Mon 23 Sep 2024
Reviewed by Tony Baer: ROBERT REEVES – Cellini Smith, Detective.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[4] Comments
ROBERT REEVES – Cellini Smith, Detective. Houghtono Mifflin, hardcover, 1943. Pony Books #54, paperback, 1946.
Cellini Smith ain’t doing so good financially. So when the hoboes offer him twenty six dollars and ninety-four cents to find a murderer, he doesn’t have to be asked thrice.
Somebody’s murdered one of the hoboes’ own. And they demand the perpetrator be handed over to them, for hobo styled justice.
Turns out the murdered hobo wasn’t any ordinary hobo. The nogoodnik son of a mining mogul, he’d absconded with a map of a hitherto unclaimed, untapped hubnerite mine in California — a good source of tungsten, better than a goldmine in times of war. He’d strike out on his own, and make it rich, out and under from his oppressive daddy.
But to start the mine running, he needed about $20,000. Who better to get money from than the local mob boss? So he gets the money for the mine, and immediately starts fooling around with the mobster’s moll.
Real smart.
And now he’s dead. Big surprise.
Still, Cellini Smith investigates the thing, laying his life on the line for nickels.
He solves the thing methodically, calling all the suspects and cops into a room for a presentation of his inductive genius.
____
Middle of the road, done fairly well in a unique voice. But of course, to me, any authentic hardboiled detective novel from the 40’s done fairly well is worth reading. Your mileage may vary.
September 24th, 2024 at 12:50 am
Probably better than 95% of the crime novels published this year!
September 27th, 2024 at 6:31 pm
My bio of Robert Reeves here:
https://pulpflakes.com/blog/2023/09/the-mysterious-life-of-robert-reeves-storyteller-soldier/
And a review of one of his short stories here:
https://pulpflakes.com/blog/2023/06/secrets-of-the-mask-part-13-nickel-and-dime-detective/
September 27th, 2024 at 7:34 pm
Good stuff, Sai, as always. Thanks!
September 27th, 2024 at 10:51 pm
Reeves and Smith are solidly in the screwball school of hardboiled tecs and as the review shows, lean into the detective story angle in the manner of Hammett, Whitfield, and Halliday rather than the violence and atmosphere style.
After years out of print some of the Reeves Smith stuff is available in trade paperback editions in pricey but attractive volumes. Its an interesting fairly forgotten series and writer left too long in relative obscurity.