Tue 11 Feb 2025
Diary Review: JOHN D. MacDONALD – A Flash of Green.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews[11] Comments
JOHN D. MacDONALD – A Flash of Green. Simon & Schuster, hardcover, 1962. Crest, paperback, date? Reprinted many times. Film: International Spectrafilm, 1984, with Ed Harris, Blair Brown, Richard Jordan.
What might easily only be a story about the expanding universe of Elmo Bliss very quickly becomes a study of reporter Jimmy Wing, who is offered an inside position in Elmo’s organization, geared to eventually be put him in the governor’s chair. Jimmy accepts, with his usual rationalized reservations. His job, to uncover the facts necessary for blackmail; the rationalizations being someone else would do it, somebody not quite so kind. And being on the inside has its own attractions. But once he rationalizes, the decision has been made.
Blackmail is considered necessary to defeat the birdwatchers opposed to filling in Grassy Bay for commercial purposes. The beginning grabs, the warnings are there, you know it’s going to be a nasty fight. Elmo has his own simplified views of man’s place in nature, of the abstraction of art and beauty, of man-devised tourist attractions as opposed to nature’s own. But in today’s pragmatic world, his views are those which are applied to the Florida of the green dollar. Which is not to pick on Florida, of course.
And the bay is filled in, with the aid of the pure in heart: the businessman with an eye to the community good, the anti-Communists who pave the way for the efficient action of free enterprise, and the zealous religionists who tie and beat those who do not confirm.
It is nasty, but not until the beating of Jackie Halliday will Jimmy have enough. His exposure of Elmo’s plans stop future ambitions for the governorship, but this does not seem enough to pay for only the physical damage done, and it is difficult to believe that life in Palm City can go on as before. But on the surface it seems to …
Lots of characters, fully realized, in depth, but almost too many to keep track of. Wives of businessmen tend to blur into identical sameness, as do the less important of their husbands. But MacDonald manages well, brings life to minor characters as few authors can, and has a point will worth making. Down with ugliness!
Rating: *****
February 11th, 2025 at 3:20 pm
An early “major” novel by JDM, published after he had made his chops with best-selling paperback originals and before Travis McGee made him a household name. Big, sprawling, and effectively written, it still could not hold my attention as well as his earlier stuff. Don’t get me wrong; it’s a darned good book — but just not JDM great.
February 11th, 2025 at 3:27 pm
I strongly suspect that you have the right of it. I also wonder how well it would stand up today, or has it become horrendously dated? It’s well written, and I gave it five stars (out of five) back then. Would I still today? I don’t know.
February 11th, 2025 at 5:04 pm
I started this one but never finished it.
February 12th, 2025 at 6:59 am
My 50+ year old impression mirrors Jerry’s. JDM would be dismayed that things have gotten even worse in Florida since then.
February 14th, 2025 at 11:54 pm
JDM in John O’Hara novelistic mode meaning this one is more a study of character and commentary on Florida, ecology, politics, and human nature than suspense novel. One of JDM’s more ambitious works, but not as tight as his suspense novels.
February 16th, 2025 at 4:03 am
Haven’t read the paperback but I’ve (partially) seen some kind of PBS or HBO version of it starring the interesting actor, Richard Jordan. Well-done atmosphere.
February 16th, 2025 at 11:21 am
I don’t know much about the film, but according to IMDb, it did make its TV debut on PBS. I’ve added some basic info to the credits at the top of the review.
February 19th, 2025 at 1:17 am
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Flash_of_Green suggests that the AMERICAN PLAYHOUSE folks bought it for PBS runs in ’86, after an art house run in theaters in ’84.
I’m startled to not recall it, as both a MacDonald and AMERICAN PLAYHOUSE fan.
February 22nd, 2025 at 4:29 am
I’m with ya there. America Masters and American Playhouse were extraordinary bang-for-the-buck value.
Well literally, no-bucks-at-all as it was all of course, free over the airwaves.
I swear I envy that world of rooftop antennae better than the one we’ve got now.
Just more exciting somehow –more spontaneous. You would disobey Thy Parental Units and sneak some way to stay up late, by hook or by crook. Roll the TV into your room and huddle in front of it. Not knowing what one might find –no program guides, no program schedules –just flip through the channels. Accidentally stumble across hordes of hidden gems.
The PBS affiliate who’s broadcast coverage encompassed my little town, geez –provided me with countless Brit-based treasures. Thames Productions, Granada Productions, ITC Productions. I greedily glommed it all down.
McGoohan in ‘Danger Man’ or ‘The Prisoner’. ‘Pennies from Heaven’ with Bob Hoskins, ‘The Charmer’, ‘Reilly’, and (still my all-time #1 fave, ‘The Singing Detective’.
Vincent Price hosting ‘Mystery!’; Alistair Cooke hosting ‘Masterpiece Theater’.
American Playhouse and American Masters: Robin Williams in ‘Seize the Day’, James Whitmore in ‘All My Sons’. Big Greg Peck in ‘Painting Churches’. Tommy Lee Jones in ‘Cat on a Hot Tin Roof’.
Huge influence. I can’t even recall everything I scarfed down. Its all buried in my subconscious at this point.
February 23rd, 2025 at 3:18 am
My posts aren’t appearing. Am I on some kind of blacklist? Why aren’t my remarks being logged anymore? Halp
February 23rd, 2025 at 11:56 am
Well, this one showed up just fine, and so did some later ones from you. I’ll check the blog’s spam folder to see if any ended up there.
ADDED LATER: You were right. Not about the blacklist, but I’m sure glad you said something. I found 2 or 3 of your recent comments in the spam file, from which I have retrieved them. All is well!