Tue 31 Aug 2021
Reviews by L. J. Roberts
HARLAN COBEN – Win. Grand Central Publishing, hardcover, March 2021.
First Sentence: The shot that will decide the championship is slowly arching its way toward the basket.
Billionaire friend of the author’s Myron Bolitar character, Windsor Horne Lockwood III is taken to the tower apartment of a hoarder who has been murdered. While one can barely move in the main room, the victim’s bedroom is immaculate with minimal contents. However, there is a Vermeer painting that had been stolen from the Lockwoods, and a bespoke leather suitcase bearing the Lockwood family crest and Win’s initials.
Both the painting and the suitcase had been missing since Win’s cousin, Patricia, had been kidnapped, yet escaped, more than 20 years ago. The apartment murder victim was behind a group of 70s domestic terrorists, some of whom are still free. The FBI, and Win, would like to find them.
As the psychopathic sidekick to best friend Myron Bolitar, Win was intriguing. As the protagonist, he’s just boring. By the nature of his character, he’s an empty shell mimicking a functional person. In that, Cohen succeeded in creating his character. However, as a reader, it is not enough.
The narcissistic recitation of his wealth, art, cars, planes, suits, guns, knowledge of martial arts disciplines, is eye-rolling. It soon becomes apparent his family is as psychotic as he is. Yes, he has one slight crack of humanity; but even that threatens to be a continuation of his dysfunctional family line.
As for the Jane Street Six, those of us who lived through the years of the SLA, etc., don’t need to be reminded, especially when we now have the Oath Keepers, Proud Boys, QAnon, etc. It may have been Coben’s attempt to make the plot current but, with many being on overload, it just doesn’t work.
Win is a book most readers will probably enjoy. Some, however, may find themselves not caring enough to do more than skim through.
Rating: NR (Not Recommended)
August 31st, 2021 at 8:32 pm
Big selling writer, certainly he has many fans,just not me.
August 31st, 2021 at 10:05 pm
I’ve always meant to read one of his Bolitar stories, but so far I just haven’t. His standalones have never interested me.
September 1st, 2021 at 6:19 am
How does a psychopath – even a billionaire psychopath – have any friends?
September 1st, 2021 at 8:16 am
I agree 100%! Nice one, L.J. I loved the Myron Bolitar books and Win was always fun when he’d pop in and do his thing, but I had to give up on this one less than 50 pages in. L.J. nailed it – it was just boring.
Maybe Harlan is just too tied up with all his European television work, or maybe you just can’t go home again, but even fans will hate this one.
September 1st, 2021 at 6:34 pm
Posting a negative review is never fun, and I always hesitate about posting a negative review. But then I feel certain there are others who felt as I did so, perhaps, confirmation would be good. Thank you, Jeff, for confirming that.
September 1st, 2021 at 6:39 pm
I wonder if Robert Crais had the same issue when he used Joe Pike as the lead and not Elvis Cole? Pike was the same, no personality side kick who did alot of the dirty work, but not sure he could carry a whole book.
September 1st, 2021 at 6:41 pm
I’ve been wondering that, too. I’ve not read any of Crais’s books in which Pike was the lead character, but the ones he’s been in with Cole, I feel the same as you.