Tue 29 Mar 2011
Please stand by…. // R. I. P., H. R. F. KEATING
Posted by Steve under Obituaries / Deaths Noted , Personal Notes[28] Comments
I don’t know what caused it but I had a massive muscle spasm in my right hip Sunday morning, bad enough for us to call an ambulance to take me to the emergency room around 3 pm. They assumed it was a fracture but all of the tests, Xray, MRI and Catscan, were negative.
They finally found a medication that killed the pain, and I came home around 5 pm Monday. The pain is still mostly gone and for the most part I can get around, but I’m still too light-headed to do more than post this message to the blog. I’m using my wife’s downstairs computer. I can’t maneuver my way to my upstairs study where mine is. (We live in a split level house.)
I see that a lot of discussion is still going on following last week’s posts, especially the one about the Mannix TV show that Michael Shonk wrote up, but I don’t imagine I’ll be able to post anything new for the next few days. The visiting nurse made her first visit about 30 minutes ago, and I’ll be making a trip to our chiropractor this afternoon, I hope.
I’ll have to see if there’s as easy way from me to read my email from here. My wife uses gmail or hotmail, and I don’t. I’ll probably have to add updates to this post to stay in touch.
[UPDATE] 03-30-11. Here’s the culprit, clinically speaking: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piriformis_muscle
Located in men right where your billfold sits in your back packet. I don’t know if a possible cause is having too many bills in your wallet, but since that’s hardly ever true in my case, chances are slim that’s what happened to me. I have pills to take, and they seem to work, but the basic cure seems to be rest. And if something I do causes pain, then stop doing it.
Moving laterally is my biggest problem, which makes getting to my computer upstairs still too tough to do. Right now there’s only a narrow passageway up the stairs and into the room. I’ll be careful and not try to overdo anything I shouldn’t.
Thanks for all the good wishes. This was my first overnight stay in a hospital, though it was only in the Emergency Room. My problem seems awfully minor after seeing the incoming patients and listening to them talk to the the doctors and nurses in the cubicle next door. Everything seemed crowded and chaotic at first, but after a while it was still crowded and chaotic — but under control. The staff seemed to know exactly what they were doing.
David, I think it was you who asked about the MRI exam. It was full body one in a narrow closed tube, though open at both ends. They handed me a bulb to press if I experienced any kind of problem. It took me less than five seconds to press the bulb. It took a small sedative to get me through that. If that hadn’t worked, I think they were ready to use one of the conks on the head that knocked Mannix out every so often.
The blog will be back in business by this weekend, I’m sure, if not before. Thanks again for all the cheer and goodwill!
[UPDATE #2] 03-31-11. R.I.P. H.R.F.KEATING (1926-2011). See Comment #20 and David Vineyard’s tribute to one of the Giants of the world of mystery and crime fiction, followed briefly by one of my own.
March 29th, 2011 at 9:59 am
Steve,
Please take it easy. Get well soon!
Mike
March 29th, 2011 at 10:13 am
I second Mr. Grost’s comment. And our thoughts are with you.
March 29th, 2011 at 10:37 am
I’m going in today for x-rays on my back.
Even though my back is very sore, I can’t even imagine what you are going through.
I agree with Mike Grost and David, please get a LOT better soon.
March 29th, 2011 at 10:59 am
What they said. Be well.
March 29th, 2011 at 11:08 am
Get better and don’t worry about us. We don’t mind waiting, we wouldn’t be here without you. So don’t rush, get healthy first.
March 29th, 2011 at 11:14 am
Wishing you a speedy recovery, Steve. There is nothing more humiliating than an injury that renders you practically immobile.
Take it easy.
March 29th, 2011 at 11:16 am
Mine did something similar about sixteen years ago. I was just getting out of a chair when suddenly I went to the floor. A couple of months of Percodan and therapy later (you can learn to hate a medicine ball but the ice and heat are nice) I went under the knife — only to find I had a spinal defect I was born with and they didn’t catch until I was in my forties.
The good news is I came out of surgery feeling much better than I went in. The bad news is I am still plagued with a bad back — had a spell that only ended mid week last week. Even though I only use them rarely I keep my handy dandy walking sticks where I can get to them quickly.
There is more they can do other than surgery today, but if it does go to that it still beats the pain. The bad thing is living with it until they can stop it or reduce it.
Most of the time it is a minor irritation to an annoying ache, but you do sometimes ‘hit the wall’ as I call it — the point when something has to give and you can’t push beyond it. Then all you can do is take the meds, follow the instructions, and hope it gets better soon.
With any luck you will find fairly quick relief and they will spot the underlying cause. Until then try not to worry too much.
The other good thing is when you are in that much pain you probably don’t have to worry about getting addicted to the pain killers. They burn through your system pretty clean when the pain is bad enough. It’s managing chronic pain that causes the problem.
Whatever you do, try not to sneeze.
I had my surgery ten days before I got married, and stood up in the church with ten inches of wire still holding my spine together. It still felt better than that spasm.
Bless you and try not to worry. As the urologist said of the kidney stone — this too will pass.
But I will confess the only pain in my life that came anywhere near it was the cluster headaches I had most of my adult life (called suicide headaches because a third of all sufferers kill themselves over the pain) — that’s pretty high on the pain scale. I’ve broken bones, had a four inch bolt through my leg, and was once cut in a knife fight and none of it compared to that back spasm.
March 29th, 2011 at 12:11 pm
My wishes to you for a quick and complete recovery, Steve.
Cheers,
Jeff
March 29th, 2011 at 12:28 pm
Take care, Steve!
March 29th, 2011 at 5:45 pm
Like everyone else, my best wishes for you, Steve.
March 29th, 2011 at 6:11 pm
Oh, I am so sorry to hear this. Hope by the time you read this, it is gone.
March 29th, 2011 at 7:23 pm
Very much better luck to you, Steve. As with David, I had something similar happen to me in my forties, which in this case was two years ago (and I’m still in my 40s)…I suddenly found myself at my office unable to walk without assistance or stand very long likewise…which was a serious drag inasmuch as I had worked till I was nearly alone in the building (it was a Very painful slow walk to the elevator). Happily, we still had a good man working security at that time, one Howard Ford, and between him and my best friend Alice Chang we were able to get me out to her car…I bought a cane that evening. I’m not even sure to this day what the trouble was, but it hasn’t recurred after a few days of cane-dependency…I did suspect it was keyed to my body recuperating from a week of gall-bladder blockage and fairly consistent bed-rest shortly beforehand.
May yours be at least as transient as mine, and as unique in your experience as mine has been in mine.
March 29th, 2011 at 9:06 pm
Steve:
Have had back trouble for the past twenty odd years. A couple of years ago, I fell and broke my hip. That started to heal nicely, but was knocked down again. Nothing broken,but every muscle pulled. Now get around with a cane which is better than not getting around. No rush on getting back to the blog. Just get better.
Best,
Victor
March 30th, 2011 at 1:03 am
I’ll add my best wishes. Keep us updated on your situation, when you can.
March 30th, 2011 at 2:57 am
Steve
When you are well enough, did you do open or closed MRI? I only ask, because when you are in spasm to begin with getting on that cold hard table and riding through that tube while the machince bangs and pings like you left your spiked tennis shoes in the dryer is a unique experience when accompanied by pain.
All accompanied by the operator, well away from the danger, telling you to be still, don’t move, and just relax, because nothing is more relaxing than being entombed in an iron lung for twenty minutes while it rattles and bangs like Tuesday morning trash pick up.
Normally I’m not claustraphobic, but after about a quarter of an hour I was reconsidering being cremated instead of buried.
The CT scan is bad enough, but at least it doesn’t sound like a car that’s driving on tin cans.
On top of which I’m 6’2″ and weighed about 225 at the time — an experience that makes you appreciate how toothpaste must feel going into the tube.
All I could think of despite the pain, was thank God it’s not my head in there.
March 30th, 2011 at 5:20 am
Getting old is a bitch. Recently I went through an ordeal while the medical profession tried to figure out what the hell was wrong with me. Blood work, CAT scan, MRI, stress test on the treadmill, lung tests in some type of $64,000 glass booth, inhalers, etc. So many tests, I’ve forgotten some.
Finally, I’ve decided no more tests. My problem is I’m getting older and like an old car or an old book, things start to go wrong. I wish you luck Steve. If I see you at Windy City Pulp Convention in Chicago, I’ll know you feel better.
March 30th, 2011 at 10:59 am
Steve:
Allow me to join all the other well-wishers in hoping that you soon feel better and that you may be up to returning to your daily schedule with Mystery*File.
Speedy Recovery,
Tise
March 30th, 2011 at 1:24 pm
Dear Steve ,
take ALL the time that is necessary for your recovery !
You have accumulated such a wealth of fascinating info over the years ,that waits to be read ,and reread !
So- no sense in hurrying, what needs time-get well , THAT is the imortant thing.
Best wishes, looking forward to hear about your recovery
THE DOC
March 30th, 2011 at 2:03 pm
Just concentrate on getting better. Mystery*File and all of the regulars will all be there when you get back.
All the best.
March 31st, 2011 at 5:02 am
I don’t think Steve will mind, but while he is away I’m going to post some news here, though many of you may already know — H.R.F. Keating reportedly died on March 27th.
Aside from his fine novels both about Inspector Ghote and not, he was a noted genre critic, and his thin little books on the social background of the Golden Age, MURDER MUST APPETIZE is one of the most attractive and entertaining books of its kind ever printed, filled with wonderful reprints of period illustrations and Keating’s always canny observations.
Simply one of the most important critical voices of the genre, and a charming and enteraining writer as well, he will be missed.
March 31st, 2011 at 11:42 am
This is sad news. I don’t think that Keating was nearly as well known in the US as he should have been, but David’s last paragraph summarizes his achievements in the field to a T.
My favorite of his Ghote books was The Body in the Billiard Room, which takes numerous good-natured jabs at the conventions of the Golden Age of Detection novel — Agatha Christie in particular, as I recall. But before the solution is revealed, Keating also adds some modern takes on the detective novel in terms of setting, characters and solid everyday police work.
As I say, it’s one of my favorites of Keating’s work, but I haven’t read more than a handful of others. If anyone has another one you’d like to recommend, please do.
David mentioned MURDER MUST APPETIZE (1975), and it’s as wonderful a way to spend several hours reading your way through as he says. Other books by Keating that everyone reading this blog should have easy access to, if not own outright are:
Writing Crime Fiction (1986; 1994)
Crime and Mystery: the 100 Best Books (1987)
The Bedside Companion to Crime (1989)
These are absolutely must have’s. Keating knew detective and mystery fiction inside and out. His was the voice of a giant in the field.
March 31st, 2011 at 11:43 am
Happy to read you are feeling better, Steve.
Classic era mystery fans have much to be depressed about this week. While not as sad as David’s news in #20, Disney has casted Jennifer Garner (age 38) as Miss Marple. The Christie estate is not pleased.
March 31st, 2011 at 1:06 pm
Michael
I’d be horrified if I wasn’t laughing so hard. I suppose she can’t be much farther from Christie’s creation than the marvelous Margaret Rutherford was, save I have no hope that Ms Garner is a comic genius. Miss Marple doing kung fu — those high kicks are going to be hell in those long tight skirts.
Still, you can never tell. Robert Downey turned out to be a splendid Sherlock Holmes and Seth Rogan at least doesn’t look bad as the Green Hornet.
But Jennifer Garner as Miss Marple? I guess with the trial and all Lindsay Lohan wasn’t available.
Even with Garner in the role I’m not sure I’m ready for a nude Miss Marple.
Next thing you know they’ll announce Charlie Sheen as Ellery Queen.
Steve
Glad to hear from you. I know what you mean about lateral movement. Been there, couldn’t do that.
Mine wasn’t caused by the weight of my wallet either. Still a pinched nerve or bad disc can send pain anywhere south from the hip to the big toe. Most of the time they go away with rest.
You were lucky to be home when it happened. A friend was hit while at the grocery store and went to the floor right there. They had to sedate him to even get him in the ambulance. The only way I got to the doctor without one when mine happened was that my Continental had bucket seats and the passenger side let all the way down flat. Otherwise I could not have gotten in the car.
I made it through the MRI in one go, but only by telling myself that I wasn’t going to do this again, and if I just kept calm it would be over. I have to say it wasn’t too convincing and a conk on the head would have been welcome.
But at least we know literally what it feels like in a clothes dryer. My first wife once accidentally turned the dishwasher on with the cat in it (he was wet but fine — only in there long enough to yowl when the first water hit him)— after the MRI I had tremdous sympathy for him. Only the hot water was missing.
March 31st, 2011 at 2:44 pm
Due to my health problems (I’ll spare you the details) I have had several MRIs and MRAs. My favorite was for the brain. I am claustrophobic only if my face is covered. Inside the machine there was a video screen showing outdoor landscapes. It got me through it.
The doctor said I had lost only 20 percent of my brain function. He said it was not an important 20 percent (and I hear David saying, “Well, that explains everything.”).
March 31st, 2011 at 4:10 pm
Michael
Never. I wouldn never argue/discuss with anyone I didn’t respect. Besides, half the time I’m likely only operating on 20% of brain function. At least 80% of yours is working, and that still puts us both ahead of some folks who are in the single digits.
And don’t think I pick on you. You just happen to make intriguing points that are worth discussing.
I suppose a nice screen and movies would have helped in the MRI, but a later one in an open MRI was a much more pleasant experience. It still sounds like the inside of cement mixer though.
Did the open CT scan too, you ride through a ring on a sort of conveyer belt. Felt awfully Star Trek. I half expected DeForrest Kelley to show up with a Tricorder.
March 31st, 2011 at 5:31 pm
Steve
Re Keating FILMI FILMI INSPECTOR GHOTE has the additional pleasure of being about Bollywood.
INSPECTOR GHOTE MOVES ON was adapted by the series STORYTELLER and Ghote featured in the 1988 movie THE PERFECT MURDER (played by Nasrudeen Shah). Another novel HUNT FOR THE PEACOCK was adapted for DETECTIVE and Keating wrote the screenplay for the Christopher Lee/Patrick McNee film SHERLOCK HOLMES AND THE LEADING LADY.
In addition Keating’s work has been adapted on BBC 4 Extra (formerly BBC 7). He also appeared as himself on AGATHA CHRISTIE: CRIME DOES PAY and CRIME WRITERS.
His 100 BEST CRIME AND MYSTERY NOVELS is one of the best such books in the genre. His short intelligent defense for each book he choose are literate and well balanced even when I didn’t always agree with the choices. I think I’ve read all but five of the books, and of those I’ve read other books by the writers.
He is also fair in that he gives equal weight to the classics, the Golden Age, hard boiled, crime, and suspense novels.
March 31st, 2011 at 6:16 pm
Steve,
Sending good (and hopefully healing!) thoughts your way…
April 3rd, 2011 at 8:21 pm
I may as well say that I wish you well or you may think I don’t care. I have my physical problems, but after all I have read here I don’t think I’m doing too badly at that! Really sorry to hear about Keating’s death.