Tue 12 Aug 2025
Reviewed by Dan Stumpf: WILLIAM L. SHIRER – The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich.
Posted by Steve under Reviews[13] Comments
WILLIAM L. SHIRER – The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. Simon & Schuster, hardcover, 17 October 1960. TV adaptation: ABC, 1968, consisting of a one-hour episode aired each night over three nights.
I’m anticipating here.
See August is the end of Summer, and that got me to thinking of September. Which is the month before October. (Check your calendars.) Which is the month I spend reading scary books and watching old monster movies.
And that got me thinking about an Autumn a few years back, when I led into it….
(Cue harp.)
…by reading William L. Shirer’s classic The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich , a real mega-book when it first came out – I remember it was serialized in Life, there were TV shows, bubble-gum cards, tie-in comics, etc. – and it’s easy to see why: More’n fifteen hundred pages and scarcely a clunker in the bunch. Well, I admit to skimming over some of the background on Hitler’s grandparents, but by and mostly this is a compulsive page-turner, even if the title gives away the ending.
What’s Halloween-scariest, though, is the first third, describing Hitler’s rise to power: how he subtly smeared his rivals with racist tactics, arranged to have opposing parties disenfranchised, convinced Parliament to give up its oversight powers, and the people to abridge their civil liberties in the name of National Security; filled the media with scare stories about threats from Poland and Czechoslovakia… one either sees the parallels or never will, but what impressed me is that you and I read about these antics and say, “I don’t wanna do that stuff if Hitler did it,” but apparently some people read this and say, “Hot dang! That’s slicker’n a toad in a out-house! I gotta try that….
I guess Real Life gets scary too.
August 13th, 2025 at 6:24 am
The Third Reich fell? Has anyone told Trump?
August 13th, 2025 at 8:10 am
Theodore Adorno said: “Hitler has imposed a new categorical imperative upon humanity in the state of their unfreedom: to arrange their thinking and conduct, so that Auschwitz never repeats itself, so that nothing similar ever happen again”.
I’ve never been able to figure how prezactly I’m supposed to arrange my thinking and conduct, except to try to exercise humility, try not to impose upon others, to respect where they’re coming from, and admit my own frailties and ignorance. And to oppose authoritarianism in all its forms.
August 13th, 2025 at 11:01 am
I was under the strong impression that politics were unwelcome here.
August 13th, 2025 at 11:31 am
You are correct. I plan for this to be a one time exception, with comments welcome from all.
August 13th, 2025 at 5:12 pm
Amen, a non-denominational / generic amen, to #3 and #4.
August 13th, 2025 at 8:27 pm
Politics?
I’m trying to remember when I first wrote this. I know it was for DAPA-EM, which dates it as probably sometime in the “W” administration.
Perhaps some things are in the eye of the Beholder?
August 14th, 2025 at 1:33 pm
Steve,
Your blog and James Reasoner blog are the only
two blogs I have read almost every day for at least 15 years.This is because both blogs are about subjects I have loved since I was a teenager and they have avoided things like politics and everyone could enjoy common interests.
No matter what Dan says I don’t think there can be any question his review is a blatant political statement as well as is Jerry’s comment.
I strongly agree with Barry Lane’s and Bill Kelly’s comments. I as well I am sure most readers of your blog do not come here to discuss politics. There many places we can go to do that and in fact I do that every day. But it is out of place here.
Steve, I have two questions for you. Why was Dan’s review posted without a note that by his own statement it was at least 20 years old? Second, you said you made a one time exception in this case. I think you owe an explanation to your loyal readers as to why you did so.
Now don’t get me wrong, I have enjoyed both Dan’s and Jerry’s reviews and comments for many many years and will continue to do so in the future. I just feel their statements have no place on this blog.
Laris bullock
August 14th, 2025 at 2:36 pm
Hi Laris,
Good to hear from you. I think, after some consideration, I will leave things as they are. I hope you’ll keep coming back, though, and for some time to come. And feel free to object, if you ever again think that things have done gone wrong.
August 14th, 2025 at 2:33 pm
I agree with Laris Bullock’s comment above in every detail and despise the big shot whining of Jerry House, and sink Dan into the ignore phase,disagree entirely, and I’m completely disgusted.
Love and kisses.
August 15th, 2025 at 9:55 am
I view this site as an oasis in the desert. I thank you for all your efforts. If a book has a political element, fair game to comment, but there are so many websites covering the day to day, nasty, political dustups.
August 17th, 2025 at 12:16 am
Shirer is a high-quality source for info on Hitler; his account is an academic-level reference suitable for many purposes. It’s also very readable.
If memory serves, he was either one of “Murrow’s boys” or from some other rival broadcasting team. Anyway, he was feet-on-the-ground; his narrative is rife with fine-grain details.
Shirer’s juggernaut is worth combining with ‘The World at War’ narrated by Olivier.
Nevertheless (save for the Anti-Semitism) Hitler was hardly the first despot to wield his particularly odious tactics.
Cleon of Athens is one of the earliest:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleon
Adorno was himself, a fine thinker. One of his themes was to urge our distrust of all programmed popular culture including newspapers. Similar stance as Antonio Gramsci.
August 17th, 2025 at 1:18 am
Hitler’s anti-Semitism was not just a personal preference; he murdered those people by the million, so let us be careful how we use this bastard’s name as a reference point.
August 23rd, 2025 at 3:54 am
My copy sits directly across from me as I type on my reference shelf.