Fri 9 May 2014
A Western Movie Review by Jonathan Lewis: LAST TRAIN FROM GUN HILL (1959).
Posted by Steve under Reviews , Western movies[10] Comments
LAST TRAIN FROM GUN HILL. Paramount PIctures, 1959. Kirk Douglas, Anthony Quinn, Carolyn Jones, Earl Holliman, Brad Dexter, Brian Hutton, Ziva Rodann. Screenplay by James Poe, based on a story by Les Crutchfield. Director: John Sturges.
Last Train from Gun Hill is a 1959 Western directed by John Sturges (Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, The Magnificent Seven) with a memorable score by Dimitri Tiomkin (High Noon). It features Kirk Douglas as a U.S. Marshal seeking justice for his murdered Cherokee wife (portrayed by the Israeli actress Ziva Rodann) and Anthony Quinn as a corrupt cattleman whose screw-up of a son is responsible for the horrific crime.
The film, which co-stars Carolyn Jones (The Addams Family) and Earl Holliman (Hotel de Paree), is fairly standard American Western fare. The themes of frontier justice, domestic violence, the rights of Native Americans, and the relationships between fathers and sons all play prominent roles in James Poe’s solid, but not particularly novel, screenplay.
The plot of Last Train from Gun Hill isn’t all that difficult to follow. The film begins with a somewhat lengthy chase scene in which two inebriated cowboys, Rick Belden (Holliman) and Lee (Brian G. Hutton) recklessly chase a wagon driven by a Cherokee mother (Rodann) and her son Petey.
The mother, wanting to protect her son, uses a whip to fend off the attackers, leaving a brutal mark on Rick’s face. But it’s too little, too late. Eventually, the ruffians succeed in driving the two innocents off the road. Although we do not witness the crime directly on screen, it is clear that Rick both rapes and murders the Cherokee mother.
Fortunately, Petey escapes and heads into town where his father, Matt Morgan, (Douglas) is a U.S. Marshal. Morgan rides to the crime scene and finds a horse with a saddle engraved with the initials C.B. He realizes it belongs to his old friend, Craig Belden (Quinn), and Rick’s father who is now a cattle baron in the town of Gun Hill.
Prior to setting out for Gun Hill, Morgan has a brief exchange with his murdered wife’s Native American father, who urges him to seek vengeance and kill the culprit slowly, the “Indian way.” As a lawman, however, Morgan appears more concerned with justice than with revenge.
Making his way to Gun Hill by train, Morgan meets Linda (Jones), Craig Belden’s estranged girlfriend on the trip. Unfortunately, what could have been a more exciting film devolves into a very slow-moving story in which Morgan and his old friend Craig Belden argue, debate, and fight each other over whether or not Morgan is going to bring the son, Rick Belden, to justice.
Problem is: Belden has the whole town of Gun Hill in his back pocket, so it’s not completely clear at the outset how Morgan is going to pull this off. Still, he’s determined that he’s going to be on the 9 PM train out of Gun Hill — the last train out for the day — with Rick Belden and Lee in federal custody.
The movie plods along for a good 45 minutes or so, with an especially lengthy sequence in which Morgan holds a whining Rick Belden captive in a hotel room. Finally, there’s a dramatic scene in which Lee burns down the hotel, forcing Morgan out into the town streets.
The last ten minutes of the film, which features a final, inevitable, showdown between Morgan and Craig Belden, makes up for the fact that not all that much memorable happens for a good part of the film. Indeed, the biggest flaw of Last Train from Gun Hill is in its pacing. There are some scenes that go by far too quickly; others seem to take forever.
In general, Douglas is solid in his portrayal of a U.S. Marshal. Initially, he isn’t particularly convincing as a grieving husband. That changes when he encounters a man in Gun Hill who thoughtlessly insults his deceased wife’s heritage. Indeed, nothing seems to enrage Morgan more than hearing men belittle his wife’s Native American ancestry.
Quinn, on the other hand, seems just a bit out of place in this film. Still, his acting is perfectly fine and he portrays the character of Craig Belden as a man who is both extremely powerful and extremely lonely, a man trapped by his own success.
Last Train from Gun Hill is by no means a work of cinematic excellence. That said, it’s not a bad film. Fans of Kirk Douglas and Anthony Quinn would likely appreciate the two men cast as friends turned rivals. In many ways, it’s a very American film, albeit not an especially cheerful one. It’s a movie about friendship, family, and frontier justice, the type of Western that one might enjoy on a lazy Sunday afternoon.
May 9th, 2014 at 4:05 pm
Anthony Quinn has always seemed to be an actor with some of the same issues as Lee J. Cobb, but in Quinn’s case, instead of gas it manifests itself as acid reflux.
May 10th, 2014 at 5:58 am
Some of Sturges’ westerns are quite enjoyable (BACKLASH, BAD DAY AT BLACK ROCK etc.) but I found this and GUNFIGHT AT THE OK CORRAL surprisingly flabby.
Incidentally, readers here may not be aware that Steve Lewis missed his chance for Western Stardom when jealous co-stars Yul Brynner and Steve McQueen insisted that all his scenes be cut out of a movie that was originally to be called THE MAGNIFICENT EIGHT.
May 10th, 2014 at 7:20 am
Been awhile since I’ve seen GUN HILL and maybe its time for a refresher.
May 10th, 2014 at 10:02 am
Dan, Comment #2
And I thought they were my pals, too!
May 10th, 2014 at 10:06 am
Fans of Old Time Radio will recognize the name of Les Crutchfield, who wrote a ton of radio shows, including one of the best, GUNSMOKE. Not to mention a shorter but almost as impressive list of TV shows, including GUNSMOKE (56 episodes).
May 10th, 2014 at 10:09 pm
Lesser Sturgis, but still worth a viewing. I found Douglas character a bit off putting, since as an actor who specialized in rage, here he veers violently from professionalism to rage for no reason. You expect this to be a revenge fantasy and it turns out to be an unconvincing treatise on law and order. I really didn’t buy that Douglas character didn’t lynch Holliman and burn down the town. Lawmen in the old west tended not to be sticklers about that sort of thing.
Quinn seems to be doing this one for the paycheck, and it was difficult for me to buy Earl Holliman as his son. There was some hanky panky going on somewhere.
This is enjoyable, Sturgis made few bad westerns, but far from his best.
It looks great though.
May 10th, 2014 at 11:14 pm
You’re right about Douglas the more I think about it. At the beginning of the film, Douglas is way too calm for a man who just lost his wife to such an act of of violence. Then, all of a sudden, he gets enraged on the streets of Gun Hill after a man makes a derogatory comment about Native Americans. Then he’s calm again.
Visually, the film can be appealing. Belden’s office and the saloon are very well done sets
May 10th, 2014 at 11:15 pm
Also, Earl Holliman does not seem like Quinn’s son. Not at all.
May 11th, 2014 at 2:07 pm
Generally I have negative thoughts about Sturges. Results matter, and the misses out number the hits, though they are certainly striking and makes you wonder if the auteur theory has any validity. Not much, I say.
February 2nd, 2021 at 11:05 pm
I remember this as an especially dark, gloomy, doom-laden film. Would agree that the emotional arcs of the characters are choppy to the point of incomprehensibility. But it is Sturges, and I did enjoy it.
Admittedly, the plot seems a thinly-disguised compendium of 7 or 8 of the best ‘Gunsmoke’ radio episodes; all these father-son themes are amply harped on in that program. [In truth, I only stumbled over this review because I was looking for mentions of Les Crutchfield. I can see clearly that I can’t tell you anything you all don’t already know about such writers.]
Earl Holliman as a ‘son’ to Anthony Quinn: sure might be somewhat wonky here; but you can see them again in a studio drama called, ‘Hot Spell’ (co-stars Oscar-winner Shirley Booth). A moving and realistic film in my opinion. At least I found it so.