Fri 7 Mar 2025
ROSS MACDONALD – Sleeping Beauty. Lew Archer #17 (of 18). Alfred A. Knopf, hardcover, March 1973. Bantam, paperback; 1st printing thus, May 1974. Reprinted many times since.
One of the later books in the series, and to my mind, not one of the better ones. Archer meets a young woman against a backdrop of a huge oil slick off the southern California coast. She is married but distraught, not only because of the disaster, but the oil company responsible for the damage is owned by her parents and other members of her family.
After he takes her home with him, she leaves with a massive amount of sleeping pills along with her. And then disappears completely. Archer is hired by her husband to help find her, but matters are complicated by a ransom note received by her family. Is it real, or is it a fake? A scheme designed for revenge. For the money? Is she part of her disappearance herself?
This is something that has happened in the past, several years earlier. It is part of her makeup. Part of her history.
The opening is fine. It’s the investigation Archer undertakes that follows this that struggles to match it. The woman has a large, complicated family, and there is a lot of baggage that has accumulated over the years. Archer’s job: to make his way through all the physical and mental debris that has piled up, including murder, questioning everyone as he goes, driving from family member to family member to near exhaustion.
There is not much action. This is adult stuff. It is also a book I had not read until now, but I’m sure if I had read it earlier, a lot of what Archer brings out into the light of day would have been over my head, in terms of having experienced anything similar. I would have been too young. And then there’s this. The back story, as revealed, is not as interesting even now as it should have been. A list of characters and who they are would have helped.
But, and I am still trying to work out how this is true, the story is compelling. There’s plenty of guilt to spread around, and that includes that caused directly by the killer. My greatest wish is that I’d rather have had the killer’s identity come out as something other than an anti-climax.
March 7th, 2025 at 10:01 pm
I found this one a big disappointment, I know Macdonald’s health and mental state were failing and it is surprising the book is as good as it is, but it contains every flaw of the Archer books and few of the virtues including the crystalline pieces of prose.
I have my problems with Macdonald, but I wish I hadn’t read this one. I would rather have remembered him at his best and not have this my final exposure to his work.
March 7th, 2025 at 10:11 pm
David is right. SLEEPING BEAUTY is a disappointment. I’m guessing Macdonald’s health and dementia affected the writing of the book. As bad as it is, we can all go back and read THE GALTON CASE or THE CHILL to remind us of how great a writer he was in his prime.
March 8th, 2025 at 12:10 am
I liked this novel but then again the entire Lew Archer series is a big favorite with me. This week’s New Yorker has an interesting article on Ross Macdonald.
March 8th, 2025 at 12:46 am
I had more trouble with this one than I expected to when I started it, and I think my review showed how I struggled with it. It’s not a horrible book, but I think if this was the only book Macdonald wrote about Lew Archer, both of them would be all but forgotten today.
March 12th, 2025 at 2:01 pm
I’ve definitely read part of this book, but I’m not certain that I finished it. Now, though, your review has reignited my curiosity! Even if it isn’t the best of the series, I think I’ll give it another look.
One question: which books in the series do you consider the best? I’ve already read The Moving Target, The Drowning Pool and The Zebra-Striped Hearse.
March 13th, 2025 at 7:48 pm
Dominic,
I don’t have a best of list for Macdonald, but I can highly recommend these three: “The Ivory Grin”, “The Chill” and “The Doomsters”. ALL Ross Macdonald books are good as far as I’m concerned. Enjoy!!
March 14th, 2025 at 2:09 pm
Excellent! Thanks, Paul. I’ll definitely give those a look.
March 14th, 2025 at 3:28 pm
I think most folks would say he hit his apex starting with The Galton Case and continued to write similarly great ‘lost youth’ mysteries thru The Goodbye Look. Millar says he had some sort of epiphany writing the Doomsters which he took forward in the books that followed. It was at that point that he kind of comes into his own and out of Chandler’s shadow. For some ‘favorite McDonald’ opinions, see: https://www.januarymagazine.com/features/lindkvist.html