Thu 1 Aug 2024
SF Diary Review: HARRY HARRISON – Deathworld 3.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Science Fiction & Fantasy[4] Comments
HARRY HARRISON – Deathworld 3. Dell #1849, paperback original; 1st printing, May 1968. Cover art: John Berkey. Ace, paperback, 1987. Serialized earlier in Analog SF, Feb-Mar-Apr 1968, as The Horse Barbarians.
Jason dinAlt convinces some of the inhabitants of the planet Pyrrus (Deathworld 27) to attempt resettling on Felicity. Rich mineral deposits await them, but the native barbarians make the new planet only slightly less unfriendly to new off-world settlers. Their culture is that of warring tribesmen, cities are [restricted] by traditional laws, and death by following the law is [definitely an] obstacle.
The Pyrrans attempt infiltration of the most powerful clan, led by Temuchin, but they discover that cultural change can come only from within, and that defeat can lead to final victory.
Too much of the story is spent on the wrong approach, which would be acceptable if bloodshed were an approved form of entertainment. [Worse], Jason has on page 21 a computer capable of providing the necessary conclusions, and it is not until page 167 that it even appears in the story again. The emphasis on fighting and violence is not justified, […] with the latter breaking out over and over again.
Rating: ***
August 1st, 2024 at 10:37 pm
Harrison’s “Deathworld” series consists of three novels followed by one short story, and in fact has its own Wikipedia page:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deathworld
Considerably more detail is given on this page than I did in the review of this, the third in the series.
(I do not remember if I’d read the first two novels before tackling this one.)
August 2nd, 2024 at 11:57 pm
Interesting set up, but as you point out it feels as if it is more interested in effect than the internal logic of the story or series.
August 3rd, 2024 at 1:46 pm
I read the original DEATHWORLD in ASTOUNDING long, long ago. Loved it. I read the sequels and found them…mediocre. I also read Harry Harrison’s THE STAINLESS STEEL RAT series. Loved the first couple books…and the rest went on a downhill slide.
August 3rd, 2024 at 3:36 pm
George, I’ve not read enough of Harrison’s work to be able to say for sure, but based on what I *have* read, I very much tend to agree with you.