Fri 23 Feb 2024
Reviewed by Tony Baer: JAMES GUNN – Deadlier Than the Male.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[7] Comments
JAMES GUNN – Deadlier Than the Male. Duell Sloan and Pearce, hardcover. 1942. Signet #709, paperback, 1949. Forthcoming from Stark House Press, softcover, April 2024 (intro by Curtis Evans). Film adaptation: Released as Born to Kill (RKO Radio Pictures, 1947, with Claire Trevor, Lawrence Tierney, Walter Slezak).
Legend has it that there was a time where men were men and women were women. James Gunn is here to tell you that that time, if it ever existed, wasn’t in 1942.
Sam Wild is a man. A wild man, a man’s man, a ladies man. He’s redheaded, rough and tough and he smells like sweat.
Mrs. Krantz runs a boarding house and lives for the lurid stories of her only friend: Laura Pollicker.
Laura is a marginally wealthy, flaccid gigolo-monger, in ruffles. Picture Bette Davis’s Baby Jane trying to seduce you. She comes bearing gifts.
Laura regales Mrs. Krantz with legendary lovemaking with her new beau: He’s redheaded, rough and tough and he smells like sweat.
Sam Wild finds his benefactor with another gigolo, and goes wild, killing Laura Pollicker as well as his rival.
The cops have no clues. But Mrs. Krantz is determined to sniff out the killer: “Laura was all I had. Laura and the bottle. There’s nothing I can do for the bottle, but I won’t let Laura down.”
There’s a pretty funny scene where Mrs. Krantz tracks Sam Wild down, sits two rows behind him at the theater, trying to sniff him out, leans over the dividing row, sticking her huge ass high in the air, blocking the view of the other patrons, inhaling deeply at the smell of her prey, exclaiming: “Laura! I found him!”
Sam Wild escapes from Mrs. Krantz, only to be ensnared by Helen, a blonde bombshell. And Sam, for all his animal force, realizes he’s lost to “the most beautiful smiling thing I ever saw, with a body like honey and a face that smiles. She sits and smiles and swings her legs, above me, above the world, knowing she’s better than anybody ever was, sure that she and her kind own the earth we live on. And they do. And she hates me.”
But “Helen had had about enough of men sobbing on beds. She slapped his face, hard. He cringed as she leaned over him.”
Helen is a femme fatale for the ages. She destroys everyone in her orbit and emerges unscathed, nay better, stronger, richer, more powerful than ever, by the end. A school of weak men drowned in her wake.
—–
I liked the book. Didn’t love it. But then again I already knew the femme fatale was deadlier than the male. It may have been news in 1942, but it’s a pretty well trodden path today. The reviews of the day showed the book by this 21 year old writer blew people away: “This Stanford Senior writes better than Cain ever wrote”, said John Selby in his syndicated book review. The philosopher Gilles Deleuze named it his favorite of the first 1000 serie noires.
So ‘people’ love it. But it’s always hard to know what history was like before it happened. I’ve already seen Body Heat and many more like it. So I’m not surprised. But if readers of 1942 were used to Goldilocks, they had another think coming. A think which must have felt a bit like when Mrs. Krantz, “with all her might … jabbed up between his legs with her hatpin.”
February 23rd, 2024 at 2:39 pm
Here’s a link to the movie’s Wikipedia page.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_to_Kill_(1947_film)
It goes into detail about the controversy that arose upon its release, but doesn’t say anything about the book itself.
For that, another essay on the book is here:
https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/lure-devil-james-gunns-deadlier-male-gilles-deleuzes-philosophy-crime-novels/
February 23rd, 2024 at 3:37 pm
Here’s the film: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KltT_rTDYx4
February 23rd, 2024 at 10:12 pm
And here’s some good news: I’ve just discovered that Stark House Press will be reprinting the book in April.
February 23rd, 2024 at 10:40 pm
There seemed to be in that era an attempt to see who could write the most bleak, violent, and savage book, and Gunn certainly raised the stakes. Psychosexuality ran rampant through the James M. Cain stakes in the period.
February 24th, 2024 at 5:52 am
I’m withya on this one. A good enough book, if you want to spend your time with good-enough books.
February 24th, 2024 at 10:06 am
Read this in June 2021 in the Chartered Mystery Digest format. Made a note to myself: “Great Read!!!” A couple blurbs on the back cover:
DEADLIER THAN THE MALE by James Gunn, is more on the horror than the mystery side, but is exceptionally well written. (Book of the Month Club) & DTTM is on the James Cain order, but bloodier, nastier, tougher, and will chill you pleasantly. (Clifton Fadiman, in the New Yorker.
Back cover also says this is Gunn’s first book, and he went to work in Hollywood where his first job was on the script of “The G-STRING Murders”.
February 27th, 2024 at 8:06 pm
Re: msg #6. I lurvv ‘The G-String Murders’ by which I mean to say, I love the Babs Stanwyck musical-comedy-mystery made from it (hope I gots all me facks straight here; I admit not having read the original pulp by …Gypsy Rose Lee (?)
Anywayz, the Stanwyck farce is an all-time feel-good homage to burlesque. Utterly hilarious characters and astonishing physical dance routines.
Some might scoff, but I say the grainy, murky poor-quality b&w print we see today offers a lurid Broadway mystery like no other. My favorite depiction of backstage vaudeville.
Lawrence Tierney, et al tough guys: was recently reading about Leo Gordon. Another scary dude wit a b.g. cut from da same bolt o’ cloth..