in his hospital bed at the end, Marian comes to tell him she loves him, and in scene that will be copied in a million variations in countless Hollywood newspaper movies to come…
“But —â€
“Say! I’m a newspaper man now. Get a stenographer. But give me a kiss before you go and have another kiss ready when you get back!â€
Just how this one avoided Hollywood I don’t know. You can practically see it as you read it as a Frank Capra film with Gary Cooper or Joel McCrea and Jean Arthur or Carole Lombard. The Savage Gentleman is a relatively short book, very much a pulp adventure tale, and more of interest as a yarn than philosophy, but that is all to the good, and there is no such think as superficial Wylie, his active mind at work in even the simplest of tales his eye every bit as savage as his hero.
April 3rd, 2023 at 4:54 pm
Wow! More to be said but not by me at this time.
April 3rd, 2023 at 5:43 pm
I have not read the source, but David sold it. Could this kid have grown up to be Donald Trump? Intended apolitically.
April 3rd, 2023 at 6:05 pm
Barry,
‘Lovestruck’ is something I have a hard time envisioning the orange man of whom you speak.
April 3rd, 2023 at 8:17 pm
The 20’s superman or ubermensch that evolved into Doc Savage, Superman, and Captain America among others was a pretty common figure in the fiction of Edgar Rice Burroughs, George Allan England, Olaf Stapleton, and into the thirties and forties Stanley G. Weyman, Norvel Page, and Robert A. Heinlein.
Even Walter Tevis gave us his MOCKINGBIRD a relatively late entry superman as was Frederick Pohl’s MAN PLUS and Martin Caidin’s SIX MILLION DOLLAR MAN.
He tended to be a tragic figure in most serious fiction as in Wylie’s GLADIATOR or Weyman’s NEW ADAM, an outsider who was so alien and other than he repulsed most humans. Wylie himself was fascinated with variations of the superman both in his popular and serious fiction with variations in everything from NOTHING BUT THE NIGHT to THE SPY WHO SPOKE PORPOISE from the physical to the mental superman in different books.
As for Wylie unrepentant intellectual, iconoclast, gadfly, fearless controvertist, sexually outspoken, and environmentalist he never saw a battle he wouldn’t engage taking on Momism and Religion with equal zeal.
And, of course, he had one last tie to popular entertainment. THE MARCUS NELSON MURDERS was based on the shocking murder of his daughter in New York and introduced the character of Telly Savalas Kojack.
As for Donald, apolitically and Achilles heels to the contrary, not many supermen have bone spurs, but I can see Howard Hughes imagining himself in this role.
April 3rd, 2023 at 9:33 pm
David,
Our hero has a physical flaw, like Samson’s hair. Donald’s hair is problematic, perhaps barely existent, so bone spurs seem to work. I salute the thought.