Thu 6 Feb 2025
An Archived PI Mystery Review by Francis M. Nevins: RICHARD S. PRATHER – The Amber Effect.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[9] Comments
RICHARD S. PRATHER – The Amber Effect. Shell Scott #40. Tor, hardcover, 1986; paperback, 1987.
The ingredients of today’s private eye fiction are brooding and corruption, mangled relationships and a soiled world. But there was a time when, if you picked up a PI book by one particular writer you’d be grabbed by plot situations wild and woolly as a bighorn ram, by characters straight off the nut tree — including a bevy of nubile bubbleheads sans clothes or sexual inhibitions –and by narrative and dialogue eccentric enough to pop the eyeballs.
For this particular writer the private eye novel wasn’t a Film Noir in prose, it was a hoot, no more believable or substantial than a comic book but outrageously, bawdily funny while it lasted. His name was Richard S. Prather and his principal character was Shell Scott, a big ex-Marine PI with the white hair cut Camp Lejuene style and the angular eyebrows and the Cad convertible and the tropical fish.
Scott was the first major private eye whose adventures were published as paperback originals, and roughly 40,000,000 copies of those escapades were sold between his debut in 1950 and the mid-1970s. Then, for reasons too complicated to go into here, Prather shut down his word factory. The good news is that production has started up again — this time in hardcover — and that none of his inspired looniness has been lost.
Prather plots defy summary. Suffice it to say that The Amber Effect kicks off with Scott finding the doorway of his L.A. apartment graced by an undraped lovely who is both the winner of the Miss Naked California contest and the target of a gaggle of hit men, including a human clam, an ex-Rams linebacker, and a half-senile gun-for-hire known in the trade as One Shot.
In time Scott finds the connection between the lady and a weirdo scientist who, before he was murdered, invented something potentially worth billions. All trails lead to a pair of unforgettable wacked-out action scenes where. without a gun and assisted only by several three-dimensional holograms of himself, Scott takes on the entire cast of bad guys.
The Amber Effect isn’t way out there in the stratosphere with alternative classics like Prather’s 1964 The Trojan Hearse, but — insane story-line, juvenile double entendres, Fifties mammary fixations, and all — -it’s a tour de farce of the sort no one in the world but this particular writer could have turned out, and it’s wonderful to have him back at work.
February 6th, 2025 at 1:32 pm
“”…Juvenile double entendres, Fifties mammary fixations…”
Ah, memories, but in my case it was the Sixties. Guys in my high school who would never be caught reading a book would flock to pick up the latest Shell Scott.
February 6th, 2025 at 1:45 pm
This sounds like a lot of fun! To my shame, I’ve never read any Shell Scott. However, this review has inspired me to get started. Kindle Unlimited has box sets of most of the novels; I’ve downloaded the first one and am about to get stuck in.
February 6th, 2025 at 3:13 pm
I have no idea what readers today might think of the Shell Scott books. When I read them back in the late 50s, they were great. When Jerry read them in the 60s, they were still a lot of fun. When Mike read this later one some 35 years ago, he liked it a lot. But all of this took place quite a while ago.
If you find yourself so inclined, Dominic, report back when you can.
February 7th, 2025 at 11:43 pm
Prather is often described as Spillane crossed with Robert Leslie Bellem, but the truth is he was an original who had his own unique voice and style that developed fairly quickly once he started writing about Scott.
I don’t worry much about what modern readers would think about Prather, fact is Scott’s adventures are available in ebook form and seem to sell fairly well so I assume some modern readers are consuming them and enjoying them.
Of course they will never be the phenomena they once were again, but neither will Spillane, John D. MacDonald, or Ross Macdonald, not the way Chandler and Hammett have stayed in the the public imagination.
As for the “bubbleheads sans clothes” that included Scott himself who lost his own clothes in his adventures as much as any of the women.
I’m not quite as enthusiastic about that late set of Scott adventures as this review is. They aren’t bad, but I would even argue the series lost some momentum once Prather moved to Pocket Books. They aren’t bad books, they just don’t quite match the level of cranky genius the Gold Medal books did.
February 8th, 2025 at 9:27 am
I remember being excited to read this one when it came out but then finding it slightly disappointing. Not bad, mind you, I still enjoyed it quite a bit, but I’m afraid my expectations were too high.
My favorite Shell Scott story–and I’ve probably told this here before, so bear with me–was when I was reading one of them in algebra class (I’d already finished my work, so why not?) and the teacher walked up to my desk with a stern look on his face. He was also the head football coach at our high school, so he could be a little intimidating. He said, “Is that one of those Shell Scott books, Reasoner?” I replied nervously, “Uh, yeah, Coach.” A big grin breaks out on his face. “I love those! I’ve read ’em all!” We were good friends the rest of my high school career despite me not being an athlete.
February 8th, 2025 at 1:53 pm
It’s a great story, James, one worth retelling whenever you want!
February 21st, 2025 at 8:22 am
Sounds like soft sci-fi. Will there be any more with Scott?
February 21st, 2025 at 11:37 am
Richard Prather died in 2007, and while the original books are still available as eBooks or POD format, Shell Scott seems to have passed away along with him. I haven’t heard of anyone being signed up to write anything more about him
February 26th, 2025 at 1:55 pm
Apologies for the delay in getting back. It’s been a busy few weeks.
It turned out that I *had* read the first Shell Scott novel, Case of the Vanishing Beauty. I read it again anyway, and I’m now about halfway through the second one, Bodies in Bedlam.
I’m enjoying them. Are they dated? Sure. Attitudes have changed a bit in the past 75 years. Is there much psychological depth? Not so far. But the prose is entertaining and the plots keep you turning the pages. I’m definitely going to keep on reading.