Sat 19 Jul 2025
Diary Review: ROBERT L. FISH – Always Kill a Stranger.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews[4] Comments
ROBERT L. FISH – Always Kill a Stranger. Captain Jose Da Silva #6. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, hardcover, 1967. Berkley X1511, paperback, February 1968. Foul Play Press, paperback, 1998.
Captain Jose Da Silva of the Brazilian police and his friend Wilson, US assignee to Interpol in Brazil, combine to thwart the planned assassination of a diplomat attending a conference of the OAS.
The relationship between the two men, friendly, humorous, and occasionally antagonistic, is the most satisfying part of the book. Most pertinent, perhaps, is their agreement to disagree on the merits of the CIA, and American efforts on foreign policy in general. As a member of the US Embassy in Brazil, however, Wilson has the opportunity of meeting and recognizing various types of ugly American. Indeed, what Brazil needs from the US is more Wilson.
The surprise ending is dependent on the previously unknown [WARNING; Plot Alert.] of a brother who looks very much like the intended victim. Deducible, I suppose. [End Plot Alert.] The incompetence of several members of the Brazilian police, though probably realistic, on at least two occasions allows the assassination plot to head on to a climax undisturbed.
Rating: ***½
July 20th, 2025 at 2:03 pm
Just by chance, I just came across a couple Robert L. Fish books I hadn’t read yet. I’ve read several of Fish’s books over the years, but my favorites are: The Incredible Schlock Homes (1965) and The Memoirs of Schlock Homes (1974).
July 20th, 2025 at 2:41 pm
Ah, yes. Fish I think is today on the verge of being forgotten as an author, unjustly so, but his Schlock Homes stories will be what he’ll be most remembered for, and for some time to come. At least I hope so. They’re wonderful.
July 26th, 2025 at 10:51 pm
It is hard to remember today what an impact this series had in its day. da Silva and Wilson were among the most popular tec teams of that era.
The books hold up well reread today, suspenseful, fast paced, and smart with attractive leads who are believable within their milieu.
I’m a bigger fan of Fish’s Kek Huygens and Shclok Homes, but I always enjoyed da Silva and Wilson.
July 28th, 2025 at 2:51 pm
Fish never quite reached the following that Queen, Christie, Stout and others had, but I think he was as good a writer, if not better in many ways, than all of them. It’s really too bad he’s so well forgotten today.