Sun 14 Mar 2010
A Movie Review by Walter Albert: THANKS FOR EVERYTHING (1938).
Posted by Steve under Films: Comedy/Musicals , Reviews[2] Comments
THANKS FOR EVERYTHING. 20th Century Fox, 1938. Jack Haley, Jack Oakie, Adolphe Menjou, Arleen Whelan, Binnie Barnes, Tony Martin, George Barbier, Warren Hymer, Renie Riano. Songs: Mack Gordon and Harry Revel; photography: Lucien Andriot. Director: William A. Seiter. Shown at Cinecon 45, Hollywood CA, September 2009.
In this engaging satire of American mores, Jack Haley is a small-town nobody who wins first prize in a national radio contest in which his answers to 100 questions on his preferences for a variety of products establish him as “Mr. Average American.”
However, Menjou, head of the company that promoted the contest, in collaboration with his flunky (played by jack Oakie), concocts a scheme to disqualify Haley and then hire him at a small salary to test products for their appeal to the average man, a ploy that’s an over-the-top success for Menjou and his newly-formed company, Guidance Inc.
As you might suspect, the plan begins to unravel, with Menjou and Oakie forced to increasingly desperate measures to keep Haley in the dark, leading to an attempt to make Haley declare himself for or against going to war that culminates in the simulation of an enemy attack on New York City.
This pushes Haley into the war camp but also precipitates a series of escalating farcical scenes that lead to a triumph for Haley that is an uncanny foreshadowing of Preston Sturges’ Hail the Conquering Hero.
The film has real comic bite, and the cast is uniformly superb, with a stand-out performance by Renie Riano as Haley’s stand-in telephone girl friend.
March 15th, 2010 at 3:22 am
The plot reminds me a bit of MAGIC TOWN with James Stewart as a pollster who finds the perfect average American town and tries to keep the locals from discovering he’s using them for his national polls.
The highlight of that one is Stewart and Jane Wyman doing a spirited and increasingly frantic reading of Tennyson’s ‘Charge of the Light Brigade.’ You’ll never watch the Errol Flynn version the same way again.
This one sounds like fun. Hollywood never seemed to quite figure out what to do with Haley. This being made in 1938 I assume that it’s too early to have been influenced by the Orson Welles WAR OF THE WORLDS fiasco (October ’38) in regard to the ‘invasion’ of New York, but it is interesting historically how common that theme was in this period.
Both OPERATOR #5 and the DAN FOWLER G-MAN series featured almost monthly invasions from the outside or hordes of home grown fanatics marching on the capital. War scare paranoia was even greater than post 9/11 terror scares. Thought not exactly unjustified. My family said rumors of German u-boats in Houston bay were constant — and turned out later to often have been true.
August 27th, 2025 at 9:22 pm
Thanks!
I’m not seeing it at YouTube or Internet Archive.
I was wondering, from the description, if it took a stand against American involvement in WWII, under the influence of America First.
From your description, no.